Billie Carlyle (1902-1991) – Of Claude Dampier & Mrs Gibson*

Claude Dampier and Billie Carlyle, in The Adventures of Algy, with, at right, Eric Harrison. A Beamont Smith film, 1925. Photo from the Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.
*Mrs Gibson was an imaginary character in their act.

The Five second version
Twenty-three years after the death of comedian Claude Dampier, his third and final professional and personal partner and an Australian by birth, Billie Carlyle (1902-1991), wrote a memoir entitled Claude Dampier, Mrs Gibson and Me. Self-published and less than 120 pages in length, it provides selected insights into the couple’s life together. However, as is often the case with celebrity memoirs, there are problems in relying too heavily on this one source. There is, for example, compelling evidence that Billie’s unhappy early adulthood coloured some decisions of her later life.[1]See Richard Fotheringham’s 2024 biography of another actor of the same era, Jenny Howard (1902-1996), for a deeper analysis of the extent of these difficulties

Billie (born Doris Ann Davy in South Australia) had started out in variety in 1924. She met Claude on the set of the Australian film The Adventures of Algy (1925). Her collaboration on stage with Claude began soon after, when she became his “feed” – the sensible person whose comments helped set up his jokes. “Petite and sparkling,” Billie was the perfect foil for Claude Dampier’s loud, boorish, lumbering fool or “Professional idiot” character.[2]Daily Telegraph (UK) 1 August 1991 Working in Britain after 1927, Billie and Claude became regulars on BBC radio and Claude an occasional character actor in films. Their collaboration lasted into the early 1950s.

Before Billie Carlyle died in England in 1991, she left a selection of the couple’s personal records to the Australian Performing Arts Collection in Melbourne, Australia.

Above: Billie Carlyle in late 1924.[3]Everyone’s (Aust) 29 Oct, 1924, p40

Left: The author’s well-thumbed copy of Billie Carlyle’s 1978 book. One can only admire her determination to write, publish and sell it. Right: Billie Carlyle, c 1925-6. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre, Melbourne

The background – Claude Dampier comes to Australia in 1910

British comedian Claude Dampier (1878-1955) was 24 years Billie Carlyle’s senior, and was already well established in Australia when she met him in 1925.

He was born Claude Connolly Cowan in London in 1878. He had married fellow British performer Irene Vere (1889-1968)[4]Birth name Eileen Geraldine Thompson in April 1907. The couple had arrived together in Australia on the Orontes in October 1910, with their one year old daughter, Dorothy Dampier (1909-2002).[5]The Register (Adelaide) 12 Oct 1910, p5 They had been contracted to tour Australia with Edward Branscombe’s company, usually known as the Red Dandies. Over the next seven years Claude and Irene appeared on Australasian stages, often presenting original material – monologues, songs and dances, sometimes to remote audiences in small country halls or even in open-air settings. In February 1911, Adelaide’s Evening Journal assured readers that “The Dandies were in splendid form… Mr. Claude Dampier’s delightful absurdities were a feature of the entertainment. Though he is exceptionally funny, he never descends to vulgarity. His items included Singers and Talkers and The Poet… The clever soubrette, Miss Irene Vere, met with her usual favourable reception in songs, which included Mandy’s Christening, The Merry month of May, and Sympathy.”[6]Evening Journal (Adelaide),13 Feb 1911, p2 Billie Carlyle was to claim that one of the first live shows she ever saw in Adelaide was the Dandies featuring Claude Dampier.[7]Carlyle,1978, p1 Perhaps it was this one.

Claude Dampier and his wife and first stage partner, Irene Vere. c1912. Kura Heritage Collections Online, Auckland Libraries. New Zealand. [8]The New Zealand Graphic and Ladies Journal, 10 July 1912, p.22

After almost seven years work in Australia and New Zealand, in early February 1917 Claude and Irene departed for South Africa, where they performed for similarly appreciative colonial audiences. But in late 1919, Irene left Claude, and South Africa, and returned to England to pursue a career on her own.

Irene Vere announces her return to England in 1919 [9]The Stage (London) 19 Dec 1919

Claude teams with Hilda Attenboro.

Claude Dampier returned to Australia from South Africa in September 1921. With him was a new professional partner he had met in South Africa – Hilda Attenboro (1896-1980). [10]Her stage name was also sometimes spelled Attenborough. She had been born in England in 1896 as Alice Hilda Sweet. Of interest, she had appeared in at least three silent films in South Africa in 1918 Hilda was introduced to the Australian press as Claude’s “stage assistant”, however there is no doubt the couple were also romantically involved. In March 1923 in Hawthorn, Victoria, a daughter was born of the union.[11]Victorian Birth Certificate Number 13524 / 1923, 23 March 1923 Dampier and Attenboro claimed on the birth certificate that they had married in Pretoria in 1920, however no records of such a marriage exist.[12]The marriages of South Africa’s white population during this era can be found on Familysearch.com. In these records we can see Hilda had actually married performer Thomas Henry Daniels in South … Continue reading In fact, Dampier and Irene Vere did not divorce until April 1928.[13]National Archives (UK) Divorce Court file J 77/2445/6307 Appellant: Eileen Geraldine Violet Keith Cowan

Claude Dampier and Hilda Attenboro in late 1921, newly arrived in Australia from South Africa.[14]Critic (Adelaide) 7 December 1921, p10 They appeared on the Tivoli circuit, in an act that lasted about 30 minutes.

Most importantly, on his return to Australia, Claude Dampier’s act appears to have evolved. He was now a consistent exponent of the silly ass, Johnnie-type humour,[15]Sunday Times (Sydney)16 Oct 1921, p3 a stereotype of the upper-class, English-twit character that Australians could immediately identify and laugh about. A few weeks after their arrival, Sydney’s Sunday Times was quite explicit about Claude’s character: “One sees in him a creature of birth but no brains, and his well-bred inanities become excruciatingly funny because one feels that they are possible… that somewhere or other in the cold, old country there may be a person who looks like and behaves like this long-nosed idiot of the cheerful grin.“[16]Sunday Times (Sydney) 27 Nov 1921, p17

As Clay Djubal notes, Claude went on to perform with several troupes in the early 1920s, including Pat Hanna’s (1888-1973) Famous Diggers.

Undated post-war cartoon by Frank Dunne. The English officer bears an uncanny resemblance to Claude Dampier’s character – which had become a well established stereotype in Australia, and continues to this day.
The Australian War Memorial

During 1924 Dampier appeared in a film for Beaumont Smith (1885-1950), featuring his well established stage character. Hullo Marmaduke saw Dampier playing an English “remittance man” [17]The Oxford reference guide describes a remittance man as typically a disgraced man of good position or family who has been sent abroad by his family and whose payments depend on his remaining there who seems to have been born with the proverbial silver spoon in his mouth and a monocle firmly screwed in his eye.[18]The Advertiser (Adelaide) 15 Dec 1924, p11

Claude Dampier as “the perfect ass” in Hullo Marmaduke (1924) [19]Everyone’s (Aust) 19 Nov 1924, p11

The success of this encouraged Beaumont Smith to make a second film with Dampier the following year – entitled The Adventures of Algy. On this film a young Australian actress named Billie Carlyle also had a role. Fortunately, this film has survived.

The Title card and trick opening shot of Beaumont Smith’s The Adventures of Algy (1925). Dampier turns and makes his famous grotesque monocled leer to the camera. [20]This film survives but is difficult to source. These screen grabs are from the documentary A History of Australian Cinema, Part Two, The Passionate Industry 1920-1930, available from Umbrella … Continue reading

Billie Carlyle and Claude, 1925-1955

“MRS. DORIS KELLY. WHO IS MISSING. Mrs. Kelly left on January 16 for a holiday in the eastern States, but for six weeks no news has been received from her.”[21]Mail (Adelaide) 1 March 1924, p5

Billie Carlyle was the stage name of Doris Ann Nesida Kelly nee Davy, a twenty-three year old from Adelaide when she got her big break in The Adventures of Algy. Of her childhood we know almost nothing, except that her birth certificate suggests her father George was in sales, and we know that she had an older brother. Her 1978 memoir actually begins with her as a 21 year old catching a train to Melbourne, determined to make a career on stage – she provided no commentary about her childhood or what sparked her interest in performing. In fact, behind the cheerful story in her well – manicured memoir, her entree to acting really had a very tragic background. Births, Deaths and Marriages records from South Australia show that while aged only 18, she had married returned serviceman Harold John Kelly – in May 1920. In October 1921 she had given birth to a girl, but sadly the child had died in early 1923.[22]The Chronicle (Adelaide), 15 Oct 1921, p31 and The Express (Adelaide) 4 January 1923, p3 Quite possibly suffering severe depression, in early 1924 she went on “a holiday” to Australia’s eastern states, but after six weeks, her husband reported her as a missing person. We know this because newspapers on the Australian east coast carried the story and some even published her photo. South Australian Police also listed her as a missing person.[23]See for example –Daily Standard (Brisbane) 27 Feb 1924, p2 and The Chronicle (Adelaide) 1 Mar 1924, p50

A week later she was found in Melbourne. Doris reassured Police she was safe and had somewhere to stay, but said she would not be returning to Adelaide. She said she wanted to pursue a career on the stage.[24]The Sun (Sydney) 9 Mar 1924, p2 And extraordinarily, given the circumstances, she did. Just seven months later, Everyone’s magazine was able to report that “a bright career” was predicted for her.[25]Everyone’s (Aust) 29 Oct, 1924, p40

Billie with D B O’connor in the town of Tumut in December 1924.[26]The Tumut Advocate and Farmers & Settlers’ Adviser (NSW) 16 Dec 1924 p5

Records confirm that in early 1924 Doris, now calling herself Billie Carlyle, found work with comedian Wally Reynolds [27]in her memoirs she recalls him as “Wally Peterson” at St Kilda’s Lyric Theatre in a variety called Hullo People – reported to be full of “good clean humour.” She then joined D. B. O’Connor’s troupe, which toured through smaller Australian towns, as they made their way from Melbourne to Sydney, performing The Merry Widow and Are You a Mason?

Cropped photo of Billie Carlyle from her collection, dating to about the time she met Claude, c1925. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre, Melbourne.

As noted, Billie met Claude Dampier on the set of the film The Adventures of Algy. The film opened on 20 June 1925 [28]Pike & Cooper (1980) p164-165 and several enthusiastic newspapers predicted that Billie would soon become one of the “best screen actors ever produced by Australia.”[29]Mirror (Perth) Sat 8 Aug 1925, p7 This was doubtless just newspaper chatter, and it should be noted that Claude’s partner at the time, Hilda Attenboro, was also in the film.[30]Clay Djubal provides a precis of the film’s plot here

Rare production stills from The Adventures of Algy. Left to right: Claude Dampier, Billie Carlyle at Sydney’s The Gap, and New Zealand actress Bathie Stuart (1897-1987), with unidentified Māori extras. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre, Melbourne.

With the release of the film, Claude took to performing at some of the screenings, adding a 40 minute live act – at first with Hilda and then, from mid -1926, with Billie. Billie recalled that she met Claude’s estranged partner Hilda, before she took over touring with Claude, to support screenings of The Adventures of Algy.[31]Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate (NSW) 3 May 1926, p6 Billie’s memoir explains that Hilda and Claude separated because their relationship was “explosive,” although she avoided making reference to their private relationship, or their child.[32]Carlyle 1978, p12

This act was called The Deputy Pianist. Billie played “a long suffering artist performing with an incompetent pianist.” Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre, Melbourne.

It is clear from Billie’s memoirs that she co-wrote much of the material they performed, although at the same time, her on-stage role with Claude became the straight person, or “feed” in the act. In a short, undated obituary for Claude held by the Australian Performing Arts Collection, Billie explained that Claude would continually rework his material, “practically to the last minute.” Her published memoir also provides evidence of her many efforts to record amusing conversations with Claude – things that they could then work up to use on stage. The following example illustrates their banter:[33]Carlyle 1978, p35

Billie: [Handing Claude a letter on stage] I am sorry, a gentleman asked me to give you this just before we came on stage.
Claude: Well open it and see what it says. It might be important...
B: It's from a Reporter
C: Reporter?
B: Now don't tell me you don't know what a Reporter is...
C: Oh you mean one of those fellows that go around letting off reports?
B: Not exactly. He is a man that goes around finding things out.
C: Oh! You mean a nosey parker! What does he want to know?...
B: He said he'd like a photograph. Have you got one?
C: Well yes. Here's a photo of me and my friend Mrs Gibson bathing.
B: Ah. What's this...round thing sticking out of the water?
C: Oh that's part of Mrs Gibson. See that? That's a bit of seaweed. I'm behind that.

Mrs Gibson became a running joke of their act. The character would often be worked into a routine, and sometimes a member of the audience would be mistaken as Mrs Gibson. Billie Carlyle dates the genesis of the character to August 1926, in a performance in New Zealand. Billie claims the couple were later briefly banned by the BBC after an ad-libbed line where Claude claimed he was going to “squeeze Mrs Gibson’s oranges.” [34]Carlyle 1978, p43-44

The Unprofessional Photographer. One of Claude and Billie’s acts. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.

A snapshot of their UK careers

In February 1927, Claude and Billie took passage on the Orsova for England. It is not really clear from Billie’s memoir why they decided to make this move at this time. Of course, many young performers wanted to try their luck in Britain, but Claude was now 48, and had been living and performing in Australia, New Zealand and South Africa for 17 years, in an act he had successfully refined for colonial audiences. Claude was now completely forgotten in England, and he warned Billie that they would both “have to start out from scratch.”[35]Carlyle, 1978, p21 Billie Carlyle recalled that it took seven years for Claude to establish himself again in Britain – to be listed at the top of a bill, as he had been in Australia.[36]Carlyle, 1978, p29.

Billie and Claude, perhaps on their way to England. The Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.

Billie’s memoir states that it was around the time of Claude’s divorce from Irene that she became romantically involved with him – in England – in 1927-28. She said that she had gradually fallen in love with him.[37]Carlyle, 1978, p20-21

The transition to performing in Britain was not without its challenges and it is likely that what was successful in Australia and South Africa did not immediately work on the British stage. Billie managed only one performance with Claude at London’s Victoria Palace Theatre in April 1927, before being briefly replaced by Irene Vere for a few days – either due to illness[38]The Stage (London) 14 April 1927, p13 or perhaps it was because a Manager insisted on the change.[39]Carlyle, 1978, p18-20. However, her own account of this is ambiguous Contrary to her claim in the memoir that she and Claude never got a poor review, early reviews of their act were variable. One British paper suggested Dampier’s “act should be scrapped and quickly. His patter is so over deliberate and it drags and his chatter with Miss Carlyle and himself is old stuff… No, Mr. Dampier we cannot let you get away with this act. You can do much better.” [40]Unnamed British paper cited in The Leader (Perth) 15 Jul 1927, p3 Revised and improved, their act gained better reviews as they toured British towns.[41]Nottingham Evening Post (UK) July 16, 1927 p4

Programs listing Claude and Billie’s act, from (left) London’s Holborn Empire in 1929 and (right) the Victoria Hotel at Sidmouth, Devon, in 1947. (click image to enlarge) The Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.

Claude and Billie first appeared on radio in 1934, and as Billie’s memoir notes, this dramatically changed their fortunes, soon making them a headline act. The BBC’s database lists over 200 radio and TV performances by Claude Dampier, often featuring Billie as his feed. The radio programs of the mid 1930s included Variety, Radiolympia, Music Hall and Mrs Gibson’s Guesthouse – all of which included performers who were best known for their stage acts. Although tastes were changing and live vaudeville was in decline, variety-themed shows remained a feature of broadcasting well into the era of television. Claude’s last regular appearance appears to have been in the radio comedy series Up the Pole between 1947 and 1952, with Jimmy Jewel (1909-1995) and Ben Warriss.(1909-1993)

Claude’s first major film in Britain, Radio Parade of 1935 (1934), was produced by the prolific Walter C Mycroft (1890-1959), and was cobbled together using established stage acts, with a thin storyline carrying the narrative along – a style of British “musical” that was really a series of variety acts – apparently very popular in the 1930s. Claude went on to join a number of familiar, usually eccentric, character actors who popped up from time to time in British films of the 1930s.[42]The IMDB lists at least one short involving Claude Dampier from the early 1930s, but further details of Claude Deputises (1931) are elusive Billie also appeared in a handful of Claude’s films in the 1930s, in very minor roles.

Claude Dampier as the eccentric piano tuner in Radio Parade of 1935 (1934)Screengrab from the Oldnews (and new) channel on Youtube.

Billie Carlyle explained in her memoirs that – as one would expect – the couple’s friendships grew from professional associations on the stage, radio and in films. Will Hay, Jack Hyton, June Clyde and Zasu Pitts all became close friends.

Billie and Claude occasionally appeared on live television after 1936. Regrettably, very few examples of pre-war British television survive today, however this advertisement from the Radio Times lists Billie and Claude as part of a series of variety acts presented on TV under the banner of a “Western (Wild West) Cabaret.”

A 1939 BBC TV broadcast.[43]Radio Times (UK) 11 June 1939, p16

Despite Billie’s assessment that working with the wartime entertainments Unit (ENSA) was frustratingly awkward, they joined in morale-boosting war work alongside so many other British entertainers – at fund-raising appearances and openings. An example of a BBC Workers Playtime performance from 1943 can be heard here.

The burdens of Billie Carlyle

It is commonly stated that Billie and Claude married in the UK in the late 1920s or early 1930s, and indeed Billie’s own memoirs infer this. Although it is of much less importance to many people today, there is, in fact, no evidence in the British marriage databases of the couple marrying at any time. In late 1937 Harold John Kelly finally sought a divorce from Billie.[44]The Advertiser (Adelaide) 6 March 1938, p32 Surprisingly, the divorce documents in the New South Wales Supreme Court referenced only Harold’s missing wife Doris Ann Kelly, whom Harold said he “could not find.” The documents made no mention of Billie Carlyle the actress, who had appeared in a popular Australian film, or of Claude Dampier the well-known comedian.

In this writer’s opinion, it is quite likely that this divorce [45]the era of no-fault divorce in Australia was still decades away was a result of some agreement between Billie in England, and Harold, a part-time labourer then struggling to make a living in Katoomba, New South Wales. The petition emphasizes Harold’s poverty, states that he had a new partner and that they had five children to support.[46]New South Wales State Archives. Divorce papers Harold John Kelly and Doris Ann Kelly.NRS-13495-15-250-2203/1937 It could be concluded that the unhappy early marriage and the death of her child was an onerous burden that Billie had carried for fifteen years.

Coincidentally – or perhaps not; in December 1937, at the same time the divorce was being filed in New South Wales, Billie and Claude left England for a holiday touring the United States.[47]Carlyle 1978, pps46-56 At the time, entry to the US required a great deal more personal information to be presented than most countries. The SS Aquitania‘s passenger list of 15 December 1937, showed Doris Ann Davy, a 34 year old unmarried Australian-born actress, and Claude Cowan, a 59 year old married English actor, on board. Today, it is very difficult to believe the divorce action and the holiday trip to the US were not connected – timed to limit any potential embarrassment to Billie and Claude. But if this was the case, Billie and Claude need not have worried. There was no bad publicity, and the New South Wales Supreme Court granted Harold Kelly a decree nisi in June 1938.

On their return from the US on the Queen Mary, Claude Dampier and Billie Carlyle used their stage names for UK entry, and Claude now claimed to be only 49. [48]Sunderland Daily Echo & Shipping Gazette, 1 March 1938 p1

Billie Carlyle after Claude’s death

Claude Dampier died of complications arising from pneumonia in early 1955. He was 76. While this meant Billie no longer had a stage partnership, she did not disappear. She continued to maintain her show-biz relationships, and appeared a few more times at special commemorative events and reportedly on radio quiz shows.[49]Daily Telegraph (UK) 1 August 1991 Finally, in the mid 1970s, she returned to visit Australia, perhaps to see her brother again, after almost 50 years. In retirement in the UK, she painted, learned to type and wrote and self-published her memoirs – leaving her voice at the forefront of the Claude Dampier story. She also wrote several works of fiction – that were not published.[50]These were Delora’s Dilemma and Answers for Anne – the latter being an unusual work – written in 1985, it concerns the rape of the protagonist, Anne, and a series of very complex … Continue reading

In the 1980s Billie decided to leave a heavily curated selection of the couple’s collection of scrapbooks, programs and photographs to the newly established Australian Performing Arts Collection in Melbourne, Australia.

Billie Carlyle at home in 1981. [51]The Australian Women’s Weekly, 6 May 1981, p11

Billie and Claude had no children together, however Claude’s daughter Dorothy by Irene Vere became a performer and visited Australia for at least one long tour in 1937.

The daughter of Claude and Hilda Attenboro grew up and raised a family in Australia.

Billie Carlyle died in England in July 1991. She had re-married in 1961.

Dorothy Dampier in Australia in 1937. She was sometimes known as Dorothy Vere.[52]The Wireless Weekly. (Aust) 25 June 1937, p7

Nick Murphy
September 2024


References

Thanks

  • Claudia Funder and the staff at the Australian Performing Arts Collection, Art Centre, Melbourne, who arranged my access to the Billie Carlyle & Claude Dampier Collection

Births, Deaths & Marriages documents

  • South Australia Births Deaths & Marriages
    Birth certificate: Doris Ann Nesida Davy, 10 Feb 1902 (The middle name looks like Rosida on the birth certificate)
    Marriage certificate: Doris Ann Nesida Davy and Harold John Kelly 15 May 1920
  • Victoria Births Deaths & Marriages
    Birth Certificate: Marjorie Sheldon Cowan, 22 March 1923.
  • National Archives (UK)
    Divorce papers (Court minutes) Eileen Geraldine Violet Keith Cowan and Claude Connolly Cowan, 1927-1928. J 77/2445/6307
  • Museums of History NSW – State Archives Collection
    Divorce papers Harold John Kelly and Doris Ann Kelly.NRS-13495-15-250-2203/1937.
  • HM Passport office, General Register office (UK)
    Claude C Cowan & Eileen Geraldine Thompson, Marriage Certificate, 30 April 1907.
    Claude C Cowan, Death Certificate, 1 January 1955.
    Billie Carlyle-Blake, Death Certificate, 23 July, 1991.

Text

  • Richard Anthony Baker (2013) Old Time Variety. Pen & Sword Books.
  • Billie Carlyle (1978) Claude Dampier Mrs Gibson & Me. Billie Carlyle
  • Clay Djubal at the Australian Variety Theatre Archive
    The Adventures of Algy (2017)
    Claude Dampier
    (2018)
    Edward Branscombe (2013)
  • Richard Fotheringham (2024) “Autobiography as publicity: the case of Jenny Howard” in Australian Journal of Biography and History, No 8, 2024, Australian National University
  • Andrew Pike & Ross Cooper (1980) Australian Film 1900-1977. Oxford University Press.
  • Frank Van Straten (2003) Tivoli. Thomas C Lothian
  • Adrian Wright (2020) Cheer Up! British Musical Films 1929-1945. The Boydell Press.

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

Te Ara – the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, Dictionary of New Zealand Biography

Encyclopaedia of South African Theatre, Film, Media and Performance (ESAT)

Audio & Film

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 See Richard Fotheringham’s 2024 biography of another actor of the same era, Jenny Howard (1902-1996), for a deeper analysis of the extent of these difficulties
↑2, ↑49 Daily Telegraph (UK) 1 August 1991
↑3, ↑25 Everyone’s (Aust) 29 Oct, 1924, p40
↑4 Birth name Eileen Geraldine Thompson
↑5 The Register (Adelaide) 12 Oct 1910, p5
↑6 Evening Journal (Adelaide),13 Feb 1911, p2
↑7 Carlyle,1978, p1
↑8 The New Zealand Graphic and Ladies Journal, 10 July 1912, p.22
↑9 The Stage (London) 19 Dec 1919
↑10 Her stage name was also sometimes spelled Attenborough. She had been born in England in 1896 as Alice Hilda Sweet. Of interest, she had appeared in at least three silent films in South Africa in 1918
↑11 Victorian Birth Certificate Number 13524 / 1923, 23 March 1923
↑12 The marriages of South Africa’s white population during this era can be found on Familysearch.com. In these records we can see Hilda had actually married performer Thomas Henry Daniels in South Africa in August 1918, and by whom she already had another child
↑13 National Archives (UK) Divorce Court file J 77/2445/6307 Appellant: Eileen Geraldine Violet Keith Cowan
↑14 Critic (Adelaide) 7 December 1921, p10
↑15 Sunday Times (Sydney)16 Oct 1921, p3
↑16 Sunday Times (Sydney) 27 Nov 1921, p17
↑17 The Oxford reference guide describes a remittance man as typically a disgraced man of good position or family who has been sent abroad by his family and whose payments depend on his remaining there
↑18 The Advertiser (Adelaide) 15 Dec 1924, p11
↑19 Everyone’s (Aust) 19 Nov 1924, p11
↑20 This film survives but is difficult to source. These screen grabs are from the documentary A History of Australian Cinema, Part Two, The Passionate Industry 1920-1930, available from Umbrella Entertainment/Film Australia
↑21 Mail (Adelaide) 1 March 1924, p5
↑22 The Chronicle (Adelaide), 15 Oct 1921, p31 and The Express (Adelaide) 4 January 1923, p3
↑23 See for example –Daily Standard (Brisbane) 27 Feb 1924, p2 and The Chronicle (Adelaide) 1 Mar 1924, p50
↑24 The Sun (Sydney) 9 Mar 1924, p2
↑26 The Tumut Advocate and Farmers & Settlers’ Adviser (NSW) 16 Dec 1924 p5
↑27 in her memoirs she recalls him as “Wally Peterson”
↑28 Pike & Cooper (1980) p164-165
↑29 Mirror (Perth) Sat 8 Aug 1925, p7
↑30 Clay Djubal provides a precis of the film’s plot here
↑31 Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate (NSW) 3 May 1926, p6
↑32 Carlyle 1978, p12
↑33 Carlyle 1978, p35
↑34 Carlyle 1978, p43-44
↑35 Carlyle, 1978, p21
↑36 Carlyle, 1978, p29.
↑37 Carlyle, 1978, p20-21
↑38 The Stage (London) 14 April 1927, p13
↑39 Carlyle, 1978, p18-20. However, her own account of this is ambiguous
↑40 Unnamed British paper cited in The Leader (Perth) 15 Jul 1927, p3
↑41 Nottingham Evening Post (UK) July 16, 1927 p4
↑42 The IMDB lists at least one short involving Claude Dampier from the early 1930s, but further details of Claude Deputises (1931) are elusive
↑43 Radio Times (UK) 11 June 1939, p16
↑44 The Advertiser (Adelaide) 6 March 1938, p32
↑45 the era of no-fault divorce in Australia was still decades away
↑46 New South Wales State Archives. Divorce papers Harold John Kelly and Doris Ann Kelly.NRS-13495-15-250-2203/1937
↑47 Carlyle 1978, pps46-56
↑48 Sunderland Daily Echo & Shipping Gazette, 1 March 1938 p1
↑50 These were Delora’s Dilemma and Answers for Anne – the latter being an unusual work – written in 1985, it concerns the rape of the protagonist, Anne, and a series of very complex and implausible relationships
↑51 The Australian Women’s Weekly, 6 May 1981, p11
↑52 The Wireless Weekly. (Aust) 25 June 1937, p7

The Bennettos – the talented sisters from Fitzroy

Ethel Bennetto as she appeared in the Egyptian ballet of the revue Time, Please in June-July 1918. [1]The Green Room magazine, 1 June, 1918, P2. Mitchell Library, State Library of New South Wales Melbourne newspapers of the time reported this scene was altered or “censored” at the request of Police. It appears not to have bothered Ethel at all.[2]The Herald (Melb) 12 Jul 1918, p1

The Five Second version
Alice Bennetto (1885-1970) and her younger sister Ethel (1889-1985) both built successful careers on stage in Australasia in the early twentieth century. Typical of the working-class, inner-city children who joined Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company, they were talented singers and dancers. and their speciality was the ever popular comic opera and variety – that audiences were so familiar with. In 1919, Ethel appeared in the now lost film Does the Jazz Lead to Destruction? before marrying a New Zealand doctor and retiring from the stage. About the same time, Alice became a personal and professional partner of popular Scottish-born comedian Elton Black (James McWhinnie)(1881 -1948), performing with him for the next twenty years and finally marrying him in 1939. Both women died in New Zealand.

Alice and Ethel growing up in Fitzroy

Alice Bennetto and Ethel Bennetto on tour in Manila and enroute to North America – with Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company c1903.[3]Enlarged from a photo in the Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne

Architectural Historian Miles Lewis has observed that by the end of the nineteenth century, “the inner suburbs in general, and Fitzroy in particular, were occupied not by people who aspired to be there, but by people who could not get out.”[4]Lewis (Ed) 2012, P63 It is likely that an apprenticeship to Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company was recognised by Fitzroy families as one means of social mobility, of “getting out.” In the case of three families who, in the late 1890s, lived in Kerr Street, Fitzroy, getting out, thanks to Pollards Lilliputian Opera, is what happened. Most of the Trott family – originally resident at No 56 Kerr St – left Australia in company with successful daughters Daphne and Ivy in 1907, re-establishing themselves in Seattle.[5]They had been living in King William Street when they departed Australia, leaving one married daughter behind 16 year old Oscar Heintz from No 84 Kerr St did not return with the Pollards troupe at all after the 1904-07 tour, instead settling in Portland, Oregon, where, with the help of the YMCA, he made a successful (non-theatrical) life for himself. His younger performing brother Freddie later moved back to the US in hopes of building a career, but met with little success. The subject of this account, the Bennetto girls, also moved away from Kerr Street Fitzroy after experience with Pollards.

Kerr St Fitzroy in 2024. In the late 1890s, No. 84 (red door on the left) housed the Heintz family, No 76 (centre of photo) the Bennettos, and No 56 (the white building in the right far distance) was home to the Trott family. Children of all these families joined the Pollards.[6]No 86, the home of William Bennetto, now demolished, was to the left of the photo

Alice (1885-1970) and Ethel (1889-1985) Bennetto were born in the inner Melbourne suburbs, the children of bricklayer Arthur Bennetto (1857-1909) and his wife Sarah nee Montague (1862-1920). Arthur, who was the Australian-born son of Cornish goldrush immigrants, moved his family around various rental properties in the Fitzroy and Carlton areas, until settling into Kerr Street, Fitzroy. His unmarried brother William (1859-1895), a carpenter and builder, who might possibly have been a business partner, also lived and worked in Kerr St until his early death in 1895.

The Bennetto girl’s uncle William advertising in 1889, at the height of Melbourne’s building boom.[7]Jewish Herald (Vic) 16 Aug 1889 p3

Like many of the children who travelled overseas with Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company, we have only vestiges of information about the home life of the Bennetto girls.

In 1908, at age 46, Alice and Ethel’s mother Sarah gave birth to another daughter – Violet. But a year later, their father Arthur died at the family home at 76 Kerr Street. The girls and their brothers almost certainly attended school number 111 in nearby Bell Street, Fitzroy. Irene Goulding (1888-1987), a friend of Alice Bennetto, is known to have attended the Bell Street school, and like the Bennetto girls, she left at a young age to join Pollards. Interviewed near the end of a long life, Irene could still recall that her favourite teacher at Bell Street did not approve of her leaving school for a life of touring with Pollards.[8]Regrettably, all records regarding this important early Melbourne school have been lost or destroyed by the Education Department. The 1985 interview with Irene Goulding is held by the Performing Arts … Continue reading

Fitzroy girls with the Pollards: Alice Bennetto (Right front), with friend Irene Goulding standing behind her (Right rear). Also shown are Pollards proprietor Nellie Chester, left front, and Alice McNamara, left rear. c1900 [9]Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne


Alice and Ethel had four brothers, none of whom joined Pollards, and several of whom struggled to find a direction in life. On occasion the Bennetto boys were in trouble with the law, and two of them were rejected as medically unfit for military service in World War One. Oldest brother Thomas William Bennetto (1883-1943) blamed his poor education for not remembering details of his military service when he applied for a fresh copy of his discharge papers in 1937.[10]See his National Archives of Australia military file, p28 Whatever benefit the Pollards experience had brought his sisters, it apparently had not extended to him.


Alice and Ethel with the Pollards

Alice Bennetto first travelled with Charles Pollard and Nellie Chester’s Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company in 1899. Alice is listed returning from South Africa in February 1900 on the passenger manifest of the Salamis. In July 1900 both Alice and Ethel were listed as members of the next Pollards troupe, appearing on the manifest of the Pilbarra, arriving in Western Australia from Melbourne, while on their way to the “Far East.” Thus, the girls began touring overseas with the Pollards, at ages 14 and 11.

Alice and Ethel Bennetto, c1900-3, while with the Pollards. Irene Goulding at right, Nellie Chester in the foreground.[11]Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne

It was Alice Bennetto who the Pollards chose to sing Nearer My God to Thee at a special memorial service held in Honolulu in October 1901, following the assassination of US President William McKinley. The Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company were on their way to North America at the time. She was the company’s leading player, a newspaper reported.[12]The Honolulu Republican, 1 Oct 1901, p1

Despite the Pollards popularity, not all audiences felt comfortable at the sight of children acting in adult roles in comic opera. In 1907, one correspondent for the Hong Kong Daily Press asked readers: Pollard’s Lilliputians are children, but their performance is anything but childish… That shrimp of a maiden …who portrays a woman many times divorced, how are we to regard her? [13]The Hong Kong Daily Press, 27 December 1907, p17

Comic operas, such as The Belle of New York, included lyrics like this:[14]The Victoria Daily Times (Victoria BC), 26 June 1913, p5

Teach me how to kiss dear,
Teach me how to squeeze,
Teach me how to sit upon your simple Celtic knees.
Teach me how to coo dear, like a turtle dove,
Teach me how to fondle you,
Oh teach me how to love.

Today, many would have mixed feelings about the appropriateness of some comic operas for child performers, but as this writer has noted elsewhere, Pollards repertoire reflected the dominant tastes of the time (or at least, some people’s taste). On the goldfields of Kalgoorlie for example, a reviewer for the Kalgoorlie Miner felt comfortable writing; Miss Alice Bennetto, as The Belle of New York, whose gradual diminution of costume during the evening suggests awful possibilities if the play were prolonged by another act.[15]Kalgoorlie Miner (WA) 23 July 1900, p8

Alice and Ethel Bennetto (red dots) with Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company, c1903. [16]Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne

Alice and Ethel went on three Pollards overseas performance tours together –

  • July 1900 to April 1901,
  • September 1901 to October 1902 and
  • January 1903 to April 1904.

All of these Pollards tours ended up in the US and Canada, where the company was so popular – except on the US east coast, where the Gerry Society’s efforts to keep child performers off the stage were successful.[17]“The Gerry Society” was the popular name for the very influential New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children Alice also went on the very long tour of September 1904 to February 1907, as a supervising adult and likely also as one of the troupe’s singing/dancing mistresses. By 1904 she was almost 20 years old and could no longer pass as a juvenile or Lilliputian, and while her name is on the shipping manifest entering Vancouver in March 1905 with the Pollards, it is not found in surviving programs.[18]A potted version of Alice’s career was given to News (Adelaide), 1 May 1924, p2 Back in Fitzroy, perhaps tiring of the long tours overseas, Ethel Bennetto instead joined Tom Pollard’s branch of the Pollards company – that toured locations in Australasia.[19]The Evening Star (WA) 9 Feb 1906 p3 Joining her were Minnie and May Topping, neighbours from 49 Fitzroy Street, Fitzroy who, had also previously been with Charles Pollard and Nellie Chester’s troupe in North America. Perhaps they too, were tired of long periods away from family and friends.

Alice and Ethel’s Australasian careers – 1910s

 Left: Alice in Table Talk (Melb) 6 Jan 1910 p23. Courtesy Australian Performing Arts Collection.
Right: Ethel in 1909, while with Meynell and Gunn’s Opera Company. [20]Table Talk (Melb) 29 April 1909, p22

Following the Pollards tours, both Alice and Ethel built careers on the Australian stage. Their experience was common to other capable and aspiring young Australian actors at the time – Enid Bennett, Dorothy Cumming, Gwen Day Burroughs, Cyril Ritchard, Clyde Cook, Dorothy Brunton, W.S. Percy, and others. The Bennetto girls met and worked with many of these performers. They also benefited by patronage of experienced performers – Alice nominated singer and actress Florence Young (1870-1920), for whom she understudied, as a positive influence on her career, although she also noted that Young was always unwilling to disappoint fans by not appearing, even when ill.[21]News (Adelaide) 1 May 1924, p2

The sisters employment was very much dominated by JC Williamson’s, the Australasian theatre monopoly – and a surviving JC Williamson’s contract for Alice listed her 1916 salary as a modest £6 per week, whilst on tour. On a few occasions the Bennettos were in the same productions – for example they both appeared together in Meynell & Gunn’s production of The Belle of Mayfair [22]a burlesque version of Romeo and Juliet, in Auckland, in June 1909 and in The Arcadians in Melbourne in 1915.

Alice Bennetto and Lillian Lea singing in the 1909 panto Babes in the Wood. The Argus (Melb) 28 Dec 1909 p7 [23]National Library of Australia

The AusStage database shows an almost continuous body of work for both women in Australia in the 1910s, mostly comprising musical comedy and panto. However, newspaper reports show an endless series of less well documented variety performances were also a feature.

As Elisabeth Kumm has noted, dramatic changes were already under way in the Australian theatre scene when war broke out in 1914. The trend to concentrated ownership continued, but after a dip in attendances, demand for entertainment returned, and became such that during the war years some 200 new plays were performed in Melbourne alone.[24]Kumm, 2016 Frank Van Straten notes that the Tivoli circuit turned to big, imported revues at this time.[25]Van Straten, (2003) p53-57 War also meant there were fewer British stars available, and while US actors filled some of the gap, more Australian actors were given opportunities to impress. It is in this environment that the Bennetto girls flourished. Although never leading stars of the stage, they were increasingly profiled and often received good reviews.

Left: Ethel Bennetto helps advertise Cohen & Son’s new swimsuit. Theatre Magazine, 1 Feb 1916 [26]Theatre Heritage Australia digital Collection Right: Ethel Bennetto on the cover of Green Room magazine, while performing in the revue Time, Please in August 1918. , Perhaps she was channeling Annette Kellerman in the new film Daughter of the Gods (1916).[27]State Library of NSW, Mitchell Library

In 1918, Melbourne’s Table Talk magazine acknowledged the change in wartime when it reported:
Alice Bennetto, one of the principals in The Rajah of Shivapore at the Princess, is a young Australian who has already had a lot of stage experience but not much chance to shine. Now she scintillates, for she not only looks beautiful and acts appealingly, but proves herself. the possessor of a light soprano voice of delightful quality and charm. Yet with all these gifts she has had to tarry long in the chorus. The most successful favourites we have ever had on our light opera stage have been Australian.[28]Table Talk (Melb) 21 Feb 1918, p9


Ethel Bennetto’s 1919 film

In 1919 Ethel appeared in a comedy film entitled Does the Jazz Lead to Destruction? With her in this was Sydney dancer George Irving.[29]not the well known US film director with the same name, as the IMDB currently claims Unfortunately other details of the film are unknown to us now because -it is long considered lost. Advertising on its limited release suggests it may have been a comedy short, made to be a part of a mixed-bill variety program, with Jazz-themes.

Does the Jazz Lead to Destruction (1919) with Ethel and George Irving.[30]The Picture Show, 2 August 1919, p13. Mitchell Library, State Library of NSW

Following this, Ethel joined the Sydney Tivoli Revue company for a New Zealand tour. And then, in 1920, she rather suddenly married well-known Auckland medico Theodore Endletsberger (1869-1931).[31]Born in Austria in 1869, Endletsberger had arrived in New Zealand in about 1906. He had been interned during the First World War, but had since built a successful practice By March 1920, Ethel had retired completely from the stage, and following the death of Sarah Bennetto in Fitzroy, 11 year old Violet, the youngest member of the Bennetto family, had come over to live with the couple in New Zealand. Auckland’s affluent suburb of Mount Eden would have been a stark contrast to King William Street in Fitzroy.


Alice Bennetto and Elton Black after 1919

Alice was interviewed several times in the 1920s. One brief interview from 1924 published in an Adelaide paper under the title Confessions – actresses unburden their souls suggests Alice had a very dry sense of humour – a tantalising glimpse of the real person. Asked what her “ideal man” was, Alice’s answer was – He doesn’t exist. Her favourite word was not in the dictionary. Of the stage, she responded that it was a decent way of making a living and of her greatest joy – she said it was singing for my salary. Her most awkward moment was when I crack on a top C. [32]News (Adelaide) 14 Jan 1924, p6 Despite the witty commentary about a lack of ideal men, Alice had already met someone she would spend the next thirty years with.

Left: Alice Bennetto in the comic opera The Rajah of Shivapore in Melbourne in early 1918. [33]Table Talk, 7 Feb 1918, p22
Right: Elton Black in 1923. [34]The Critic (Adelaide) 21 Nov 1923, p11

Sometime in late 1918 or 1919, Alice Bennetto met and became a professional and personal partner of comedian Elton Black (1881-1948) (real name James McWhinnie) – although the exact context of how this happened now seems lost. At the time Elton Black was already married to pioneer actor, director and writer Kate Howarde (1864-1939).[See Note 1 below]

Elton and Alice in a variety lineup in Brisbane, 1923.[35]Daily Standard (Qld) 19 Sept 1923, p2

Amongst the earliest collaborations between Elton Black and Alice Bennetto was Walter Johnson’s “Town Topics Company”. This was the pantomime Robinson Crusoe, performed in December 1919. Elton Black’s script for this survives in the Nat Phillips papers, at the Fryer Library at the University of Queensland. Even in its incomplete state, it is an fascinating example of how successful variety acts were stitched together, with handwritten corrections over the typed manuscript.

Alice Bennetto spent most of the next three decades performing with Elton Black. Clay Djubal’s research into the professional life of Elton Black also gives a survey of just how busy and successful they were as a partnership.[36]See his article on Elton Black at the Australian Variety Theatre Archive, here Their acts varied, but their speciality was increasingly the “Scottish comedian” act, in the style of Harry Lauder. Alice was his foil, a “Highland lassie.”

While performing with Elton and Billy Maloney (1895-1957) for the Town Topics Company, Alice was asked what made for success in vaudeville. She answered;
it has to be a pot-pourri of every thing of the best. Singing, dancing, comedy, and frocking. I always make a great point of the last mentioned, because it helps every item. I put all my money into my stage clothes, and we are fortunate in having an expert wardrobe mistress… I’m sure you will love the costumes they wear in Mr. Maloney’s number, Yes, we have no bananas – pink and grey silk paisley.[37]The Advertiser (Adelaide) 29 Nov 1923, p11

In September 1924 Alice and Elton arrived together in England on the SS Euripides, (apparently after several months spent in South Africa). For the next 20 months they performed successfully in Britain. While Alice was recognised for her own talents, one newspaper having described her as a charming musical-comedy-revue heroine, [38]Dundee Evening Telegraph,15 September 1925, p10, it was especially the Scotch comedian and his “Heilan’ Lassie” act that drew attention. They arrived home on the SS Runic in May 1926.[39]News (Adelaide) 11 May 1926, p1

Elton Black and Alice Bennetto advertising in London’s The Stage, soon after arriving in Britain.[40]The Stage (London) 6 Nov 1924, p10

Elton and Alice lived together as a couple for many years, with Auckland, New Zealand as their base from the late 1920s. However, it was only after Kate Howarde’s death in 1939, that they finally married.[41]Alice Catherine Bennetto & James McWhinnie, New Zealand Marriage Certificate – 1939/2568 The couple continued to work together almost until Elton’s death in 1948, including on some radio variety programs (in both Australia and New Zealand).

Elton Black’s Community Entertainers performing through regional Western Australia in 1935[42]The Mirror (Perth) 30 Nov 1935, p22

As Clay Djubal’s research suggests, by the 1930s it would seem their repertoire found more consistent audiences in provincial and regional settings. Live variety had adapted to the arrival of silent and then sound films, but perhaps more conservative audience tastes also helped companies touring variety survive longer in regional areas than the larger cities. Amongst Alice and Elton’s final shows was a live version of the popular radio show Chuckles with Jerry, on tour in New Zealand in 1947.

Left: Alice and Elton in a variety lineup in New Zealand in 1939 and at right, in a radio-themed lineup in 1947.[43]Auckland Star, 9 August 1939, p22, and Bay of Plenty Beacon, 11 April 1947, p1

Following Elton Black’s death in 1948, Alice Bennetto’s performances also came to an end. She died at Auckland’s Cornwall Hospital in early 1970. Ethel also died in Auckland, in 1985. Theodore Endletsberger had died in 1931 and Ethel had remarried in 1939.


Note 1: Elton Black & Kate Howarde c1904 – c1919

Elton Black had arrived in Australia in the early 1900s. He married Kate Howarde (1864-1939)[44]Born Catherine Clarissa Jones, her name at the time was Catherine De Saxe. Her first husband William Henry De Saxe had died in July 1902 at Port Adelaide in February 1905. A few months later, the couple departed for North America, and later Britain – where they sometimes performed together, before returning to Australia in 1909. The Kate Howarde Company toured Australia and New Zealand until about 1914, and Elton Black’s career appears to have been often intertwined with hers. In 1914 Kate Howarde settled into producing weekly rep at Balmain’s National Theatre. As Ina Bertrand notes, at least some of their performances were original works by Kate Howarde – The White Slave Traffic (1914) and Why Girls Leave Home (1914). While Elton Black was first and foremost a comedian, at times he took on character roles with the company. They toured again in 1918 – in regional Victoria, at the end of which Elton Black made a very late attempt to join the Australian Army, under his stage name. He was rejected as medically unfit, and late October 1918 was too late to make a difference anyway. His relationship with Kate Howarde seems to have come to an end at about this time.

Kate Howarde’s ‘Possum Paddock as a film. Theatre Magazine, 1 December 1920, p54. At right is Leslie Adrien, Kate’s daughter.

Creative and busy to the end of her life, Kate Howarde went on to direct a film version of her very popular play ‘Possum Paddock in 1919, becoming the first woman to write and direct an Australian feature film. See Ina Bertrand’s survey of her life at the Australian Dictionary of Biography, and the Women Film Pioneers project. She died in Sydney in 1939.


Nick Murphy
July 2024


References

Australian Performing Arts Collection, Art Centre, Melbourne

  • Alice Bennetto contract with JC Williamsons
  • Irene Smith (Goulding) interview by Sally Dawes, 1985

Births, Deaths & Marriages documents

  • Victoria
    • Alice Catherine Bennetto, Birth Certificate, 5 Oct 1885
    • William Bennetto, Death Certificate, 25 Sept 1895
    • Ethel Bennetto, Birth Certificate, 22 December 1889
    • Arthur Bennetto, Death Certificate, 8 June 1909
    • Sarah Bennetto, Death Certificate, 3 April 1920
  • New Zealand
    • Ethel Bennetto & Theodor Endletsberger, Marriage Certificate 1920 -1920/5541
    • Alice Catherine Bennetto & James McWhinnie, Marriage Certificate 1939 – 1939/2568
    • Ethel Endletsberger & Andrew Kyle, Marriage Certificate 1939 – 1939/295
    • James McWhinnie, Death Certificate, 2 August 1948 -1948/30008
    • Alice Catherine McWhinnie, Death Certificate, 22 January 1970 -1970/25618
  • Australian Marriage Index 1788-1950 (Via Ancestry)
    • James Macwhinnie (sic) and Catherine De Saxe, Marriage Certificate, 2 Feb 1905, Port Adelaide, South Australia

Other Websites

  • Fitzroy Research Melbourne – Ongoing research into the history of Fitzroy buildings. Rachel Axton
  • Women Film Pioneers Project
    Bertrand, Ina. “Kate Howarde.” In Jane Gaines, Radha Vatsal, and Monica Dall’Asta, (eds) Women Film Pioneers Project. New York, NY: Columbia University Libraries, 2013. 
  • Australian Variety Theatre Archive
    Clay Djubal: “Elton Black.” 3 April 2021. Accessed online 5 July 2024.
  • Funny As: The Story of New Zealand Comedy
    Peter Downes interview

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

Text

  • Cutten History Committee – Fitzroy History Society (1989) Fitzroy : Melbourne’s first suburb. Hyland House, South Yarra.
  • Elisabeth Kumm: “Theatre in Melbourne 1914-18; the best the brightest and the latest.“ The La Trobe Journal, No 97, March 2016.
  • Miles Lewis (Ed) Brunswick Street lost and found : proceedings of a seminar at Fitzroy. 20 May 2012. Available from Fitzroy History Society pages here.
  • Andrew Pike and Ross Cooper (1981 and 1998): Australian film, 1900-1977 : a guide to feature film production. Oxford University Press.
  • Frank Van Straten (2003) Tivoli. Thomas C Lothian
  • Margaret Williams (1983) Australia on the Popular Stage 1829-1929. Oxford University Press
This site has been selected for preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 The Green Room magazine, 1 June, 1918, P2. Mitchell Library, State Library of New South Wales
↑2 The Herald (Melb) 12 Jul 1918, p1
↑3 Enlarged from a photo in the Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne
↑4 Lewis (Ed) 2012, P63
↑5 They had been living in King William Street when they departed Australia, leaving one married daughter behind
↑6 No 86, the home of William Bennetto, now demolished, was to the left of the photo
↑7 Jewish Herald (Vic) 16 Aug 1889 p3
↑8 Regrettably, all records regarding this important early Melbourne school have been lost or destroyed by the Education Department. The 1985 interview with Irene Goulding is held by the Performing Arts Collection
↑9, ↑11, ↑16 Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne
↑10 See his National Archives of Australia military file, p28
↑12 The Honolulu Republican, 1 Oct 1901, p1
↑13 The Hong Kong Daily Press, 27 December 1907, p17
↑14 The Victoria Daily Times (Victoria BC), 26 June 1913, p5
↑15 Kalgoorlie Miner (WA) 23 July 1900, p8
↑17 “The Gerry Society” was the popular name for the very influential New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children
↑18 A potted version of Alice’s career was given to News (Adelaide), 1 May 1924, p2
↑19 The Evening Star (WA) 9 Feb 1906 p3
↑20 Table Talk (Melb) 29 April 1909, p22
↑21 News (Adelaide) 1 May 1924, p2
↑22 a burlesque version of Romeo and Juliet
↑23 National Library of Australia
↑24 Kumm, 2016
↑25 Van Straten, (2003) p53-57
↑26 Theatre Heritage Australia digital Collection
↑27 State Library of NSW, Mitchell Library
↑28 Table Talk (Melb) 21 Feb 1918, p9
↑29 not the well known US film director with the same name, as the IMDB currently claims
↑30 The Picture Show, 2 August 1919, p13. Mitchell Library, State Library of NSW
↑31 Born in Austria in 1869, Endletsberger had arrived in New Zealand in about 1906. He had been interned during the First World War, but had since built a successful practice
↑32 News (Adelaide) 14 Jan 1924, p6
↑33 Table Talk, 7 Feb 1918, p22
↑34 The Critic (Adelaide) 21 Nov 1923, p11
↑35 Daily Standard (Qld) 19 Sept 1923, p2
↑36 See his article on Elton Black at the Australian Variety Theatre Archive, here
↑37 The Advertiser (Adelaide) 29 Nov 1923, p11
↑38 Dundee Evening Telegraph,15 September 1925, p10
↑39 News (Adelaide) 11 May 1926, p1
↑40 The Stage (London) 6 Nov 1924, p10
↑41 Alice Catherine Bennetto & James McWhinnie, New Zealand Marriage Certificate – 1939/2568
↑42 The Mirror (Perth) 30 Nov 1935, p22
↑43 Auckland Star, 9 August 1939, p22, and Bay of Plenty Beacon, 11 April 1947, p1
↑44 Born Catherine Clarissa Jones, her name at the time was Catherine De Saxe. Her first husband William Henry De Saxe had died in July 1902

Jenny Golder (c1893 – 1928) From Kyneton to Paris

Above and below: Jenny Golder (Rosie Sloman) in a male impersonation act. National Portrait Gallery (UK) Collection. Bassano Ltd, Whole-plate glass negative, 30 October 1925, Creative Commons Licence.
The Five Second version
Jenny Golder, the stage name of Rosie Solomon or Sloman, was an acclaimed Parisian music hall performer in the 1920s. When she took her life in Paris on July 11 1928, her French and British audiences knew of her as Australian-born and indeed she was – the child of two Australians and born in the early 1890s. Like the celebrated dancer Saharet, who had taken the US and Europe by storm twenty-five years before, Jenny’s Australian roots seem to have added an exotic dimension to her public persona. But in reality she had spent only a year or two in Australia before her parents took their family to England, permanently. It is known that she started on stage in the 1910s, and that her breakthrough was appearing in Paris in the early 1920s – “a most versatile, artist, whose studies range from ragtime singing soubrettes to dramatic Italian song stories and male impersonations.“[1]Daily News (London) 3 July 1924, p8

A tumultuous family life forgotten

Jenny Golder was born Rosie Solomon to John Henry Solomon (1846-1902) and Annie Louise Golder (1862-1931). The surname Sloman was adopted by the family in the mid 1890s, while the stage name Jenny Golder was taken from her mother’s surname. Both parents were Australian born. Unfortunately for historians, John and Annie failed to register Rosie’s birth, and most of their other children’s births, as the law required. There are several likely reasons for this, including John’s regular change of address and endless changes of employment. But the most important reason was that John Solomon was already married, to someone else. In 1867 he had married a woman called Kate Gainsborg, while living in Ballarat.[2]Births Deaths & Marriages Victoria. Marriage record 2171/1867 But John Solomon went on to have at least eight children with Annie Golder, including Rosie, and it was most of these births that were unregistered, probably to avoid the stain of illegitimacy. [See also Note 1 below]

Kate Solomon finally sought a divorce from John Solomon in the Victorian Supreme Court in June 1900, when at least some of his double life was publicly revealed.[3]See Herald (Melb) 14 August 1900, p4 The records of the divorce are intriguing – and reading them today it is almost impossible to believe Kate Solomon’s version of finding out about her husband’s long period of infidelity, including the eight children to Annie, whilst she was still in contact with his extended family, and living with one of them.[4]Public Record Office Victoria, Supreme Court Records, Solomon v Solomon, File 1900/60

In the divorce documents and newspaper reports of the early 1890s, John Solomon was described as an auctioneer. In the only existing biography of Jenny Golder, written and published by Alan Black in 2000, he was also identified as a performer, magician and bookmaker, amongst other things, and sometimes known as Johnny Solomon.[5]Black (2000) Pp6-15 Black also identifies him as the same John Solomon who built Sydney’s Criterion Theatre. Solomon also briefly operated a “Royal Museum and Palace of Amusement”, a sort of P.T. Barnum (1810-1891) museum, opposite the Sydney Town Hall in George St.[6]The Sydney Morning Herald, 19 October 1889, p12. Solomon himself also liked the Barnum analogy, and sometimes called himself the “Barnum auctioneer.” See The Advertiser (Adelaide)13 Sep … Continue reading He adopted the surname Sloman about the time he moved to England, in the mid 1890s.

We might think of Solomon as a speculator or entrepreneur, even what Australians today like to call “a colourful character.” When he died in England in 1902, one Sydney paper recalled him as “a man of sanguine temper, and decidedly enterprising, though he was not fated to achieve any very extraordinary success.”[7]Australasian Star (Syd) 9 December 1902, P4

The mystery of the birth of Rosie Sloman

Rosie Sloman’s French death record gives her place of birth as Kyneton, Australia [8]misspelled as Kighton and the date of birth as 14 January 1896. In 1925, Rosie had already told the British magazine Answers that she was born in Kyneton.[9]cited in Black (2000) p6 And again, when she entered the US in June 1927, she listed Kyneton, Australia as her birthplace.[10]Ship’s Manifest, Mauretania, June 1927. In this document she inferred a birth year of 1896

Mollison Street, Kyneton c1912. The Temperance Hall referred to in the image below was in the 3 story hotel at left. [11]Shirley Jones Collection of postcards, State Library of Victoria

The present writer contends there is a strong likelihood that Rosie was born in 1893, although other years have been suggested. Following the family’s move to Britain, the 1901 English census listed Rosie Sloman as an 8 year old, Australian-born student, indicating she was born in 1893.[12]This is the oldest existing official document with her name on it In addition, John Solomon can be traced as working as an auctioneer in Kyneton in early 1893.[13]And there is no evidence he was working in Kyneton in January 1894 or 1896 Following his bankruptcy in Sydney in April 1890 [14]NSW Government Gazette, 18 April 1890, Issue 216, p3248 and subsequent appearance in court for organising Sunday dancing [15]See references to Walker v Solomon at Ausstage and New South Wales Law Reports, he moved to Melbourne. Between March 1892 and February 1893 Solomon was active as an auctioneer, moving the family around as he worked at the larger and more prosperous Victorian country towns not too far from Melbourne – Geelong, Bendigo, Ballarat, Castlemaine and finally Kyneton. In the later part of 1893 he moved on to South Australia – and another period as a roving auctioneer. His modus operandi was to import goods or arrange to sell up goods from debtor’s estates, for well-advertised auctions. Rosie’s time spent in Kyneton was therefore quite short – she was born there because her mother was there, while John was working as an auctioneer for a few months.

John Solomon auctioning goods in Kyneton in early February 1893. [16]The Kyneton Observer, 4 February 1893, p3

On stage in Jenny and Joe

Unfortunately we do not know when and why the family moved to Britain. We might assume the move was necessary because of something that had happened in Australia – perhaps the state of John Solomon’s financial affairs. However, so far there is no definitive evidence of this. The use of the surname Sloman appears to date from the time they moved to England, but even this may be an assumption, as the family seem not to have used the surnames Solomon or Sloman to travel.[17]There is no record of a family of that name arriving in Britain in the late 1890s Perhaps they travelled as the Salmon family – who arrived in England via Cape Town on the Union line ship SS Scot in May 1894. Unfortunately we have no way of confirming this today, and thus, no confirmation of the date they arrived in England.


Grainy photos chart the start of her career. Left: “Rosina Sloman,” one of The Ascot Girls, while appearing at the Tivoli Theatre, Dublin.[18]The Dublin Evening Telegraph, 17 February 1911
Right: Who is it? asked Kinematograph Weekly on 28 August 1913. A week later the paper revealed it was Rosie Sloman, member of The Rag Time Six. [19]Kinematograph Weekly, 4 Sept 1913, p29

Alan Black has found that by 1897, directories indicate John Sloman was living and working in Brighton, East Sussex, while the 1901 UK census shows the family living, at least for a time, in Reigate, Surrey. After a lifetime of moving around, the Slomans finally settled in North London – first Kentish Town and then Highbury. This is where Rosie Sloman grew up, and learned to dance and sing. John Sloman died in London in 1902, a year after finally marrying Annie Golder.[20]UK General Registry Office, Marriage Certificate John Sloman and Annie Golder, 16 May, 1901

Unfortunately much of Rosie Sloman’s early career remains a mystery and even Alan Black’s access to scrap books kept by Rosie’s younger, English-born sister Miriam (later a ‘transformational” or quick change dancer, known professionally as Muriel Glen), sheds little light on the sequence of events in her life. The common use of stage names in preference to birth names merely compounds the challenge of researching her professional life. However newspaper reports show one of her earliest appearances on stage – as “Rosina Sloman” – was a variety act called The Ascot Girls, in 1911. The song and dance act toured, and at Dublin’s Tivoli Theatre “brought down the house.”[21]Music Hall and Theatre Review,16 February 1911, p13

Yet, before this appearance in 1911, there is evidence she may have already begun a stage career with “Joe Bowden”, a comedian, dancer and singer, in the later part of 1910. The act was called Jenny and Joe. The Jenny and Joe act toured South Africa’s Grand Theatre circuit for five months in mid-1912[22]The Music Hall and Theatre Review, 20 June 1912, p394 and the November 1912 manifest for RMS Saxon lists a group of Music Hall artistes returning to Southampton from Natal, including Joe Bowden and a “Jenny Bowden.” Rosie did marry Joe Bowden, but not until she was touring with him in Lancashire in 1914.[23]UK General Registry Office, Marriage certificate Joseph William Bowden and Rosie Sloman, 5 December 1914 Of course, it is not possible to be certain whether Rosie Sloman was always the Jenny part of the Jenny and Joe act.

The Rag Time Six in 1912-13 featured (left to right) visiting US vaudevillians Frank A Vardon (1877-1950), Harry H Perry (1882-1961) and “Wilber”. Rosie Sloman is the girl at right. Photo courtesy Gregg Miner at Harpguitars.net[24]Harpguitars.net – Wilbur Wanted

That Rosie Sloman appeared in another act called The Rag Time Six in late 1912 is well established. Led by US vaudevillians Frank A Vardon (1877-1950), Harry H Perry (1882-1961) and a third team member called “Wilber,” the act captured the British fascination with rag time, but seems to have involved a continuously changing lineup. Gregg Miner has established that over the life of the act, “Wilber” was more than one performer and the women in the group were also changed.[25]See Miner (2020) Chapters 5 & 6 However, Rosie Sloman can be identified with confidence in the photo above.

In 1913, Rosie appeared in several of the Selsior company’s “dancing films”, performing with Harry Perry. These dancing shorts were designed to be screened as part of a variety bill, accompanied by a live orchestra, who followed the direction of a filmed conductor, visible in the lower corner of the screen. Sadly neither of these films survive.[26]The Cowboy Twist and
The Spanish-American Quickstep. See Miner (2020) p72 for a rare surviving still from one of the films, featuring Rosie. See also Bottomore in Brown and Davison, (2013) P163-182

Jenny and Joe touring in 1913[27]Melton Mowbray Times, 12 Dec 1913, p4 and 1916.[28]Devon and Exeter Gazette, 28 Aug 1916, p2

The Jenny and Joe act can be found in British music hall bookings consistently through to the end of 1916, with their last appearance in 1917. Dancing, singing, comedy patter were the duo’s routine, although reports of their final appearance together – in a piece entitled Chess So, suggests a musical farce.[29]Merthyr Express (Wales) 7 July 1917, p6 The couple had also performed on tour in South Africa in early 1915, presumably as Jenny and Joe, and they quite possibly toured internationally again at the end of the decade.[30]Ship’s manifest Dunvegan Castle, returning to Southampton in May 1915


Becoming Jenny Golder

Jenny Golder (Rosie Sloman). National Portrait Gallery (UK) Collection, Unknown photographer, mid 1920s. Creative Commons Licence.

Rosie Sloman appeared on stage as Jenny Golder in Brussels, in early 1920. She was no longer in partnership with Joe Bowden, but whether this means something had happened to her marriage, we no longer know. Her first performances at the Alhambra theatre in Brussels have been confirmed by several sources, including the memoirs of theatre producer Jacques Charles (1882-1971), De Gaby Deslys à Mistinguett, published in about 1930.[31]From Gaby Deslys to Mistinguett. Cited in Black, 2000, p13-15 By October 1920, she was in several acts in the Jacques Charles revue Paris qui Jazz, at the Casino de Paris. This featured popular stars Harry Pilcer(1885-1961) and Mistinguett (1875-1956), with whom Jenny would be increasingly associated over the next eight years. Oo-La-La! Oui Oui!, a popular American piece, may have made its appearance in her act at this time. Jenny was introduced in this first Paris outing as the famous Australian “eccentric” – which could mean many things – but often meant a dancer with moves that were highly individualistic, sensational and daring. And indeed, over the next six years, she steadily built her reputation in Paris revues and music hall as a comedian and dancer.[32]Black (2000) Chapter 2, pps16-25

Ruby and Jessel’s popular wartime Oo La La, Oui Oui, sung by Jenny Golder (and others) c1920-1921. Author’s Collection.

In late 1921, London’s Tatler magazine’s Paris correspondent reported on Jenny Golder, the emerging Parisian star, who was then performing in La Belle De Paris at the Apollo. The journalist was apparently unaware that Jenny Golder had already been on stage – for ten years:

Jenny Golder in 1924. [33]The Sketch 23 July 1924. Illustrated London News Group

“There’s an excessively entertaining show at the Apollo, in which a charming looking young creature with legs, eyes and teeth of the first water, named Jenny Golder, hails from Australia, murders French, dances ‘squisitely, and had a success that would have been greater still if she dropped a few exaggerated vulgarities and could remain more than three minutes at a stretch without winking.”[34]The Tatler, (UK), 9 Nov 1921, p190

In June 1924 Jenny Golder returned to England to perform again – first stop being the Holborn Empire. The Era introduced her to readers as the “chic” Jenny Golder from the Folies Bergère.[35]The Era, 4 June 1924, p13 The Stage also reported on Jenny Golder, “apparently an English girl, who…is described as the “international fantasy artist from the Folies Bergère“:

She gives most infectiously gay interpretations of bright and breezy items that stamp her as a comedienne of much ability, while her agile dances, some of a burlesque character, are very effectively performed, and make one wish for an extension of this branch of her work. Miss Golder makes her changes so that they can be seen in silhouette on a white backcloth, but this feature of her act is the only thing that is cheap and unnecessary.[36]The Stage, 5 June 1924, p12

As Alan Black has shown, the two revues at the Théâtre le Palace that ran between 1926 and 1928 were the great triumphs of Jenny Golder’s career. “Her anglicised French was part of her charm. Parisians loved it. There was a comic scene in the first of these revues where an Australian girl (Jenny) and an American man (Harry Pilcer) fail to understand one another, and have to be helped out by an Italian (Odoardo Spadaro)”[37]Black, 2000, p23 It is also at this time that Jenny and Harry Pilcer introduced the Black Bottom dance to audiences. Surviving footage of the couple dancing this successor to the Charleston can be seen here.

Jenny Golder poster – 1925. Henri Chachoin, Paris. [38]Gallica, Bibliothèque nationale de France

Rosie Sloman’s death

Rosie Sloman shot herself on the evening of 11 July 1928, in her Paris apartment. There was extraordinary press speculation at the time about why she suicided, much of it not very accurate. Australian newspapers also “discovered her” at this time and speculated that she had been about to accept a contract for the country’s Tivoli circuit. Perhaps this was true. [39]But Australian news reports were amongst the most inaccurate. Consider The Daily News (Perth)14 Jul 1928, p7 or The Sun (Syd) 16 Jul 1928, p1

Much was made of a letter she received just before her suicide. It has been speculated that this may have been a letter from her lover, Andre Perugia (1893-1977). That Perugia was a lover seems to have been well known by journalists at the time.[40]Also verified by his accompanying Rosie on a holiday to the US in June 1927, as the manifest for the RMS Mauretania shows. They stayed at the iconic Plaza Hotel in New York It is true that in December 1927 she underwent a knee operation and some accounts attributed the suicide to despondency over this. However, Alan Black’s conclusion, written after considering the many accounts written in French and English and much original material, still remains the most plausible. Rosie Sloman was ill, perhaps clinically depressed.

Amongst the journalists and writers in attendance at her funeral were many of the stars of French revue and music hall – including Mistinguett, Maurice Chevalier and Harry Pilcer. Pearl White, the US movie star and a friend was also there, as was Joe Bowden, her estranged husband.[41]The Daily News (Perth) 17 Jul 1928, p7. For a full account of the funeral see Black (2000) Chapter 5 p33-41

The San Francisco Examiner gives readers a particularly fanciful version of Rosie’s death. [42]The San Francisco Examiner Sept 16, 1928 p114

Jenny Golder as reported in Australia in 1922.[43]The Sun News-Pictorial (Melb)10 Nov 1922, p8

That Australian newspapers were slow to identify who Rosie Sloman/Jenny Golder was, is not hard to understand. Her Australian-born parents had clearly gone to some effort to re-start their lives in England. But more importantly, Rosie Sloman almost certainly thought of herself as a Briton, as so many Australians of her generation did. In fact, this was the case legally as well as emotionally. The Australian colonies did not federate until 1901, so Rosie had been born in the colony of Victoria, not the Commonwealth of Australia.[44]And it was only in the 1920s that the member nations of the British Empire that had been granted self-government; the Irish Free State, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and South Africa, were defined … Continue reading

Despite the legalities, the term “Australian” was still used quite freely, as a casual identifier for someone born in one of the Australian colonies. Thus Rosie Sloman/Jenny Golder could be so described, when Australian journalists discovered her.

There is little doubt that for years Australian newspapers were stretched in keeping up with public figures, who had moved overseas, who had been born in an Australian colony, or not born in one at all. Errol Flynn the Tasmanian could be described as Irish-born, a fiction from studios that some Australian journalists unwittingly went along with, while Anglo-Indian Merle Oberon could successfully claim all her life to be Tasmanian.


Note 1 – John and Annie and those missing birth certificates

John Solomon and Annie Golder registered the birth of at least one child, but only because they had to. The circumstances were tragic. 6 month old Ruby Solomon died of influenza on 18 March 1892, while the family lived in Vale Street, St. Kilda – a southern suburb of Melbourne.[45]Births Deaths & Marriages Victoria. Death record 4262/1892 Quite clearly, John and Annie were forced to register the child’s birth – which had taken place on 16 September 1891[46]Births Deaths & Marriages Victoria. Birth record 8315/1892 – in order for a death certificate to be issued and a burial at St. Kilda cemetery to take place. The birth and death documents were registered on the same day. On both documents, an official had written “Illegitimate,” which at the time was a social stain that families were desperate to avoid. However, as noted, John Sloman and Annie Louise Golder finally married in England in 1901.


Nick Murphy
June 2024


References

Thanks

  • Special thanks to Alan Black, who reached out to the author in 2026, and also shared his additional research on Joe Bowden. His monograph on Jenny Golder is recommended to interested readers. It also contains a number of photos of Jenny at different times of her life.

Primary Sources

  • National Portrait Gallery (UK)
  • Bibliothèque nationale de France, Gallica
  • National Library of Australia, Trove
  • British Newspaper Archive
  • Ancestry.com
  • Victoria, Births Deaths & Marriages
  • ProQuest Historical Newspapers
  • Newspapers.com
  • Hathitrust.com
  • The Internet Archive

Film

Text

  • Alan Black (2000) The Life of Jenny Golder. Paris and London in the 1920s. RPM Reprographics.
    [Note – unfortunately Alan Black’s monograph is out of print. However it is held in four national libraries – The State Library of Victoria in Melbourne Australia, Bibliothèque Nationale de France in Paris, The British Library and National Art Library at the V&A Museum in London]

  • Stephen Bottomore: “Selsior dancing Films 1912-1917” in Julie Brown & Annette Davison (Eds) (2013) The Sound of the Silents. Oxford University Press.
  • Jeffrey H. Jackson: “Music-Halls and the Assimilation of Jazz in 1920s Paris” in Journal of Popular Culture, Vol 34, Issue 2, fall 2005. Oxford.
  • Gregg Miner (2020) The Curious Career of Vardon, Perry and Wilber(s)? A Vaudevillian Mystery. Harp Guitar Music
  • J.P. Wearing (2013) The London Stage 1920-1929. A Calendar of Productions, Performers, and Personnel, Second Edition. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Other online Sources

This site has been selected for preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 Daily News (London) 3 July 1924, p8
↑2 Births Deaths & Marriages Victoria. Marriage record 2171/1867
↑3 See Herald (Melb) 14 August 1900, p4
↑4 Public Record Office Victoria, Supreme Court Records, Solomon v Solomon, File 1900/60
↑5 Black (2000) Pp6-15
↑6 The Sydney Morning Herald, 19 October 1889, p12. Solomon himself also liked the Barnum analogy, and sometimes called himself the “Barnum auctioneer.” See The Advertiser (Adelaide)13 Sep 1893, p8
↑7 Australasian Star (Syd) 9 December 1902, P4
↑8 misspelled as Kighton
↑9 cited in Black (2000) p6
↑10 Ship’s Manifest, Mauretania, June 1927. In this document she inferred a birth year of 1896
↑11 Shirley Jones Collection of postcards, State Library of Victoria
↑12 This is the oldest existing official document with her name on it
↑13 And there is no evidence he was working in Kyneton in January 1894 or 1896
↑14 NSW Government Gazette, 18 April 1890, Issue 216, p3248
↑15 See references to Walker v Solomon at Ausstage and New South Wales Law Reports
↑16 The Kyneton Observer, 4 February 1893, p3
↑17 There is no record of a family of that name arriving in Britain in the late 1890s
↑18 The Dublin Evening Telegraph, 17 February 1911
↑19 Kinematograph Weekly, 4 Sept 1913, p29
↑20 UK General Registry Office, Marriage Certificate John Sloman and Annie Golder, 16 May, 1901
↑21 Music Hall and Theatre Review,16 February 1911, p13
↑22 The Music Hall and Theatre Review, 20 June 1912, p394
↑23 UK General Registry Office, Marriage certificate Joseph William Bowden and Rosie Sloman, 5 December 1914
↑24 Harpguitars.net – Wilbur Wanted
↑25 See Miner (2020) Chapters 5 & 6
↑26 The Cowboy Twist and
The Spanish-American Quickstep. See Miner (2020) p72 for a rare surviving still from one of the films, featuring Rosie. See also Bottomore in Brown and Davison, (2013) P163-182
↑27 Melton Mowbray Times, 12 Dec 1913, p4
↑28 Devon and Exeter Gazette, 28 Aug 1916, p2
↑29 Merthyr Express (Wales) 7 July 1917, p6
↑30 Ship’s manifest Dunvegan Castle, returning to Southampton in May 1915
↑31 From Gaby Deslys to Mistinguett. Cited in Black, 2000, p13-15
↑32 Black (2000) Chapter 2, pps16-25
↑33 The Sketch 23 July 1924. Illustrated London News Group
↑34 The Tatler, (UK), 9 Nov 1921, p190
↑35 The Era, 4 June 1924, p13
↑36 The Stage, 5 June 1924, p12
↑37 Black, 2000, p23
↑38 Gallica, Bibliothèque nationale de France
↑39 But Australian news reports were amongst the most inaccurate. Consider The Daily News (Perth)14 Jul 1928, p7 or The Sun (Syd) 16 Jul 1928, p1
↑40 Also verified by his accompanying Rosie on a holiday to the US in June 1927, as the manifest for the RMS Mauretania shows. They stayed at the iconic Plaza Hotel in New York
↑41 The Daily News (Perth) 17 Jul 1928, p7. For a full account of the funeral see Black (2000) Chapter 5 p33-41
↑42 The San Francisco Examiner Sept 16, 1928 p114
↑43 The Sun News-Pictorial (Melb)10 Nov 1922, p8
↑44 And it was only in the 1920s that the member nations of the British Empire that had been granted self-government; the Irish Free State, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and South Africa, were defined as being “Dominions” – with equal standing but a common allegiance to the British crown. Further changes took place over the next 50 years to define Australian sovereignty – a slow process
↑45 Births Deaths & Marriages Victoria. Death record 4262/1892
↑46 Births Deaths & Marriages Victoria. Birth record 8315/1892

Lois Green (1914-c.2006) – An Australian Nanette

Above: Lois Green c1939. The photo was taken about the time she appeared in Ken Hall’s Gone to the Dogs. State Library of Victoria Collection.

The Five Second Version
Lois Green left Australia in 1939 to try her luck on the London stage. Over the previous 10 years she had successfully built a reputation in musical comedy and had even starred in one of the few Australian feature films of the late 30s. These experiences established her reputation as an skilled actress, dancer and singer. But after only a year in London she left the country with a shadowy figure, an Australian-born commission agent, who she married while in South Africa. By 1944 she was no longer married and was working for ENSA in Egypt. By late 1945 she was back in London again, specialising in revues and pantomime. Nanette in No No Nanette became one of her signature roles, a musical she performed many times. She married a second time in 1947 and made a brief visit to perform in Australia. Her final roles in British pantomime occurred in the later 1950s. She and her second husband retired to the Isle of Man.

Lois’s 1947 comments about Australian men being “extremely tiresome” are unusual for the era.

Above: Lois Green and fellow dancer Frances Ogilvy on the cover of Table Talk in 1932.[1]Table Talk, 25 Feb 1932, P1

Growing up in Australia.1914-1939

Born in Tongue Street Footscray in December 1914, Mabel Lois Green was the only child of Beaumont Hamilton Green, a carriage-builder, and Mabel nee Thretheway, the daughter of a local grocer. The family moved to leafy Hotham Street, East Melbourne in 1925, coincidentally quite near the home of young Joan MacGillicuddy (who would one day become Joan Winfield in Hollywood).

Lois danced from a very young age, attending the school run by Mrs William Green (no relation) and her daughter Florrie in Fitzroy. By the mid 1920s, she was dancing under the tuition of the very well known Jeannie Brennan, who had a close association with JC Williamson’s, the Australian theatre monopoly. Years later, her mother elaborated – she had also studied singing with Mary Campbell and later with Carrie Cairnduff, and took elocution lessons from Victor Trotman.[2]The Herald (Melb) 30 Jan 1947, p17

This training translated into exciting opportunities for a young person like Lois, who had her heart set on the stage. In 1929, she impressed visiting Mieczyslaw Pianowski, Anna Pavolva‘s partner, who reputedly told her mother: For a child of fourteen and a half years, your daughter is, in my opinion, the most remarkable example of dancing ability I have ever encountered. It would be a pity to keep so rare a talent in Australia.[3]The Herald (Melb) 26 June 1929, p5 If this really was said to her mother, then the expectations of a successful future were high.

Lois Green grew up dancing in public, thanks to her teachers, parents and enthusiastic Melbourne newspapers – 1918, 1920, 1929.[4]Left to right – Melbourne Punch, 26 Dec 1918, P20; Table Talk, 16 Dec, 1920, P19; Table Talk, 4 July 1929, P6

Although only 16, her first role professionally appears to have been in the ballet pieces for a revival of the musical comedy The Maid of the Mountains, with Gladys Moncrieff.[5]Sunday Times (Sydney) 1 June 1930, P2 From 1930 she was almost continually in employment for J.C Williamsons. The roles she featured in brought her prominence, and contact with emerging and established Australian actors. For example, in the early 1930s she was appearing with a young Robert Helpmann in Katinka, Sinbad and Happy and Glorious. [6]Ausstage database. Helpmann was six years her senior. She was in the cast of the original Australian musical Blue Mountain Melody, (which enjoyed a reasonable run in Sydney and Melbourne in 1934) with Cyril Ritchard, Madge Elliot, Agnes Doyle and Don Nicol. In time, she happily acknowledged the assistance and mentoring of many of these experienced performers had provided her.[7]The Sydney Morning Herald, 20 April, 1939 p31

It was however, her leading role in No, No, Nanette in 1938 that brought her to national prominence – with Smith’s Weekly announcing that Lois’ place “as No. 1 musical comedy lead in Australia seems to be assured.”[8]Smith’s Weekly (Sydney), 10 Sep 1938, p24 She was still only 24 when it was announced she had a role in an upcoming Cinesound film, featuring comedian George Wallace.

24 year old Lois making up for the title role in No, No, Nanette, September 1938. Australian Performing Arts Collections, Arts Centre Melbourne.

An Australian film and the London stage. 1939 – 1940

Despite its rather silly premise, Ken G Hall’s Gone to the Dogs proved to be a successful film. Cheerful, amusing and accompanied by some catchy songs, it made a clear profit in Australia and was exported for release in Britain.[9]Pike & Cooper (1980) p242 Lois Green played the ingenue role (as Jean MacAllister) with a confidence and ability not found amongst many of her Australian contemporaries. She demonstrated she could sing, dance and act, and projected an attractive and confident persona on the screen.[10]Reid 2007, p91-2 But even before filming began, her plan to try her luck in London had been announced.

Lois Green with George Wallace in the main musical number of Gone to the Dogs (1939). Source of screengrabs – Youtube
Lois singing during the main musical number of Gone to the Dogs. Also audible in this clip is George Wallace.

In April 1939, Lois departed Australia on the Matson liner Monterey, with her first stop being to “look in on Hollywood,” before going on to London. Also on board was fellow JC Williamson’s actor Enid Hollins, who was on the same journey. Although not close friends, both women seem to have matched up their travel plans, heading to the Ambassador Hotel in Los Angeles. It was really just a “look in on Hollywood” as Lois had reached London only a few months later. She appears in the September 1939 English census, living at a boarding house in Chelsea. Her first stage work in London was in the chorus of All Clear, a “thoroughly mediocre” revue that had a run at Queen’s Theatre.[11]The Spectator (London) 12 January 1940 cited in Wearing, 2014, p774 She understudied for Beatrice Lillie, the show’s lead.

Soon however, she had a job singing at the famous Cafe De Paris in Piccadilly, part of an act with comedian Fred Emney.[12]Sunday Mirror (London) 31 March 1940, P23 She also appeared in at least one BBC radio broadcast – a selection of songs from All Clear – the first of many performances for the BBC.

South Africa, the war, a marriage and return to London. 1940-45

Evening Standard (London) 23 March 1940, P6

Despite her emerging career in Britain, during the later part of 1940 she disappeared completely from the London theatre scene. Records show that on 1st August 1940, she boarded the Llangibby Castle,(a Union Castle liner) for passage to South Africa, an unusual decision given that U-boat attacks on British shipping were already occurring. She had previously refused to discuss her personal life –“Lets leave my private life out of this” she bluntly told an Australian journalist on the eve of leaving Australia [13]Woman’s Weekly (Australia) 18 March 1939, P3, but this otherwise puzzling change of direction appears to have been for just that reason. Her journey to South Africa was undertaken with a 36 year old commission agent who went by the name William John Munden, and whom she had known since at least 1939. The couple married on 16 May 1942, at Johannesburg Anglican Cathedral.[14]presumably St Mary’s Cathedral(Also see Note 1 below)

In later comments Lois mentioned work in pantomimes and another run of No, No, Nanette during her three and a half years in South Africa, but gave no other details, except to say that South Africa was a “very young country… a youthful Australia.”[15]The Age (Melb)12 Feb 1947, p6 Of her four years with Munden, nothing was ever said to journalists.

Lois re-appeared in Cairo in mid 1944, now performing in ENSA productions, including No, No, Nanette, again.[16]ENSA was the British Entertainments National Service Association At the war’s end she was back in London again as though nothing had happened – and soon in a good run of the pantomime Cinderella at the Adelphi Theatre, playing the title role and receiving very positive reviews.[17]The Observer (London) 30 December, 1945 P3 She also made some appearances for the BBC – on radio and in the early days of live TV, after it re-started in June 1946. Desperate for material for the new medium, the BBC borrowed heavily from variety theatre.

Above: Lois Green with Royal Australian Air Force personnel in Cairo, while performing in No, No, Nanette. c1944. Photo – Laurence Craddock Le Guay, Australian War Memorial collection.

Follow the Girls in Australia. 1946-7

In late 1946 Lois was flown to Australia by JC Williamsons, to perform in the musical comedy Follow the Girls. Like some other Australians who had been unable to see family because of war, the chance to visit her parents in East Melbourne was probably also an important attraction. Her contract was a very generous £70 per week,[18]about $AU5,100 in 2024 money doubtless negotiated for her by her London agent, Fosters. Follow the Girls was a lightweight story that involved some “US sailors, a strip-tease artist (Bubbles La Marr – played by Lois) and some espionage.” Melbourne’s Argus also reported that the feature of the production was “dainty Lois Green’s re-introduction to the Melbourne stage, who, during her absence, has undergone a startling metamorphosis from sweet ingenue to wisecracking, and slightly hardboiled, comedienne.”[19]The Argus (Melb) 17 Feb 1947 p6 The newspaper reviewer felt Lois was playing well out of character. All the same, the play had a respectable run. It wrapped on 2 May 1947, when Lois departed for England.

Above: Lois Green and Don Nicol in Follow the Girls, His Majesty’s Theatre Melbourne,1947. Photograph by Hal Williamson, Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.

While in Australia, Lois was sought out for comment on her experiences and opinions, as were other Australian actors who returned post-war. Although her private life continued to be off limits in interviews, she ventured intriguing and some might argue, insightful comments about Australian men. “They are extremely tiresome both in their dressing and their manners… The Australian man is fundamentally a grand person. But he is so intent on playing the role of great open spaces, heart of gold beneath rough exterior, that one cannot be bothered searching for the alleged heart of gold.” [20]Undated Australian newspaper cutting c 1947, in the Bernard Woodruff Scrapbook, Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne She need not have worried about Australian men. Hugh Eagleton, a British businessman, followed her by plane to Australia and soon after her return to London in May 1947, the couple married at the Westminster registry office.[21]Marriage Certificate, Hugh Falkener Eagleton and Lois Green otherwise Munden, 21 May 1947, UK General Register Office

British Career after 1947

No, No, Nanette being produced for live TV, again, in March 1948 [22]Radio Times, 28 March – 3 April 1948, p26

Lois was involved in a string of TV and radio programs after her return to London and again, these include televised live variety programs. The BBC Genome lists Floor Show (November 1947), The Passing Show (May 1948) and Mirth and Melody (Sept 1949). However, it was performing in Christmas season pantomimes, including some that toured Britain, that she became best known for.

Puss in Boots. The 1949-50 Christmas Panto at the Palladium.[23]Author’s Collection

Even at the time, pantomime was not to everyone’s taste. In January 1950, one London theatre critic complained that “every year… [the panto season] is the occasion for the worst singing and acting and the most puerile humour that we ever have to sit through.” Puss in Boots, then playing at the Palladium and starring Tommy Trinder, Zoe Gail and Lois, was acknowledged as a spectacular, but not much more. Lois (as Princess Sonia) and Betty Frankiss (as Colin) did “their best with the scanty romantics… [while] Tommy Trinder… appeared to be satisfied with a range of jokes which would have reduced even a radio studio audience to numbness.”[24]Truth (London) 6 January 1950, p12 But pantomime always had an audience and remains an important part of the British theatre tradition today.

Lois’s performances in Cinderella, Dick Whittington and Puss in Boots were all televised in the late 1940s and early 1950s, although none of these early TV versions seem to have survived into the 21st century. She was also a regular in revues, and travelled with a Tommy Trinder troupe to South Africa to perform panto, including Cinderella in early 1951. The Stage reported Lois Green made “the ideal Cinderella, bringing out the charm and piquancy of the character, and at times displaying a pleasant sense of comedy.”[25]The Stage (London) 15 February 1951, p4 Cinderella was amongst her last roles. She appeared in it again with Harry Seacombe, touring Britain in the mid 1950s.

Tommy Trinder, Lois Green and Barbara Perry in the 1950 revue Starlight Rendezvous [26]The Stage (London) 27 July 1950, p7

Her postwar career included Noël Coward’s musical After the Ball. Based on Oscar Wilde’s Lady Windermere’s Fan; it was directed by fellow Australian Robert Helpmann. Lois had a supporting role as Lady Plymdale. Although reviews varied, it had a decent season of 188 performances at the Globe from June -November 1954.[27]Wearing, 2014, p310-311

Lois In After the Ball at the Globe in 1954.[28]The Sketch (London) 28 July 1954, P46. Illustrated London News Group

Unfortunately, of Lois’ later life we know little. Her last performances were in a Glasgow run of Cinderella in 1956, by which time she was aged 42, and perhaps less likely to be offered principal girl roles in panto. Regrettably, she was never interviewed about her 25 years of performance – the Australian tradition of quickly forgetting about those who have departed seems to have occurred, yet again. Lois and Hugh Eagleton lived for many years in South Kensington, but later in life moved to the Isle of Man. According to several online sources, Lois died there in 2006, although no confirmation could be found for this account.


Lois wearing a Norman Hartnell gown for Follow the Girls.[29]Australian Performing Arts Collection

Note 1 – The intriguing William John Munden
On his 1942 South African marriage certificate, William John Munden claimed to be of Australian birth, but he does not appear in any of the available Australian state birth databases, electoral rolls, or directories. He does appear in a few UK and US passenger documents of 1939-40, where he gave his birthplace as Orange in New South Wales, and his date of birth as 27 August 1903. He also appeared in the 1939 British census, living in the same Chelsea boarding house as Lois. When he visited New York in April 1939, he was able to demonstrate to US customs that he had the extraordinary amount of $US3000 available (about $US65,000 in 2024 money). Most visitors to the US at the time were content to show they had the required $US50. Munden disappeared from the historical record following the marriage in Johannesburg. Lois’s marriage certificate stated that she had divorced Munden.


Nick Murphy
May 2024


References

Thanks

  • Claudia Funder at the Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.

Text

  • Ken G Hall (1980) Australian Film, The Inside Story. Summit Books, Australia
  • Andrew Pike & Ross Cooper (1980) Australian Film 1900-1977. Oxford University Press/AFI
  • John Howard Reid (2007) Hollywood’s Classic Comedies. Lulu.com
  • J. P. Wearing (2014) The London Stage 1930-1939: A Calendar of Productions, Performances and Personnel. Lanham, Maryland. Rowman and Littlefield Publishers
  • J. P. Wearing (1991) The London Stage 1940-1949: A Calendar of Plays and Players. 2 Vols. The Scarecrow Press Inc. Metuchen, N.J and London.
  • J. P. Wearing (2014) The London Stage 1950-1959: A Calendar of Productions, Performances and Personnel. Lanham, Maryland. Rowman and Littlefield Publishers

Film

  • Gone to the Dogs (1939) Australian Screen. National Film & Sound Archive (3 clips available Online)
  • Gone to the Dogs (1939) Trekxx Channel @ Youtube (Online)
  • History of Australian Cinema 1896-1940. Episode 3. Now You’re Talking 1930-1940. Film Australia (2011)

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

Australian Theatre Heritage – On Stage

Online databases

This site has been selected for preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 Table Talk, 25 Feb 1932, P1
↑2 The Herald (Melb) 30 Jan 1947, p17
↑3 The Herald (Melb) 26 June 1929, p5
↑4 Left to right – Melbourne Punch, 26 Dec 1918, P20; Table Talk, 16 Dec, 1920, P19; Table Talk, 4 July 1929, P6
↑5 Sunday Times (Sydney) 1 June 1930, P2
↑6 Ausstage database. Helpmann was six years her senior
↑7 The Sydney Morning Herald, 20 April, 1939 p31
↑8 Smith’s Weekly (Sydney), 10 Sep 1938, p24
↑9 Pike & Cooper (1980) p242
↑10 Reid 2007, p91-2
↑11 The Spectator (London) 12 January 1940 cited in Wearing, 2014, p774
↑12 Sunday Mirror (London) 31 March 1940, P23
↑13 Woman’s Weekly (Australia) 18 March 1939, P3
↑14 presumably St Mary’s Cathedral
↑15 The Age (Melb)12 Feb 1947, p6
↑16 ENSA was the British Entertainments National Service Association
↑17 The Observer (London) 30 December, 1945 P3
↑18 about $AU5,100 in 2024 money
↑19 The Argus (Melb) 17 Feb 1947 p6
↑20 Undated Australian newspaper cutting c 1947, in the Bernard Woodruff Scrapbook, Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne
↑21 Marriage Certificate, Hugh Falkener Eagleton and Lois Green otherwise Munden, 21 May 1947, UK General Register Office
↑22 Radio Times, 28 March – 3 April 1948, p26
↑23 Author’s Collection
↑24 Truth (London) 6 January 1950, p12
↑25 The Stage (London) 15 February 1951, p4
↑26 The Stage (London) 27 July 1950, p7
↑27 Wearing, 2014, p310-311
↑28 The Sketch (London) 28 July 1954, P46. Illustrated London News Group
↑29 Australian Performing Arts Collection

Agnes Doyle (1905-1992) From Nymagee to New York

Agnes Doyle in November 1930 while performing in Sydney in Op O’ Me Thumb. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne.

The Five Second version
During her lifetime, Agnes Doyle found her way from a remote regional town in outback New South Wales to the New York stage. She was a popular favourite with audiences in Australia in the 1920s and early 1930s, and almost continuously in work. Like many of her contemporaries, she left Australia to “try her luck.” She enjoyed some success on the US stage, especially in a long tour of Yes My Darling Daughter, but it appears her career never took off, as had been expected. She appeared on US TV in the early days of live-to-air programming in the mid 1950s. Sometime in the late 1950s she took on an important role for JC Williamsons, the Australian theatrical company, acting as their agent in New York. In this role she negotiated contracts and royalty arrangements. She died in New Jersey in 1992.
Agnes in 1930 [1]The Bulletin 26 Nov 1930, P18

In remote Australia

Agnes Doyle was born in Nymagee, a remote copper mining town over 600 kilometres north-west of Sydney, in late December 1905. Her father Michael was a copper smelter, her mother Ada a local woman – Agnes being the third of three children. Unfortunately, deep unhappiness marred her childhood. When Agnes was very young, her parents went through a bitter separation and divorce. Custody of Agnes and her older siblings was granted to Michael, who moved the family to nearby Cobar – a much larger mining town, in 1917.[2]As with so many divorce documents of this time, a great deal was written but much remains unstated. See Divorce papers; Michael Doyle – Ada Doyle, 1912-1913, New South Wales State Archives The children all started performing even while living at Nymagee,[3]Cobar Herald (NSW) 9 December 1913, P13 but it was at Cobar that Agnes and older sister Annie shone as a young singers.[4]Western Age (NSW), 31 Jul 1917, P3 (See Note 1 below regarding her family circumstances)

Nymagee, New South Wales, with school students visible at left. Undated photo taken before 1917. Mitchell Library, State Library of New South Wales

On stage in Australia

Agnes’s first notable success on stage was as a dancer in Sydney in August 1926. With dance partner Jack Lyons, she went on to win at state and then in Australia-wide amateur dance competitions.[5]The Sun (Syd) 28 Nov 1926, P31. There is evidence that Agnes subsequently taught dancing at Melbourne’s Green Mill Dance Hall in the late 1920s. See Table Talk (Melb) 21 Mar 1929, P64 Unfortunately, where she learned to dance was never explained and what dramatic training she received is also unclear. But she had success on stage from a young age. In 1927 she was appearing in Leon Gordon‘s touring production of The Green Hat with Judith Anderson.[6]The Sun (Syd) 3 Jul 1927, P38 By early 1929, she was touring Australian towns, now in a leading role in The Patsy, with Bert Bailey.

Dancing partnership Jack Lyons and Agnes Doyle in 1926.[7]Sunday Times (Syd) 24 Oct 1926, P26

Interviewed while touring in The Patsy in Western Australia in April 1929, the twenty-four year old Agnes said exactly what might be expected of very young Australian actors of the era – “Of course, I’m dying to get to London, and I’m hoping to go in December… I adore the stage… and have always been anxious to take up that life.” And in language also so typical of the time, the Perth newspaper added: “Though her association with the stage has been comparatively brief, Miss Doyle has already made solid progress towards the top of the stage ladder, and there seems little doubt that her talents, so obvious to those who have already seen the show, [The Patsy] combined with her ambition… will carry her further.”[8]The Daily News (WA) 2 Apr 1929, P1 A Sydney Truth review of her role in the comedy This Thing Called Love in October 1930 was equally effusive. Her performance as the “inconsequential little idiot” Dolly Garrett, was “sheer joy”.[9]Truth (Syd) 12 Oct 1930, P7

Left: Agnes Doyle in Eliza Comes To Stay (1930) Photograph – Walker Studios. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne.
Right: Agnes Doyle and John Wood in Hayfever (1931) or While Parents Sleep (1932). The Marriner Theatre Archive, Melbourne.

The AusStage database entry for Agnes Doyle, which is not definitive, charts her busy schedule in the early 1930s, a reflection of her great popularity with Australian audiences. Her surviving JC Williamson contract also demonstrates how much “the Firm” valued her.[10]JC Williamson’s was the large theatrical firm that dominated Australasia In late 1933, the agreement was to pay her a working salary of £12 per week and then retain her on £4 per work when not working. It was generous pay for a woman in her late twenties. By comparison, the Australian minimum wage at the time was about £3 and 7 shillings.[11]Agnes Doyle contract with JC Williamsons. Dated 14 Dec 1933. Courtesy Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne

Agnes in Ivor Novello’s Fresh Fields in 1934. She took the same role for its New York run in 1936.[12]Table Talk (Melb), 31 May 1934, P23

Her stage work brought her into contact with an eclectic mix of visiting and Australian performers, but notably there were a large number who would also try their luck overseas in the 1930s – John Wood and Campbell Copelin, Mona Barrie, Lois Green, Mary MacGregor, Dulcie Cherry and Isabel Mahon.

When The Patsy was revived again in 1932, Everyone’s magazine reported: “The play marks another individual success for Agnes Doyle… This girl is going [ahead] with leaps and bounds. She has a whimsicality and method of expression quite unusual, and in the part of Pat Harrington… [a] very quaint and also very appealing little personality…[13]Everyones, Vol.13 No.651, 24 August 1932, P36

Patricia Penman and Agnes in 1933. A Rene Pardon Studio photograph. [14]The Sun (Syd) 6 Sept 1933, P18

By this time, her personal life had already been “remade.” She was now reported to be the daughter of “a well known grazier” and her hometown was the respectable and well established town of Bathurst.[15]The Sydney Morning Herald, 18 Oct 1934, P8 While this was a fiction, she had made some important society connections. Possibly while at Cobar she had befriended Patricia Penman [16]Western Age (Dubbo, NSW) 23 Sep 1931, P2 a budding actress now using the stage name Tisha (or Tuisha) Guille and the daughter of sportsman, mining engineer and colourful Sydney personality Arthur Percival (Percy) Penman. When Patricia married Jack Harris in 1933, Agnes was the single bridesmaid.[17]Patricia lived a long life in New Zealand. Sir Jack Harris ran New Zealand import-export firm Bing Harris for many years

Perhaps her signature role was in Ivor Novello‘s comedy Fresh Fields. The play opened in Sydney in March 1934 after a long run in London. It probably appealed to Britons and Australians for different reasons. It concerned the Pidgeons, an Australian family, who had just sold their large hotel in Brisbane and who suddenly appear in the lives of two impoverished aristocratic London sisters (who cannot afford the upkeep on their Belgravia mansion). Agnes played Una Pidgeon, the “gauche clumsy” Australian daughter, who eventually wins over everyone and makes a success at court.[18]Ivor Novello Fresh Fields synopsis (1935) The theme of brash, wealthy, but unsophisticated Australians (or Americans) versus the reserve and genteel poverty of an English family has been repeated so often it is immediately familiar to us today.

Move to the United States in 1935

Agnes arrived in the US on the SS Monterey in July 1935. Intriguingly, on US immigration documents she gave Arthur Penman as her guardian in Australia, and actor John Wood (who was then under contract to RKO) as her contact in the US. In early 1936 she played the role of Una again with the Margaret Anglin company production of Fresh Fields in New York. Reviews for her performance were positive – although the play itself may have been “too English” for a long run in the US. Variety thought it “overwritten” and a bit “too gabby.”[19]Variety 12 Feb 1936 P62

Stories that she got the role while “on the way to London” may be true, but they also bear close similarity to accounts given for the US discoveries of other young Australians – Mary Maguire, Jocelyn Howarth (Constance Worth) and Mona Barrie – and it seems to have been a favourite Australian newspaper story. Another popular story was that of the movie studio offer. In Agnes’ case, following reports back home of the success of Fresh Fields on Broadway, came stories of studio contracts and movie offers in Hollywood.[20]Daily Telegraph (Syd) 23 April 1936, P14 Whether she ever really entertained working in film is unknown, but The Australian Women’s Weekly claimed that talks with Twentieth Century-Fox had broken down because she was “asking too much.”[21]The Australian Women’s Weekly 18 April 1936, P29

Agnes touring in Yes, My Darling Daughter in 1938.[22]Fort Worth Star-Telegram (Texas) · 24 Feb 1938, P11

Still presenting as a slight but vivacious young woman, she was well suited to playing the rebellious modern daughter in Yes, My Darling Daughter, first in New York in 1937 and then on tour through the US in 1938. It was a popular success.

The celebratory press reports of the 1930s regarding Australian actors overseas regularly included news of Agnes’s doings. Her travel to London in 1936 and again in 1938 when she stayed with Lord and Lady Waleran, news of being seen in the company of interesting people like Alfred Gwynne Vanderbilt, aviator Charles Kingsford-Smith and Hollywood newcomer Jocelyn Howarth (Constance Worth); all fitted in with the contemporary nationalistic belief that Australians could do anything.[23]The Sun (Syd) 25 Jan 1938, P11 But there was little news about work on stage.

Australian sojourn 1945-6

Newly returned home in March 1945, Agnes models a New York hat.[24]The Sun (Syd) 11 Mar 1945, P6

Unusually, Agnes Doyle returned to Australia in March 1945 – before the end of World War II, a difficult task and only possible at the time if one had guaranteed work at the destination and could get a berth on a ship. Yet Agnes did this and she stepped back into the Australian theatre scene with a role in the new comedy The Voice of the Turtle, with great ease. What had she been doing in New York for the previous six years was vaguely and briefly reported. When pressed, she spoke of her recent role in (a very short run of) That Old Devil.[25]The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 8 Mar 1945, P16 She also mentioned radio plays for the B.B.C. and a play for NBC’s TV channel. She explained that she had worked for the British Ministry of War Transport for 18 months and had also helped raise $200,000 for American War Loan Bonds.[26]The Sydney Morning Herald 8 Mar 1945, P5

Voice of the Turtle demonstrated that, whatever she had been doing, she had lost none of her skills as an actor. This contemporary adult comedy had a healthy two month run at Sydney’s Minerva Theatre and Agnes and Ron Randell, her co-star, were complimented for their performances.[27]The Sydney Morning Herald 10 Apr 1945, P5 This was followed by a short run of Shaw’s Arms and the Man at the Minerva.[28]The Daily Telegraph (Syd)13 Aug 1945
P16

Career in the US after 1946

It took until April 1946 for Agnes to get a passage back to the US, and during the interim she lived with the Penman family in Sydney again. She had time to socialise with friends, support events for the services and comment on Australia’s limited post-war opportunities for actors. [29]She also thought income taxes were too high. Daily Telegraph (Syd) 7 Jan 1946, P9 Like Ron Randell, she declined to take up a role in Flying Foxes, a play with an Australian theme written by US serviceman Warren D Cheney, that was very publicly proposed for a New York launch in early 1946.[30]See Daily Telegraph (Syd) 27 Jan 1946, P6. After US war service, Warren DeWitt Cheney, a maker of medical documentaries, went on to an interesting career as an abstract sculptor and later became a … Continue reading

One might wonder why Agnes Doyle, “Australia’s great little favourite,” returned to the US if her career there had slowed.[31]JC Williamson Whistling in the Dark program, August 1932. Via National Library of Australia PROMPT collection However, as this writer has noted before, the choice for post-war Australian performers was stark. Actors could either stay – meaning they would continue to work for JC Williamsons, or on radio, or perhaps in a rare Australian film – there was, as yet, no television. Alternatively, they could try their luck overseas – where the opportunities seemed boundless.

Unfortunately, it is difficult to trace all of Agnes’s professional activities in the post-war world. She appeared in several live plays for US television in the mid-1950s and occasionally wrote for newspapers. She was living in apartment hotels in the 1940s – the Royalton and Algonquin in New York, both well known for hosting actors seeking work. However, her luck changed at the end of the 1950s, when she took on a new and very high profile role. JC Williamson’s employed her as their New York representative, to negotiate contracts and complex royalty agreements – for example for the hugely successful musical Camelot. Some of these survive in the archives of the Australian Performing Arts Collection in Melbourne.

Agnes’s name on JC Williamsons letterhead, c1960. She continued in this role for at least ten years.[32]Australian Performing Arts Collection

Agnes Doyle became a US citizen in February 1958. By that time she lived at the Martha Washington Hotel, a women’s-only residential hotel in New York.

Agnes died at the Actor’s Fund Home in Englewood, New Jersey in August 1992. She never married, had no dependents and appears to have had no significant long-term partnership. A lonely life, perhaps. In 2024, the township of Nymagee still mines copper and sustains a population of about 100.

Another image of Agnes while performing in Op O’ Me Thumb in 1930. Mitchell Library, State Library of New South Wales.

Note 1 – Her family

There were great tragedies in Agnes’s life and these almost certainly coloured her willingness to discuss her past and probably influenced many of her decisions. In December 1920, her older sister Annie died in heartbreaking circumstances, apparently as a result of an attempt to induce an abortion.[33]Truth (Syd), 2 Jan 1921, P9 Annie also left behind a very young son, and the grief for the Doyle family was palpable.[34]The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 14 Dec 1920, P4[35]The Sydney Morning Herald 14 Dec 1920, P7 Twenty-two years later, in early 1942, Agnes’s brother Dennis died in fighting during the Japanese invasion of Malaysia and Singapore. He left behind a family. It appears that Agnes was estranged from her mother for much of her life. Not so her father, who as late as 1950 was proudly providing commentary on her life.[36]The Daily Mirror (Syd) 15 Feb 1950, P24 reported Patrick Doyle appearing on 2SM’s radio program “Fifty and Over”


Nick Murphy
March 2024

References

Special thanks

  • Claudia Funder – Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne
  • Elaine Marriner – Marriner Theatre Archive, Melbourne

Collections

  • Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne Australia
  • The Marriner Theatre Archive, Melbourne
  • New South Wales State Archives, Museums of History, New South Wales
  • State Library of New South Wales
  • State Library of Victoria
  • Births, Deaths & Marriages, New South Wales
  • Ancestry.com
  • Newspapers.com
  • National Library of Australia – Trove
  • National Library of New Zealand – Papers Past

Text

  • Warren D Cheney (1978) Don’t you play games with me!: How to identify and deal with games children play against you. Randolph-Harris, California.
  • John McCallum (1979) Life with Googie. Heinemann, London
  • Ivor Novello (1933) Fresh Fields: A comedy in Three Acts. (1936 Edition) Samuel French, New York.

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 The Bulletin 26 Nov 1930, P18
↑2 As with so many divorce documents of this time, a great deal was written but much remains unstated. See Divorce papers; Michael Doyle – Ada Doyle, 1912-1913, New South Wales State Archives
↑3 Cobar Herald (NSW) 9 December 1913, P13
↑4 Western Age (NSW), 31 Jul 1917, P3
↑5 The Sun (Syd) 28 Nov 1926, P31. There is evidence that Agnes subsequently taught dancing at Melbourne’s Green Mill Dance Hall in the late 1920s. See Table Talk (Melb) 21 Mar 1929, P64
↑6 The Sun (Syd) 3 Jul 1927, P38
↑7 Sunday Times (Syd) 24 Oct 1926, P26
↑8 The Daily News (WA) 2 Apr 1929, P1
↑9 Truth (Syd) 12 Oct 1930, P7
↑10 JC Williamson’s was the large theatrical firm that dominated Australasia
↑11 Agnes Doyle contract with JC Williamsons. Dated 14 Dec 1933. Courtesy Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre Melbourne
↑12 Table Talk (Melb), 31 May 1934, P23
↑13 Everyones, Vol.13 No.651, 24 August 1932, P36
↑14 The Sun (Syd) 6 Sept 1933, P18
↑15 The Sydney Morning Herald, 18 Oct 1934, P8
↑16 Western Age (Dubbo, NSW) 23 Sep 1931, P2
↑17 Patricia lived a long life in New Zealand. Sir Jack Harris ran New Zealand import-export firm Bing Harris for many years
↑18 Ivor Novello Fresh Fields synopsis (1935)
↑19 Variety 12 Feb 1936 P62
↑20 Daily Telegraph (Syd) 23 April 1936, P14
↑21 The Australian Women’s Weekly 18 April 1936, P29
↑22 Fort Worth Star-Telegram (Texas) · 24 Feb 1938, P11
↑23 The Sun (Syd) 25 Jan 1938, P11
↑24 The Sun (Syd) 11 Mar 1945, P6
↑25 The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 8 Mar 1945, P16
↑26 The Sydney Morning Herald 8 Mar 1945, P5
↑27 The Sydney Morning Herald 10 Apr 1945, P5
↑28 The Daily Telegraph (Syd)13 Aug 1945
P16
↑29 She also thought income taxes were too high. Daily Telegraph (Syd) 7 Jan 1946, P9
↑30 See Daily Telegraph (Syd) 27 Jan 1946, P6. After US war service, Warren DeWitt Cheney, a maker of medical documentaries, went on to an interesting career as an abstract sculptor and later became a psychologist
↑31 JC Williamson Whistling in the Dark program, August 1932. Via National Library of Australia PROMPT collection
↑32 Australian Performing Arts Collection
↑33 Truth (Syd), 2 Jan 1921, P9
↑34 The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 14 Dec 1920, P4
↑35 The Sydney Morning Herald 14 Dec 1920, P7
↑36 The Daily Mirror (Syd) 15 Feb 1950, P24 reported Patrick Doyle appearing on 2SM’s radio program “Fifty and Over”

Bringing “The Mikado” to the world – the amazing Salingers

“Tillie” (Matilda) Salinger (1866-1930) at the height of her fame c1895. [1]Undated public domain photo from the Internet Archive and California Revealed The background is a photograph of port city of Yokohama, taken in 1876, about ten years before Matilda, Herbert and Helena Salinger performed there. Note the mix of European and Japanese buildings.[2]Baron Raimund von Stillfried, 1839-1911, photographer. State Library of Victoria Picture Collections

The Five Second Version
Matilda, Herbert and Helena Salinger, the Australian-born children of a German gold rush immigrant to Australia, first appeared as juvenile performers on stage in Australia and by 1881 had joined Pollard’s Lilliputian Opera Company. The Pollards 1883 tour of South East Asia and India culminated in wild accusations of child kidnapping, and Mr Nathan Salinger actually travelled to Calcutta to reclaim his children. But instead of returning to Australia, they spent most of 1884-1888 performing to expat colonial audiences in India and Asia. It was their family troupe, the English Opera Bouffe Company, that first performed Gilbert and Sullivan’s The Mikado in Yokohama Japan, in April 1887 – albeit an edited version. By the early 1890s the Salingers had emigrated to the US, where they all pursued musical and theatrical careers, often together and with great success.
“Lena” (Helena) and “Tillie” (Matilda) Salinger, soon after arriving in the US.[3]The World (New York) 18 Jan 1893, P9 and The San Francisco Call and Post, 14 Mar 1895, P6

Children of the goldfields

Matilda or “Tillie” (1866-1930), Herbert (1867-1922) and Helena or “Lena” (1869-1946) Salinger were the children of German gold-rush immigrant Nathan Salinger and his English born wife Elizabeth nee Glenister. All three children were born at the family hotel – the Freemason’s, in the gold-mining town of Ararat, in Western Victoria. By the early 1870s, the family had moved to run the Commercial Hotel at 113 Elizabeth Street Melbourne, in the city’s heart. Another son, Magnus, was born there in 1876.[4]Nathan placed newspaper notices to welcome each birth See Note 1 below regarding the Salinger family

The birthplace of the three older Salinger children – Barkly Street, Ararat.[5]Victoria and Its Metropolis, Past and Present. Vol IIA Country Districts, P203, 1888 McCarron Bird & Co, Melb

Joining the Pollards

The three older Salinger children attended the Melbourne Hebrew School, their names sometimes listed as prize winners in reports of the school’s annual awards.[6]The Argus (Melb) 19 March 1877, P7 We know little about the dynamics of the Salinger family, but we must assume that music and performance were valued and encouraged, because by 1880, Herbert and Tillie were appearing on stage at the Bijou Theatre in Melbourne for Lewis’s Juvenile Pinafore Company.[7]The Argus (Melb) 8 June 1880, P8 But not long after this, Herbert and Lena (aged 13 and 11 respectively) were signed up by Pollard’s Lilliputian Opera Company, touring Australia and New Zealand. As the following advertisement shows, the Pollards needed to supplement their troupe, as Pollard family members got older and no longer passed as children. To strengthen numbers they had also signed up other members of Lewis’s company – the Osmond children and “Little” Amy Brooks.[8]For reasons unknown, Tillie Salinger was not signed up with Pollards Their repertoire included HMS Pinafore and the comic opera Les Cloches de Corneville.

Herbert and Lena Salinger with the Pollard’s in 1881. As can be seen here, most of the performers were not Pollard family members.[9]The Lorgnette (Melb) 24 Dec 1881, P3

Amongst all the older Pollard managers (listed at the end of the 1881 Melbourne advertisement above) was a non-family member – Nathan Salinger – the troupe’s business manager. After his hotel ventures Nathan Salinger had turned his hand to other enterprises – including catering and furniture sales, and work for Pollard’s was another.[10]Years later, Tillie Salinger was understandably inclined to emphasise her father’s role as a theatre company manager rather than a publican. See The Philadelphia Inquirer 29 Dec 1918, P30 But this arrangement appears not to have lasted for very long, perhaps only while they performed in Melbourne.

Bewildered children and angry parents

Reviews of the Pollards were generally positive as they travelled through New Zealand and Australia, and over time the company added new operas. However, there were still challenges with finding available venues and fresh material to perform. By early 1883 the troupe was plodding its way through the provincial towns of northern Queensland, when the adult Pollards managing the troupe made a momentous decision. Attracted by accounts of the success some Australian theatre groups had enjoyed in South East Asia (then called “the Far East”) and India, the Pollards decided to try their luck there too.

14 year old Herbert Salinger in character as Gaspard in Pollard’s Les Cloches de Corneville, c 1881.[11]State Library of New South Wales, May Pollard collection of photos

They departed Queensland in June 1883 on the RMS Quetta, bound for Batavia and Singapore, “with thirty-five or so bewildered children” on board. “Bewildered” because, as historian Peter Downes notes, none of the parents or child performers had been consulted about leaving the Australian colonies and at least some accounts suggest the children did not know where they were going until they were at sea.[12]Downes (2002) P60-63 On the way, senior company members Tom and Charles Pollard wrote home to parents to inform them of their new plans. Charles Pollard’s letter to Eliza Salinger reveals the senior Pollards knew quite well the liberty they had taken in leaving Australia.

“Dear Mrs Salinger,
You will no doubt know before you receive this letter that the company are going to Calcutta for the Exhibition… [13]The Calcutta International Exhibition was held between December 1883 and March 1884 Of course you ought to have been informed, but it [the decision] was made so hurriedly that we…[had] no time to write… You have nothing to blame Herbert or Lena for, so you must blame me… [signed] C.A. Pollard”[14]The Times of India, Jan 24, 1884, P6


The children (those who were not Pollard family members) were indentured to the Pollards and their parents were paid an agreed salary, but there was nothing agreed about where they would perform. Even twenty years later, a surviving Pollards contract from 1900 for child actor W. S. Percy is remarkably unclear on this matter.[15]Downes (2002) P 212

13 year old Olive and 15 year old May Pollard were actually Pollard family members, as well as performers. But the Salingers, and most of the troupe were not. Photographed while in Singapore in 1883.[16]State Library of New South Wales, May Pollard collection of photos

By the end of 1883, with the troupe by now in India, Australian newspapers were reporting at length on accusations the Pollards had abducted or kidnapped the children.[17]See The Age (Melb) 17 Dec 1883, P6 Clearly some of the parents were enraged but most could do little about it. However, in December 1883, Nathan Salinger took passage for Calcutta to reclaim his children. The most reliable account of Salinger’s confrontation with the Pollards came via Joseph Bosisto, a colonial politician who was attending the Calcutta International Exhibition. He had been asked by the colonial government to meet the Pollards, check on the children’s welfare and insist on their return. Bosisto also attended court in Calcutta as an observer, when Salinger sought restitution for his expenses in collecting his children from the Pollards and returning to Melbourne.[18]See Bosisto’s statement to the Victorian parliament in The Argus (Melb) 20 June 1884, P6 Nathan Salinger was clearly a man of determination and financial resources, and the Pollards wisely settled out of court.

Calcutta as the Salingers may have seen it.[19]The Queen’s Empire, A Pictorial and Descriptive Record. (1899) P146, Cassell & Co Ltd. Photo Bourne & Shepherd, Calcutta

Under pressure from Bosisto, the Pollard troupe departed Calcutta in February 1884, bound for Australia, via performance stops in Rangoon, Penang and Singapore. They tried to negotiate a performance stop in Sydney, but Bosisto would have none of it. (See also Note 2 below)

Salinger’s English Opera Bouffe Company

Within a few months however, reports reached Australian papers that Nathan Salinger had not returned to Australia at all, but was settled in Calcutta, running a hotel[20]Tasmanian News, 27 Jun 1884, P3 and at least one of the Salinger girls was appearing in theatre there.[21]Weekly Times (Melb) 5 July 1884, P7 Although the Salinger’s footprints in India are faint today, surviving newspaper reports, show that by January 1885, Herbert and Lena were both performing with Emelie Melville’s touring company at Calcutta’s Corinthian theatre. Although an adult troupe, their repertoire included the very familiar popular operas that the Pollards favoured – Pirates of Penzance, H.M.S. Pinafore and the like. But within a few months, while in India, Melville’s company had collapsed over pay disputes.[22]Evening News (Syd)14 May 1885 P5 Ever one to seize an opportunity, Nathan Salinger set about establishing the English Opera Bouffe Company, utilising the skills of his four children (including his youngest, Magnus) and employing some of the former Melville company members.[23]Leader (Melb) 20 Feb 1886, P26

The English Grand Bouffe Company performing in Mumbai (then Bombay) in 1885. Tillie now used the stage name “Tilly Saroney.” [24]The Times of India 4 Nov 1885, P2

For the next few years the company of about 14 players performed seasons across India and South East Asia, and to Hong Kong and Shanghai. It was a small but consistently familiar group and included Arthur Rigby, Arthur Fawcett, Elsa Wilson and Frank d’Este. Arthur Fawcett wrote home to Australian papers on several occasions, including in July 1886 – from the refreshing climate of Murree, a hill station (now in Pakistan) where the troupe were about to perform Gilbert and Sullivan’s new opera The Mikado. He claimed the troupe had travelled over 11,000 miles by rail by this time, and played in nearly every garrison theatre and public hall in India – an impressive achievement.[25]Melbourne Punch 19 August 1886, P8

Interviewed years later, Lena recalled with some pride the family troupe entertaining distinguished Indian nobility and British officials, including at the wedding of the reformist Maharaja Gaekwad of Baroda to his second wife, in late 1885. But she also acknowledged that the troupe’s audiences were often at English outposts and military stations – bored soldiers must have been delighted to see them.[26]The Washington Post, 8 Oct, 1911, P3. Also contemporary accounts in Melbourne Punch (Melb) 19 August 1886, P8 and The Leader (Melb) 20 Feb 1886, P26 Their repertoire included the familiar favourites – Les Cloches de Corneville, The Little Duke, The Mikado, Pirates of Penzance and H.M.S. Pinafore.

Reviews of the small troupe varied – but the young Salingers were often singled out for praise. For example, the Shanghai North China Herald‘s review of Pirates of Penzance complemented Tillie for her “very attractive soprano voice… as good a light soprano as one could hope to hear in Shanghai, her voice is round and sweet” while “Lena Salinger is little less than a genius… so bright so full of vivacity… .” Herbert, “as Sergeant of Police was greeted with great applause, but he was quite cut out by …his corporal, Master Magnus.”[27]The North China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette (Shanghai) 16 Mar 1887, P300

The Salinger troupe performing the The Mikado in Shanghai in early 1887.[28]The China Mail (Shanghai) 8 Feb 1887.

Performing The Mikado in Japan

Gilbert and Sullivan’s comic opera The Mikado opened in England in March 1885 and was quickly a success. Today, modern audiences may find it dated and the characterisations offensive. Michael Cooper has described it as “one of the most passionately debated stage works of our time… A droll satire of Victorian England? A racist caricature of Japan? Some amalgam of the two?”[29]Michael Cooper, New York Times, Dec 25, 2016 Even in April 1887, the Salingers must have been aware they were taking a risk performing the play anywhere in Asia – but particularly in Japan, even though Yokohama, where it was to be performed, was a treaty port with numerous western merchants.


F.A. Sleap’s engraving of The Mikado at the Theatre Royal (Melb), in 1886.[30]The Illustrated Australian News. David Syme and Co. 1886. State Library of Victoria

It was Sir Francis Plunkett, the British representative in Tokyo, who insisted on changes to the play, including its title,[31]to Sotyugo Shita Sannin no Otome, roughly translated as Three Little Maids from School to avoid causing offence.[32]Lavery (2016) P224-225 It finally opened in Yokohama on April 30, 1887 and was repeated several days later, reportedly bringing in “more money than had six of any other work[s] in the company’s repertory.”[33]Civil and Military Gazette (Lahore) 16 Aug 1887, P6 Samuel L Leiter states that the Salinger troupe then repeated performances in Kobe and Nagasaki.[34]These cities were also treaty ports that allowed Western access to Japan While the choice of city to perform suggests Salinger wanted to present a new play that English-speaking expats had not yet seen, we are assured by Leiter that there were also Japanese in the audiences – although with the passage of time, their reactions seem unclear.[35]Leiter (2009) P128 Despite suggestions that the Salingers “wanted the distinction of singing the new Mikado… for the first time… in that country,”[36]The Boston Globe, 25 July 1895, P8 it would seem equally likely that Nathan Salinger’s decision to perform The Mikado in Japan was an entirely commercial one. Years later, Tillie Salinger recalled that Plunkett’s intervention had actually helped advertise the performance and improved audience numbers.[37]The San Francisco Call and Post 14 Mar 1895, P6

Following a performance season in Hong Kong in July 1887, the Salingers finally returned to Melbourne, Australia.[38]The Lorgnette(Melb) 29 June 1887, P2 They had run their travelling troupe for almost three years through India and the Far East.

In Australia, they were soon on stage again and touring familiar Australian towns. Rejoining the popular Emelie Melville again, they were listed as “Miss Tilly Sarony, the favorite soprano, Miss Lena Salinger, the imitable soubrette [and] Mr. Herbert Salinger, the versatile comedian.”[39]Euroa Advertiser (Vic.), 22 Jun 1888, P3 Although they were soon working independently of each other, they had re-established themselves as Australian stage favourites. Nathan Salinger now described himself as a Theatrical Agent.[40]See for example, Rate Book entry for 46 Brunswick St, Fitzroy in 1890 Inevitably, after several years back home, the young Salingers decided to try their luck in North America.

Lena as illustrated in a Melbourne paper in 1890.
[41]Sportsman (Melb) 15 Oct 1890, P5

A snapshot of three US careers

Tillie c1895.[42]Undated public domain photo from the Internet Archive and California Revealed

Tillie Salinger was the first of the family to depart for the United States. She boarded the RMS Alameda bound for San Francisco in October 1890 and was on stage with the Tivoli Opera House in San Francisco within weeks.[43]The San Francisco Chronicle, 24 Nov 1890, P8 Her reception proved to be a very positive one and this would have encouraged the rest of the family to follow. Only a few years later, the Music Editor for The San Francisco Chronicle, reported on her in these glowing terms: “Miss [Tillie] Salinger’s repertory is perhaps the largest of any singer, and her experience most unusually varied… Miss Salinger has a clear soprano voice of unusual volume and purity. It is powerful and well controlled... Miss Salinger is, therefore, entitled to serious consideration as a prima donna and many women have reached great prominence with far less genuine merit to recommend them.”[44]Peter Robinson in The Boston Globe, 25 July 1895, P8

Tillie and Phil, well established in 1909.[45]The San Francisco Call, 26 December 1909

Tillie remained associated with San Francisco’s Tivoli Opera for a decade, and married baritone Philip Branson, another Tivoli artist, in October 1893. The rest of the Salinger family emigrated to the US in mid 1891, with Lena also debuting at the Tivoli Opera that year. Thanks to Tillie’s talents and a life of continuous touring of the US, she became very well known. She was usually on stage in company with her husband Phil, in an endless stream of the ever popular light operas. As time went by Tillie and Phil were seen in supporting roles to newly rising stars – like Mitzi Hajos in 1911-12, and Australian Ivy Scott in 1917-18. Tillie and Phil punctuated this busy life with a short return to Australia in August – October 1900. She retired to Ridgefield Park, New Jersey in the early 1920s.

[Click on image to enlarge]
Left – Tillie and Phil Branson in the comic opera Robin Hood in 1914[46]The Missoulian (Montana) ·20 Jan 1914, P2
Centre – Three years later a revival of Robin Hood featured Tillie, Phil, and new Australian singer Ivy Scott[47]The Havre Daily News (Montana) · 19 Apr 1917, P4
Right – The musical Maytime in 1919 featured Phil and Tillie plus Herbert Salinger[48]Austin American-Statesman (Texas) 24 Dec 1919, P8

After a stint with the opera in San Francisco, Lena Salinger performed on tour with various companies throughout the US. Although inevitable comparisons with her older sister were made when she arrived, the view was that she was a mezzo soprano with “a voice of wide range and great power.”[49]Great Falls Tribune, (Montana) 3 May 1895, P4 Like her older sister, Lena appeared in a string of popular musical comedies – The Bohemian Girl, The Three Twins, La fille de Madame Angot and Telephone Girl. While touring with the Pike Opera Company in cities of the US north-west, she married fellow actor Harry R Hanlein (or Hanlon) – at the end of a performance, in Montana, in 1895.[50]San Francisco Chronicle, 23 May 1895,·P5 Like Tillie, she often toured with her husband, although as time went by, her roles were often supporting ones. After her marriage she usually styled herself Helena or Helen Salinger.

[Click on image to enlarge]
Left – Tillie, Helena and both husbands featured in this comic opera together in Chicago in 1896. [51]Chicago Tribune 29 Nov 1896, P37
Centre – Helena and Harry appeared together on tour in The Umpire [52]The Oshkosh Northwestern (Wisconsin) 25 Aug 1906, P3
Right – Helena Salinger Hanlon in 1911 about the time she appeared in the musical comedy Girl in the Taxi. [53]Signed photo dated 1911 from the Internet Archive and California Revealed

In April 1917 Helen was announced as part of the large cast being gathered for Sam Goldwyn’s forthcoming but as yet unnamed film.[54]Star-Gazette (New York) 4 April 1917, P2 After some speculation that it would feature popular actor Maxine Elliot, it ended up being called Polly of the Circus, and featured Mae Marsh and Vernon Steele. Helen’s role turned out to be a minor one.[55]The film survives and a low definition copy can be see here, at the Silent Hall of Fame Channel on Youtube Movies may have seemed an exciting change to a life of performance touring, but many actors at the time commented how professionally unrewarding film work was. For whatever reason, this appears to have been Lena’s only film. Performing increasingly in New York, she took supporting stage roles well into the 1930s.

While in St Louis in 1896, with the Al Fresco Opera Company, Herbert came to blows with a stage door johnnie, over their competing attentions to a chorus girl.[56]St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 25 Aug 1896, P5

Like his sisters, Herbert Salinger began his US stage career touring in musical theatre, and amongst his first performances were roles he knew well, such as the Sergeant of Police in Pirates of Penzance,[57]The Salt Lake Tribune, 7 May 1893, P7 and Ko-Ko from The Mikado.[58]The Buffalo Sunday Morning News, 23 Nov 1902, P6 Herbert is most commonly associated with the Manhattan Opera, which he managed and directed from about 1903. The Manhattan Opera also operated from the Rorick’s Glen Theater in the summer months. Well established in New York by 1902, he married fellow performer Odette Bordeaux in August.[59]Several years later, following the dissolution of their marriage, Odette was murdered apparently by one of her new husband’s trusted Prisoners. He was a Prison Warden Again, at times, Tillie, Helen and their husbands also performed at Rorick’s Glen.[60]Star-Gazette (New York) 19 May 1913, P6

A testament to the popularity of Gilbert & Sullivan. Performing The Mikado – again in 1905. [61]Star-Gazette (New York) 15 Aug 1905, P7

Herbert c1908.[62]The Buffalo Enquirer (New York) 24 Apr 1908, P2

After 1909, Herbert took to managing (and performing in minor roles in) touring productions, apparently working for New York’s Shubert brothers.[63]Star-Gazette (New York) 7 May 1921, P11 The musicals Princess Pat and Maytime were typical of the large scale productions taken on the road for prolonged tours. Herbert remarried in 1920, and turned some of his efforts to working the land. He took a part-interest in a property in Cody, Wyoming. Unfortunately he took ill and died there, aged only 55, in August 1922. The cause of death was given as peritonitis.[64]Star-Gazette (New York) 11 Aug 1922, P20

Herbert c1912 [65]Star-Gazette (New York) 5 Aug 1922, P2

Tillie Salinger also died relatively young, following a series of strokes, in New Jersey in 1930.[66]The Record (New Jersey), 2 June 1930, P2 Lena Salinger died at her home in Brooklyn, New York in October 1946.[67]New York, New York City Municipal Deaths, 1795-1949 database, via FamilySearch

The family’s youngest member – Magnus Salinger, having moved to the US with his parents in 1891, became a musician for the San Francisco Symphony, and was long active in the Musicians Union. His heart was soon in his newly adopted country – he became a US citizen and served in the US army in 1898-1899, during the Spanish American war. In late 1924 he returned to Australia with his wife and daughter, presumably to visit his cousins. He lived a long and successful life, dying in California in 1958, aged 82.[68]Daily Independent Journal (CA) 11 Dec 1958, P8


Note 1 – The Salinger family come to Australia

Tom Roberts’ vision of migration to Australia – Coming South (1886) National Gallery of Victoria.

Herz and Henriette Salinger brought their family from Germany to Australia in August 1858 during the Gold rushes. Nathan Salinger was their oldest son. The family were not typical of the great wave of migrants – who were often single men without family and mostly from the British Isles. By chance, the manifest for the ship Tornado has survived and shows the entire, mostly adult, Salinger family – of 5 daughters and 2 sons, travelling from Germany to Australia, via England. In Victoria, Herz and Henriette made their home at Pleasant Creek (Stawell) and later Ararat, major goldmining towns in Western Victoria.

Herz and his two sons Nathan and Emanuel may have tried mining, but records show the family soon moved into commerce – storekeeping, hotel keeping and later the local wine industry. Nathan’s brother Emanuel and his five sisters all stayed in Australia.


Note 2 – The Pollard Tour of 1880-1884

Peter Downes has documented the Pollards Lilliputian Opera Company tour of 1880-1884 at some length.[69]Chapters 6-9, Peter Downes (2002) While this tour established the practices of the later Pollards troupes, it could not have been regarded as a success at the time. Apart from the bad publicity surrounding the alleged “kidnapping” of children, in 1883 and 1884 it suffered several other serious blows. While in Rangoon, oldest son of the Pollard family Jim had shot himself[70]by accident or act of self harm, it no longer seems clear and family patriarch James Joseph Pollard, father to 18 children by two wives and owner of the Pollards, became seriously ill, diagnosed with dropsy,[71]probably heart failure at about the same time. He died soon after their return to Australia. As Downes notes, the company continued performing in Australia and New Zealand until they were disbanded in mid 1886. In 1891 a Pollard’s juvenile troupe was re-established by Tom Pollard.


References

Primary Sources

  • National Library of Australia, Trove
  • State Library of Victoria
  • State Library of New South Wales
  • Ancestry.com
  • Victoria, Births Deaths & Marriages
  • ProQuest Historical Newspapers
  • Newspapers.com
  • Hathitrust.com
  • The Internet Archive
  • Society of California Pioneers. Managed by California Revealed

Other links

  • Salinger’s Cafe at Great Western, North West of Ararat, was originally built by Nathan Salinger’s younger brother Emanuel in the 1860s as a store. It remained in the family until the 1940s. It continues to operate today as a restaurant and gourmet food-store, a quaint reminder of this pioneer family. See https://salingers.com.au/about/

Text

  • The Queen’s Empire, A Pictorial and Descriptive Record. (1899), Cassell & Co Ltd.
  • Michael Cooper (2016) “Reviving The Mikado in a Balancing Act of Taste” in The New York Times, December 25, 2016. Via Proquest newspapers
  • Peter Downes (2002) The Pollards. Steele Roberts, Wellington NZ.
  • James Jupp (2001) The Australian people: an encyclopedia of the nation, its people and their origins. Cambridge University Press
  • Joseph Lavery (2016) “The Mikado’s Queer Realism: Law, Genre, Knowledge.” Novel, A Forum on Fiction. Vol 49, No 2, August 2016, P291-235. Duke University Press
  • Josephine Lee (2010) The Japan of Pure Invention: Gilbert & Sullivan’s the Mikado. University of Minnesota Press.
  • Samuel L Leiter (2009) “Performing the Emperor’s New Clothes: The Mikado, The Tale of Genji and Lese Majeste on the Japanese Stage.” Rising from the Flames: The Rebirth of Theater in Occupied Japan, 1945-1952. (Ed) Samuel L Leiter. Lathan, Lexington Books, P125-171
  • Victoria and Its Metropolis, Past and Present. Vol IIA Country Districts, 1888. McCarron Bird & Co, Melb.

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

This site has been selected for archiving and preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 Undated public domain photo from the Internet Archive and California Revealed
↑2 Baron Raimund von Stillfried, 1839-1911, photographer. State Library of Victoria Picture Collections
↑3 The World (New York) 18 Jan 1893, P9 and The San Francisco Call and Post, 14 Mar 1895, P6
↑4 Nathan placed newspaper notices to welcome each birth
↑5 Victoria and Its Metropolis, Past and Present. Vol IIA Country Districts, P203, 1888 McCarron Bird & Co, Melb
↑6 The Argus (Melb) 19 March 1877, P7
↑7 The Argus (Melb) 8 June 1880, P8
↑8 For reasons unknown, Tillie Salinger was not signed up with Pollards
↑9 The Lorgnette (Melb) 24 Dec 1881, P3
↑10 Years later, Tillie Salinger was understandably inclined to emphasise her father’s role as a theatre company manager rather than a publican. See The Philadelphia Inquirer 29 Dec 1918, P30
↑11, ↑16 State Library of New South Wales, May Pollard collection of photos
↑12 Downes (2002) P60-63
↑13 The Calcutta International Exhibition was held between December 1883 and March 1884
↑14 The Times of India, Jan 24, 1884, P6
↑15 Downes (2002) P 212
↑17 See The Age (Melb) 17 Dec 1883, P6
↑18 See Bosisto’s statement to the Victorian parliament in The Argus (Melb) 20 June 1884, P6
↑19 The Queen’s Empire, A Pictorial and Descriptive Record. (1899) P146, Cassell & Co Ltd. Photo Bourne & Shepherd, Calcutta
↑20 Tasmanian News, 27 Jun 1884, P3
↑21 Weekly Times (Melb) 5 July 1884, P7
↑22 Evening News (Syd)14 May 1885 P5
↑23 Leader (Melb) 20 Feb 1886, P26
↑24 The Times of India 4 Nov 1885, P2
↑25 Melbourne Punch 19 August 1886, P8
↑26 The Washington Post, 8 Oct, 1911, P3. Also contemporary accounts in Melbourne Punch (Melb) 19 August 1886, P8 and The Leader (Melb) 20 Feb 1886, P26
↑27 The North China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette (Shanghai) 16 Mar 1887, P300
↑28 The China Mail (Shanghai) 8 Feb 1887.
↑29 Michael Cooper, New York Times, Dec 25, 2016
↑30 The Illustrated Australian News. David Syme and Co. 1886. State Library of Victoria
↑31 to Sotyugo Shita Sannin no Otome, roughly translated as Three Little Maids from School
↑32 Lavery (2016) P224-225
↑33 Civil and Military Gazette (Lahore) 16 Aug 1887, P6
↑34 These cities were also treaty ports that allowed Western access to Japan
↑35 Leiter (2009) P128
↑36 The Boston Globe, 25 July 1895, P8
↑37 The San Francisco Call and Post 14 Mar 1895, P6
↑38 The Lorgnette(Melb) 29 June 1887, P2
↑39 Euroa Advertiser (Vic.), 22 Jun 1888, P3
↑40 See for example, Rate Book entry for 46 Brunswick St, Fitzroy in 1890
↑41 Sportsman (Melb) 15 Oct 1890, P5
↑42 Undated public domain photo from the Internet Archive and California Revealed
↑43 The San Francisco Chronicle, 24 Nov 1890, P8
↑44 Peter Robinson in The Boston Globe, 25 July 1895, P8
↑45 The San Francisco Call, 26 December 1909
↑46 The Missoulian (Montana) ·20 Jan 1914, P2
↑47 The Havre Daily News (Montana) · 19 Apr 1917, P4
↑48 Austin American-Statesman (Texas) 24 Dec 1919, P8
↑49 Great Falls Tribune, (Montana) 3 May 1895, P4
↑50 San Francisco Chronicle, 23 May 1895,·P5
↑51 Chicago Tribune 29 Nov 1896, P37
↑52 The Oshkosh Northwestern (Wisconsin) 25 Aug 1906, P3
↑53 Signed photo dated 1911 from the Internet Archive and California Revealed
↑54 Star-Gazette (New York) 4 April 1917, P2
↑55 The film survives and a low definition copy can be see here, at the Silent Hall of Fame Channel on Youtube
↑56 St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 25 Aug 1896, P5
↑57 The Salt Lake Tribune, 7 May 1893, P7
↑58 The Buffalo Sunday Morning News, 23 Nov 1902, P6
↑59 Several years later, following the dissolution of their marriage, Odette was murdered apparently by one of her new husband’s trusted Prisoners. He was a Prison Warden
↑60 Star-Gazette (New York) 19 May 1913, P6
↑61 Star-Gazette (New York) 15 Aug 1905, P7
↑62 The Buffalo Enquirer (New York) 24 Apr 1908, P2
↑63 Star-Gazette (New York) 7 May 1921, P11
↑64 Star-Gazette (New York) 11 Aug 1922, P20
↑65 Star-Gazette (New York) 5 Aug 1922, P2
↑66 The Record (New Jersey), 2 June 1930, P2
↑67 New York, New York City Municipal Deaths, 1795-1949 database, via FamilySearch
↑68 Daily Independent Journal (CA) 11 Dec 1958, P8
↑69 Chapters 6-9, Peter Downes (2002)
↑70 by accident or act of self harm, it no longer seems clear
↑71 probably heart failure

Celebrity recipes from Australia

The sad looking roast Wallaby shown above, is recipe No 2858, from the Australian supplement in Mrs Beeton’s Book of Household Management, 1890 edition. Ward, Lock and Co. (For a similar unappetising recipe, see Parrot Pie, below)

The following recipes appeared in Australian publications between 1890 and 1976. I have come across these over the last few years of reading vintage Australian papers etc, and felt in the spirit of Christmas cheer, I should share them.

Nick Murphy, December 2023


Pacific Grill, 1976, Dame Edna Everage

Dame Edna in The Australia Women’s Weekly, 29 April 1981, P43

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
I know someone who made this. It was for a Australian house party to celebrate Charles and Diana’s wedding in July 1981. Of course it was really just another excuse to get stuck into internationally-acclaimed, award-winning Australian wine.

INGREDIENTS
6 lovely plump pork sausages; Dripping; 6 large mushrooms; 6 golden slices of freshly tinned pineapple; Tomatoes, halved; salt and pepper to taste

METHOD & RECIPE
Fry up saussies in a little fat until browned all over (turn well to avoid those horrid grey tummies). Removed from fat keeping them nice and hot somewhere. In the same dripping (already flecked with deliciously crisp sausage oozings) fry the pineapple rungs on both sides until cooked through and soggy. Drain on kitchen paper and keep hot while you sizzle up the peeled mushrooms and tomatoes, adding a dollop of extra fat if necessary, but be careful they do not break. Thrust each hot plump sausage cheekily through the hole in each pineapple slice and garnish with halved tomatoes seasoned with salt and pepper. A spicy tomato sauce is optional. [1]Source: Dame Edna Everage/Barry Humphries (1976) Dame Edna’s Coffee Table Book. P76. Australasian Publishing Company


Baked Meat Ring, 1956, anon

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
In my Australian childhood, the importance of eating copious amounts of meat was taken for granted.
But why you would go to the bother of doing this, I can’t imagine.

ORIGINAL COMMENT
Here’s a hearty main-course dish – and no one would dream it’s made from “left-over” meat… A savoury treat :

INGREDIENTS:

1lb minced left-over meat; 1/2 cup milk; 1 minced onion; 1 dessertspoon Bonox; 1 egg; 1 cup breadcrumbs; 2 tablespoons chopped parsley; 2 finely chopped mint leaves; 1/4 teaspoon salt; pepper.

METHOD & RECIPE
Combine all the ingredients and mix thoroughly. Grease a small ring mould or loaf tin and pack the mixture into it. Bake in a moderate oven (350° F) for one hour. Turn out and serve with tomato sauce, and vegetables in season.[2]The Australian Women’s Weekly 25 Jan 1956, P36


Rabbit in aspic, 1946, Gwenda Wilson

Gwenda Wilson c1945. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne Australia.

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
Long before she became famous on BBC radio’s The Archers, Gwenda Wilson was making this
dish for guests in Australia.

ORIGINAL COMMENT
With nightly performances, matinees, and rehearsals, the Don Sharp’s (Gwenda’s husband) naturally have little time for entertaining, but they love having people in for Sunday night supper. Here are some of the dishes Gwenda serves her guests on such occasions…

METHOD & RECIPE
One rabbit, cut up and cooked with enough water to cover. Add few bacon rashers and small chopped onion. Season to taste. When cooked remove all bones. Measure liquid and dissolve 1 dessertspoon gelatine, 1 cup liquid. Place hard-boiled eggs and green peas around inside mould, then arrange cooked rabbit and pour over liquid, and leave to set. Turn out and garnish with parsley or chopped mint.” [3]The Argus (Melb) 8 Jan 1946 P8


Recipe for hair dye, 1940, Nancye Stewart
[Do not eat this – it is a home-made hair dye]

Nanyce Stewart, c1930. Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne Australia.

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
This definitely belongs to the era when one made things rather than buying them, no matter how time consuming. Why a well known actor would spend time preparing this mixture rather than buying something off the shelf is unknown.

ORIGINAL COMMENT
Miss Nancye Stewart, well-known actress, tells how to darken grey hair with a simple home-made mixture. The Australian actress—whose artistry has won her many prominent theatrical roles gives the following advice on grey hair and how to darken it.

METHOD & RECIPE
FOR HAIR DYE
Anyone can prepare a simple mixture at home that will darken grey hair and make it soft and glossy. To a half-pint of water add one ounce of Bay Rum, a quarter ounce box of Orlex Compound, and 1 ounce Glycerine. These ingredients can be bought at any chemist’s at very little cost. Apply to the hair twice a week until the required shade is obtained. This should make a grey-haired person appear 10 to 20 years younger. It does not discolor the scalp, is not sticky or greasy, and does not rub off. [4]The Advertiser (Adel) 12 Sep 1940 P6


Eggs pickled in beetroot sauce, 1935, Elissa Landi

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
Another time consuming recipe – in this case for colouring hard boiled eggs, so they look a “gay shade of red.”
This is typical of celebrity recipes from Hollywood wheeled out by Australian papers at the time. Landi’s Hollywood career came to an end at about this time, after she refused a role.

ORIGINAL COMMENT
This is a dish particularly suitable for our climate. For the outdoor buffet luncheon, one of my pet recipes, says Elissa Landi, is for eggs pickled in beet juice.

METHOD & RECIPE
Boil about a dozen carefully scrubbed beets in a kettle of suited water. Pour off the liquid and cool. Have ready the desired number of cold hard-boiled eggs, and, after removing the shells, drop them in the cold beet water. Add a tablespoonful of vinegar several bay leaves, and some slices of onion. Let the eggs soak in this mixture, in the icebox, about 12 hours.

Then remove, allow to drain, and serve on crisp lettuce leaves. They should be a gay shade of red, and will taste as good as they look. [5]The Herald (Melb) 3 Oct 1935, P36


Fried Fish a la Russe, c 1931, Lupe Velez

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
Another recipe very much of its era – fried fish with a lot of cream, butter and fat.
Australian newspapers were likely given such tidbits on up and coming stars by US studios and Velez did not visit the country. Velez did work with Australian Leon Errol in the Mexican Spitfire series. The author finds it hard to believe she ate this very often, if at all.

ORIGINAL COMMENT
Lupe Velez, the fascinating talkie star, is an enthusiastic cook, and likes trying out new recipes. Here are some which she got from a celebrated New York chef. She made them for some of her friends, and she declares they were pronounced excellent. 

METHOD & RECIPE
Take two large slices of any large fish. Cut fillets, saving the skin and bones. Sprinkle fillets with pepper and salt, and pour over them one-third of a cup of white cooking wine.

Cover, and let stand thirty minutes. Drain and dip each piece separately in heavy cream, then in flour, and fry in deep fat.

Cook the skin and bones removed from fish with five slices of carrot, two slices of onion, a sprig of parsley, a bit of bay leaf, a few peppercorns, and two cups of cold water, until reduced to one cup of liquid.

Make a sauce of two tablespoons full of butter, three tablespoons full of flour, the fish stock, one-third of a cup of heavy cream, adding the yolks of two eggs, a dash of pepper and salt, and white wine to taste.

Arrange fish on a serving dish. Cover fish with a half-pound of sauteed mushrooms, and pour the sauce over it.[6]Table Talk (Melb) 9 Jul 1931 P32


The Candle Salad, c1930, Eileen Robinson

Eileen (Right) in her one film with Clara Kimball Young in 1920. Courtesy Margaret Leask

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
Eileen Robinson worked for several extended periods in the US. Unusual though it is, I tend to the view this recipe is real. The French dressing may have been a novelty in Australia at the time.

ORIGINAL COMMENT
From her extensive collection of recipes, gathered during world travels, Miss Eileen Robinson, of the Theatre Royal, supplies the following tasty dish, one which is exceedingly popular at luncheons in America. It is simple to prepare, and amply repays the trouble of making it.

METHOD & RECIPE
For each person allow a slice of pineapple and half a banana. Pare down the banana on the crooked side so that it will be straight and look like a candle. Set each section of banana into the hole in the pineapple, and place a maraschino cherry on top to represent the flame, pouring over a little paprika French dressing. Drain for a few moments, and then arrange individually on salad plates, with a garnish of lettuce.

To make the paprika French dressing take 6 tablespoons of pure olive oil, 2 tablespoons of vinegar or lemon juice, 1 teaspoonful of salt, ¼ teaspoonful of pepper, ½ teaspoonful of paprika. Pour the oil and vinegar (or lemon) into a bowl, add the dry ingredients, and beat with an egg beater until thoroughly mixed. Then serve as recommended.[7]Sunday Mail (Bris) 2 Feb 1930, P18


Parrot Pie, c1890, Mrs Beaton

AUTHOR’S COMMENT
The idea of eating Parakeets or Budgerigars in a pie stretches the imagination. They are quite small and mostly comprised of beak, feather and bone.
Still, the recipe was being prepared in England and possibly Mrs Beeton’s publishers were unclear about what a Parakeet was. (Mrs Beeton had died in 1865 but her publisher maintained the rights to use her name for many years)

INGREDIENTS
1 dozen paraqueets, a few slices of (underdone cold beef is best for this purpose), 4 rashers of bacon, 3 hard-boiled eggs, minced parsley and lemon peel, pepper and salt, stock, puff-paste.

RECIPE & METHOD
Line a pie dish with the beef cut into slices, over them place 6 of the paraqueets, dredge with flour, fill up the spaces with the egg cut in slices and scatter over the seasoning. Next put the bacon, cut in small strips, then 6 paraqueets and fill up with the beef, seasoning all well. Pour in stock or water to nearly fill the dish, cover with puff-paste and bake for one hour. Time- 1 hour. Sufficient for 5 or 6 persons. Seasonable at any time.[8]Mrs Beeton’s Book of Household Management, 1890. Ward, Lock and Co. P1259-1260

This site has been selected for preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 Source: Dame Edna Everage/Barry Humphries (1976) Dame Edna’s Coffee Table Book. P76. Australasian Publishing Company
↑2 The Australian Women’s Weekly 25 Jan 1956, P36
↑3 The Argus (Melb) 8 Jan 1946 P8
↑4 The Advertiser (Adel) 12 Sep 1940 P6
↑5 The Herald (Melb) 3 Oct 1935, P36
↑6 Table Talk (Melb) 9 Jul 1931 P32
↑7 Sunday Mail (Bris) 2 Feb 1930, P18
↑8 Mrs Beeton’s Book of Household Management, 1890. Ward, Lock and Co. P1259-1260

Eileen Robinson – Bright reports & close friends from the USA

Eileen Robinson by Hollywood photographer Max Munn Autrey, c1935. The ‘bright reports’ of Eileen’s early US successes came about courtesy of letters she sent home to her father in Sydney in 1921. Photo courtesy Margaret Leask.

The Five Second Version
The only daughter of Sydney publisher Herbert E.C. Robinson (1857-1933) and Augusta Dahlquist (1862-1914), Eileen was “a young actress with an exceptionally charming personality across the footlights” reported one newspaper after her first professional appearance in 1914.[1]Sunday Times (Sydney)19 Apr 1914 P22 Great success was predicted for her. In 1919 she went to the US, where her older brother Cecil Robinson (aka Ashley Cooper) and niece (Dulcie Cooper) had been performing for more than a decade. She again earned good reviews, but extended returns to visit and perform in Australia every few years meant it was difficult for her to build career momentum in the US.
Her close friend and professional collaborator for a decade, US actress Theresa Carmo,(1906-1990) worked with her in the US and joined her on two extended Australian trips – in 1929-1931 and 1935-1936. Their collaboration included scripting and performing original material for the stage and on radio.
In 1923 she bore a daughter, Peggy, to US actor Alan Brooks (Irving Hayward) (1888 – 1936), but their marriage was short- lived. She died in Sydney in 1955.

Eileen Robinson in an undated photo, most likely from her performances in John Ferguson in San Francisco in 1921. (Enlarged) Courtesy Margaret Leask

At the time of her travel overseas in 1919, Eileen Robinson was spoken of as one of the new generation of successful Australian actresses. She was a direct contemporary of Sylvia Breamer(1897-1943), Dorothy Cumming (1894-1983) and a friend of Judith Anderson(1897-1992), all of whom would make successful careers in the United States. As Andree Wright has noted, “At the time, [these film success] stories convinced readers that ‘with very few exceptions, every Australian who ha[d] ever gone to America ha[d] succeeded beyond expectations.“[2]Andrée Wright (1986) Pps18-19. The inserted quote is from Picture Show, 2 August 1919

Eileen, aged about 25, in 1921,[3]The Triad (Aust) 10 June 1921, P24. Photo has been filtered

Born Eola Eileen Trilby Robinson in Sydney in October 1896, to Herbert Robinson (or “HEC” as he was known – after his initials), a well known map maker and publisher, and his wife Augusta nee Dahlquist.[4]The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 30 Oct 1896, P1 Eileen’s schooling was at Astraea College in Chatswood.[5]Sydney Morning Herald, 26 Nov 1941, P9 While she was still young, her much older brother Cecil (born 1880) threw in his career as a draftsman in Sydney to pursue the stage. In 1905, Cecil [6]later using the name Herbert Robinson and then Ashley Cooper took his young family to the US, spending some years establishing himself.

While a career on the stage continued to be viewed with some suspicion in many Australian homes, it clearly had great credibility in this family. Both Augusta and HEC Robinson were friends of actress Nellie Stewart and Eileen became a good friend of Nellie’s daughter Nancye. Eileen was also known within the family as “Trilby,” a name found in the novel and play popular at the time of her birth.

Company letterhead for HEC Robinson Ltd, showing the address in central Sydney in the 1930s. Courtesy Margaret Leask

By 1912, Eileen was attending classes with well known actor Walter Bentley – later moving to Douglas Ancelon and Stella Chapman’s dramatic school. [7]Daily Telegraph (Syd) 28 March 1914, P14 As Desley Deacon has noted, in the early twentieth century, such acting and elocution schools served a much broader purpose than just knocking off vestiges of a colonial accent. It also taught girls marketable skills and instilled discipline.[8]See Deacon (2013)

In September 1919, Walter Bentley (1849-1927) reminded Sydney readers that Eileen had been one of his successful students, along with Sylvia Bremer and Dorothy Cumming. [9]Freeman’s Journal (Syd) 27 Sept 1919, P1

Eileen’s first professional outings were in productions at Sydney’s Little Theatre, in The Gay Lord Quex in April 1914, followed by a short season in George Bernard Shaw’s Fanny’s First Play. The latter was “her first important role, (where she) scored a decided success. She hit off the Cockney mannerisms very well indeed, and gave the character the required note of impudent familiarity.”[10]The Daily Telegraph (Syd), 12 May 1914, P14

Eileen in a Marie Tempest comedy, in Melbourne in November 1917. Cast members Gwen Burroughs and Nancye Stewart both tried their luck overseas.[11]State Library of Victoria

Eileen’s first contract with JC Williamson’s was for a 1916 revival of the very popular Get Rich Quick Wallingford, on £5 per week – a modest salary but still more than twice the Australian “minimum wage” of the time. [12]JC Williamson’s contracts, Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne By the end of World War 1, she had almost three years of strong stage experiences performing in Australia under her belt, including tours with visiting actors like Marie Tempest (1864-1942) and Margaret Wycherly (1881-1956). Like so many of her contemporaries at this time, Eileen embarked for the US in early 1919. She travelled with Nancye Stewart – the adventure being described as a “six month holiday.”[13]See The Daily News (WA)1 Mar 1919, P3

Like many young Australian actresses, 18 year old Eileen was paid to advertise cosmetics.[14]The Bulletin (Aust) 26 Nov 1914, P45

In later years there were oblique references to how hard it was to establish herself.[15]The Sun (Syd) 7 Aug 1921, P17 However, in early 1920 she was offered a small role on Broadway in Trimmed in Scarlet, with Maxine Elliott. The New York Tribune dismissed it as the “silliest play of the season”, which may explain its short run.[16]New York Tribune, 3 Feb 1920, P11 Enthusiastic Australian newspaper reports claimed she appeared in films for Famous Players–Lasky, a claim now difficult to verify, but she is known to have found a supporting role in Mid-Channel, a film with popular cinema actor Clara Kimball Young(1890-1960).[17]Sydney Mail, 4 Aug 1920, P13 By extraordinary chance, this film has survived.[18]It can be seen here

Clara Kimball Young and Eileen Robinson in Mid-Channel (1920) Eileen Robinson has marked herself “me!” under the photo. Most online sources incorrectly credit her as playing Mrs Pierpoint, rather than the daughter Ethel Pierpoint. Photo courtesy Margaret Leask.

There was a brief mention in one Australian magazine that although she enjoyed the novelty of “picture acting”, she preferred the legitimate stage.[19]Everyone’s.(Aust) 10 August 1921, P5 Her one outing in film was rarely mentioned again.

However, it was Eileen’s work in the the play John Ferguson, first at San Francisco’s Columbia Theatre in early 1921 and then on tour, that brought her greatest acknowledgement.[20]6 weeks of touring is mentioned in Variety, March 11, 1921, P28 An oft-cited review in the San Francisco Call reported “Eileen Robinson, young, beautiful, clever, plays the role of Hannah, daughter of John Ferguson. All eyes are turned on her the moment she enters the stage. Her voice contains that undefined something that attracts respectful attention. She is a most finished actress. In her principal scene her interpretation of her part is such that when the tenseness of the moment was over the audience broke into the most enthusiastic applause of the evening. Miss Robinson scored every moment during the rest of the play.”[21]San Francisco Call, 1 February 1921, P4

Eileen’s father passed this and similar wonderful reviews on to the Sydney papers. Also of interest to Australians was the fact that well-known Queensland actor, Tempe Pigott, was in the John Ferguson cast. Eileen wrote to her father that she was “having a glorious time” and was “enjoying herself immensely.”[22]The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 21 May 1921 P8 She ended her US experience with a series of performances at the Denham Theatre in Colorado. By August 1921, she was back in Sydney.

Almost immediately she went on stage with comedian Bert Gilbert, touring on the Tivoli circuit. At the same time she reassured journalists that she would soon return to the US. This seems to have been because, while in the US, she had met US writer and actor Alan Brooks (Irving Hayward) and the couple apparently sustained a long distance relationship for more than six months.[23]The Daily Mail (Qld) 4 Mar 1922, P11, mentions she will soon marry She departed Australia again, in April 1922, taking the SS Osterley, bound straight for Southampton, England, because Brooks was now presenting his own play Dollars and Sense throughout Britain. Eileen joined him onstage on tour, and the couple married in Paddington in January 1923.

By June 1923, she was back in Australia yet again, with Brooks, and despite being pregnant, she appeared with him on the Tivoli circuit for the opening weeks of an Australian season of Dollars and Sense. Newspapers reported he was “very proud” of his wife. Eileen was “splendid” he told Australians.[24]The Sun (Syd) 9 Jun 1923, P6 A daughter, Peggy, was born of the union in Sydney in July 1923. Several months later, they departed for the US- first Brooks, followed a few months later by Eileen and baby Peggy.

Eileen reappeared on the US stage in San Francisco in early 1926, in the comedy A Man’s Man. Sometime in 1926 or 1927 she met Theresa Carmo, an actress about ten years her junior, who was making a name for herself in ingenue roles. As subsequent events show, the two became trusted friends.

Eileen on stage with Lowell Sherman (1888-1934) in Los Angeles in 1928 [25]The Los Angeles Times, 15 Jul 1928, P44

In early 1929, Eileen and Theresa were on stage together in the comedy One Wild Night at Los Angeles’ Theater Mart, when they decided to pack up and move to Australia. We don’t know the context or exact reason for this dramatic move – perhaps Eileen wanted to see her father again, or perhaps they thought the depression would be easier to manage in Australia.[26]It wasn’t, although Carmo did tell one Australian paper that conditions were very bad in the US. See Truth (Bris), 12 Jan 1930 P25 Eileen’s marriage to Alan Brooks had come to an end by this time.[27]The Los Angeles Times 15 Jul 1928, P44 (See Note 1 below)

To the left of the ANZ Bank was the home of HEC Robinson Map publishers at 221 George Street, Sydney. The Robinson’s rooftop apartment can be made out. Eileen lived here with her father, daughter and Theresa Carmo in 1929-1931 [28]Daily Pictorial (Syd) 8 Feb 1931, P19 and again in 1935. Photograph dated 1963. Copyright City of Sydney, Archives & History Resources

Within a few weeks of arriving in Australia in August 1929, Eileen and Theresa were on stage at Sydney’s Tivoli, in a sketch they had written themselves, You’re Another. Eileen’s father escorted Nellie Stewart to watch the show from a box. Eileen announced that she was “tickled to bits! I’ve got lots of flowers and bottles of champagne… America is a dry country!” [29]This was a reference to Prohibition in the US. Daily Telegraph (Syd) 20 Aug 1929, P5 Eileen and Theresa’s US acting credentials meant that they were welcomed and feted by the city’s society and theatrical leaders. For radio, Theresa sang – occasionally in other languages, accompanying herself on the ukulele.[30]The Wireless Weekly, 27 Sept 1929, P54 For the press, Eileen provided recipes from the US and entertaining stories of Hollywood – including a lengthy description of Marion Davies’ 36 bedroom mansion.[31]Poverty Bay Herald (NZ) 12 Oct 1929, P12

Eileen, Theresa Carmo and a very young John Wood (1909-1965) with Yvonne “Fifi” Banvard in January 1930. Courtesy Margaret Leask.

By November 1929 they were appearing with Yvonne Banvard in her touring comedy company. However, by the end of 1930, their stage appearances had come to an end – presumably by choice rather than a lack of opportunity, as they were popular performers. In April 1931 they returned to the US. But this was not to be the end of their Australian connection – as in July 1935, Eileen and Theresa were back in Sydney again.

In the intervening four years, Eileen and Theresa ran an acting studio and children’s Little Theatre in Hollywood, providing elocution and preparing children for performance.[32]Sydney Morning Herald 14 Aug 1935, P7 and The Australian Women’s Weekly, 14 Sept, 1935, P25

The very simple program for Eileen and Theresa’s Theatre of Youth, Christmas 1932. Eileen’s daughter Peggy Brooks also featured.
Courtesy Margaret Leask.

They titled this “The Theatre of Youth.” Although details of the enterprise are sparse, Eileen’s family records confirm that the enterprising pair constructed their own little theatre, with seating for 70. “Three performances were given every month with different casts and programs.”[33]Margaret Leask (2023) In 1938, Eileen took some pride in telling Australians that Hollywood actress Lynn Bari had once been her student.[34]The Sydney Morning Herald, 22 Dec 1938, P21 Others may have included David Holt and Dorothy Gray.[35]Wireless Weekly, April 10, 1936, P21

Eileen and her long time collaborator Theresa Carmo c1935, taken by Max Munn Autry in Hollywood. Photo courtesy Margaret Leask.

When Eileen and Theresa arrived in Sydney again in July 1935, their focus was firmly on radio performance. Together they wrote and performed radio adaptions of popular stories and performed a stream of their own original material – whose titles hint at a range of content – The Lady’s Maid,[36]Australian Women’s Weekly 14 Sept 1935, P28 Therese and Me, the Fairy Clown [37]The Daily Telegraph 11 Feb 1936, P12 and College Daze [38]Sydney Mail, 11 Mar 1936, P34 all for Sydney radio station 2GB. It was a remarkable period of creative collaboration, but sadly only one of Eileen’s short skits has survived – a short solo piece probably designed for radio.

An undated skit by Eileen Robinson, c1935-6. Courtesy Margaret Leask. (Click to enlarge)

Eileen and Theresa’s collaborative radio work came to an end in 1936. Their final broadcast together seems to have been in early May 1936 and soon after this, Theresa went back to the California. In family correspondence there is evidence of a falling out between Theresa and Eileen, but why or over what is no longer known.[39]Personal communication, Margaret Leask to the author, December 2023

Flyer for Eileen’s Little Playhouse, established in Sydney in 1937. Courtesy Margaret Leask

After the death of her father, Eileen took an increasing role in company matters for HEC Robinson Ltd, but she still maintained an interest in the theatre. In 1937, she opened a Little Playhouse in the HEC Robinson Ltd building at 221 George Street Sydney. [40]The Sydney Morning Herald, 1 Apr 1937, P18 She had by this time, renovated her father’s old apartment on the top floor, and this became her home.[41]The Sydney Morning Herald 18 Jan 1936, P11

Judith Anderson (Centre) on a visit to the Robinson’s Sydney apartment in July 1944 with Eileen (Right) and daughter Peggy Brooks (Left). Courtesy Margaret Leask. [42]See The Australian Women’s Weekly 29 Jul 1944 P12

Unfortunately relationships within the family were unhappy in later years, and Eileen was estranged from her daughter at the time of her early death in January 1955. In the post war period she sometimes styled herself Eileen Robinson-Brooks, [43]The Sydney Morning Herald, 19 Dec 1950, P2 and was, more often than not, publicly associated with company business. The following photograph from 1945 concerned her plans to publish books about geography to ensure children enjoyed the subject at school. “Geography should be a wonderful adventure in a child’s education,” she said. [44]The Daily Telegraph(Syd)11 Jan 1945, P16

Eileen at HEC Robinson Ltd in 1945. Photograph courtesy Margaret Leask.

On her return to the US, Theresa Carmo went back to acting for the stage and radio. However, during the early 1940s she changed career and become membership secretary of the Press and Union League Club in San Francisco, a position she held for many years. Interestingly, she stayed connected to some of the Australians she had met through Eileen, even though the former partners were estranged. The 1940 US census shows her boarding with Tempe Pigott, the Queensland-born actor who was, by then 73 years old, but working on regardless.[45]Tempe told the census collector she was 56, and born in England. When Eileen died, it was mutual friend Judith Anderson who told Theresa. Theresa then set about rebuilding the connection with Eileen’s daughter Peggy and her family, later welcoming them on visits to the US and sending letters and presents. Eileen’s granddaughter Margaret Leask recalls her very fondly. Theresa died in California in 1990.[46]Personal communication, Margaret Leask to the author, December 2023


Note 1: Alan Brooks

Brooks appeared in several films in the late 1920s and early 1930s, but his reputation was also built on his work as a writer and vaudeville performer. He also appeared in a number of Broadway performances between 1909 and 1932 and he gained some notoriety when he appeared in Mae West’s scandalous production The Pleasure Man in New York in October 1928. It ran for two performances at the Biltmore Theatre before being shut down by Police, with West and the actors being dragged to court.[47]Times Union (New York) 2 Oct 1928, P1 The experience appears to have done his career little harm. Brooks died of tuberculosis at the National Vaudeville Association’s sanitorium at Saranac Lake, in September 1936, having spent several miserable years in “rest cure.”[48]Variety, 7 Oct 1936, P62

Note 2: Theresa Carmo

Theresa Carmo was born Theresa Maria Perry, probably in Oakland, California in October 1906, although some sources state the Azores, Portugal. She married in 1951 but her husband died in 1954. She had no children. Theresa is reported to have been in episodes of the Lux Radio Theatre in the late 1930s. [49]Including Confession, a 1938 episode – which can be heard at the Internet Archive, here


Nick Murphy
December 2023


References

Special Thanks

  • Margaret Leask, Eileen’s grand daughter. Margaret holds Eileen Robinson’s archive, which includes many of the photos used here. Sincere thanks for her willingness to share some of these, and the long conversation.
  • Claudia Funder at the Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne Australia.
  • Fellow researcher Jean Ritsema in the US

Theatre Heritage Australia

  • Margaret Leask, Paper presented 16 July 2023 for Theatre Heritage Australia. You Never Know Where Stories Will Take You.

New South Wales, Births Deaths & Marriages

  • Birth Certificate 1923 Peggy Hayward (Brooks)

HM Passport Office, General Register Office (UK)

  • Marriage certificate 1923 Hayward – Robinson

Clay Djubal and others: Australian Variety Theatre Archive

Films

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

Text

Primary Sources

  • City of Sydney, Archives & Resources
  • National Library of Australia, Trove
  • State Library of New South Wales
  • State Library of Victoria
  • National Library of New Zealand, Paperspast
  • Ancestry.com
  • Newspapers.com
  • Lantern Digital Media Library@ the Internet Archive
This site has been selected for archiving and preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 Sunday Times (Sydney)19 Apr 1914 P22
↑2 Andrée Wright (1986) Pps18-19. The inserted quote is from Picture Show, 2 August 1919
↑3 The Triad (Aust) 10 June 1921, P24. Photo has been filtered
↑4 The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 30 Oct 1896, P1
↑5 Sydney Morning Herald, 26 Nov 1941, P9
↑6 later using the name Herbert Robinson and then Ashley Cooper
↑7 Daily Telegraph (Syd) 28 March 1914, P14
↑8 See Deacon (2013)
↑9 Freeman’s Journal (Syd) 27 Sept 1919, P1
↑10 The Daily Telegraph (Syd), 12 May 1914, P14
↑11 State Library of Victoria
↑12 JC Williamson’s contracts, Australian Performing Arts Collection, Melbourne
↑13 See The Daily News (WA)1 Mar 1919, P3
↑14 The Bulletin (Aust) 26 Nov 1914, P45
↑15 The Sun (Syd) 7 Aug 1921, P17
↑16 New York Tribune, 3 Feb 1920, P11
↑17 Sydney Mail, 4 Aug 1920, P13
↑18 It can be seen here
↑19 Everyone’s.(Aust) 10 August 1921, P5
↑20 6 weeks of touring is mentioned in Variety, March 11, 1921, P28
↑21 San Francisco Call, 1 February 1921, P4
↑22 The Daily Telegraph (Syd) 21 May 1921 P8
↑23 The Daily Mail (Qld) 4 Mar 1922, P11, mentions she will soon marry
↑24 The Sun (Syd) 9 Jun 1923, P6
↑25 The Los Angeles Times, 15 Jul 1928, P44
↑26 It wasn’t, although Carmo did tell one Australian paper that conditions were very bad in the US. See Truth (Bris), 12 Jan 1930 P25
↑27 The Los Angeles Times 15 Jul 1928, P44
↑28 Daily Pictorial (Syd) 8 Feb 1931, P19
↑29 This was a reference to Prohibition in the US. Daily Telegraph (Syd) 20 Aug 1929, P5
↑30 The Wireless Weekly, 27 Sept 1929, P54
↑31 Poverty Bay Herald (NZ) 12 Oct 1929, P12
↑32 Sydney Morning Herald 14 Aug 1935, P7 and The Australian Women’s Weekly, 14 Sept, 1935, P25
↑33 Margaret Leask (2023)
↑34 The Sydney Morning Herald, 22 Dec 1938, P21
↑35 Wireless Weekly, April 10, 1936, P21
↑36 Australian Women’s Weekly 14 Sept 1935, P28
↑37 The Daily Telegraph 11 Feb 1936, P12
↑38 Sydney Mail, 11 Mar 1936, P34
↑39, ↑46 Personal communication, Margaret Leask to the author, December 2023
↑40 The Sydney Morning Herald, 1 Apr 1937, P18
↑41 The Sydney Morning Herald 18 Jan 1936, P11
↑42 See The Australian Women’s Weekly 29 Jul 1944 P12
↑43 The Sydney Morning Herald, 19 Dec 1950, P2
↑44 The Daily Telegraph(Syd)11 Jan 1945, P16
↑45 Tempe told the census collector she was 56, and born in England.
↑47 Times Union (New York) 2 Oct 1928, P1
↑48 Variety, 7 Oct 1936, P62
↑49 Including Confession, a 1938 episode – which can be heard at the Internet Archive, here

Isabel Mahon (1916-1993) – the “Mary Pickford” from Fitzroy

Above: 18 year old Isabel Mahon as she appears in Beaumont Smith’s final film Splendid Fellows, in 1934. This is a screen grab from the NFSA’s website Australian Screen, which contains several short clips from the film. (Click to follow the link).

The Five Second Version
Isabel Mahon (1916-1993) was not the only Australian actress to be dubbed “Australia’s Mary Pickford.” The term was regularly applied to other Australian women, including Josie Melville, Jean Duncan, Mary Maguire and Lucille Lisle. As an adult Isabel stood only about 1.5 metres (5 feet) tall,[1]She appears to have exaggerated her shortness but on stage was a vibrant and attractive performer. Born in inner city Fitzroy, she first appeared on stage at the very young age of about 8 years. By the early 1930s she had her first JC Williamson’s contract, and in 1934 she appeared in Beaumont Smith’s film Splendid Fellows. She married visiting vaudevillian Ward Gray in late 1936 and departed with him for the US to try her luck. She spent five years on the US stage, usually as a dancer. She returned to Australia with her second husband Earl Woodbury in April 1959, and spent three and a half years living there as an ordinary citizen. She died in Florida in 1993.
Isabel Woodbury nee Mahon on her Australian visa for a return visit home in April 1959. [2]Copyright National Archives of Australia – Isabel Irene Woodbury visa 1959

As historian Andrée Wright has noted, between the wars there came to be a popular narrative regarding Australia’s young actresses. These women were usually presented as sporty, good looking, capable, and more than competent on stage and screen – in fact – able to achieve anything – just by nature of being Australian. In the 1930s, newspapers delighted in listing their successes and made pious predictions about future successes overseas. “At the time, [these film success] stories convinced readers that ‘with very few exceptions, every Australian who ha[d] ever gone to America ha[d] succeeded beyond expectations.‘”[3]Andrée Wright (1986) Pps18-19. The inserted quote is from Picture Show, 2 August 1919 One such actress, briefly, was Isabel Mahon.

Isabel at the height of her Australian fame and now daubed “the Mary Pickford of the Australian stage” in 1934.[4]Sunday Times (WA) 22 Apr 1934 P11

Growing up in Fitzroy

Isabel Mahon was born in a small terrace house in Fitzroy, an inner suburb of Melbourne, in December 1916.[5]Victoria Birth Certificate, 29538/1916, Isabel Irene Mahon, born 6 December 1916 Her father Edward was former coal miner, listed in later records as a horse dealer or a labourer, her mother was Ethel nee Dennison, a Fitzroy girl who had experienced a severely disadvantaged upbringing in the suburb. Isabel was the youngest of a large family, and from a early age she showed talent and interest in performing. Like some other children of the working class inner city suburbs – notably those who joined the Pollards Lilliputian Opera company in the early 1900s – a life on stage was an exciting alternative to an apprenticeship or learning a trade.

The earliest public photo of Isabel appears in The Bulletin in 1931, while she was dancing in the panto The House that Jack Built.[6]The Bulletin 14 Jan 1931, P36,

For most of her childhood, Isabel[7]also spelled Isabelle and Isobel lived at Number 48 Little Gore Street, a laneway that appears to have originally serviced stables and provided rear access to the larger homes of Gore Street. At the time of her birth in 1916, Fitzroy, one of the city’s oldest suburbs, was developing a unenviable reputation as a “slum” suburb. Its narrow terrace housing and the proximity of factories made it undesirable to the city’s aspirational families. Accounts of working class suburbs increasingly emphasized the “rough and ready” life the citizens lived – and tended to amplify crime and coarseness. A Truth newspaper account from 1914 reported a case where Ethel Mahon had thrown a brick at a passing deliveryman whose horse and cart had just run over her cat in Little Gore St. The “lurid language” used at the time was alluded to, but the paper left spaces for titillated readers to imagine the words actually used in Fitzroy’s back streets.[8]Truth (Melb) 8 August 1914, P3

Left: 46 and 48 Little Gore Street Fitzroy, looking north towards Webb St. The dark terrace was Isabel’s home and is still a residence. The 1st floor walkways between warehouses are unusual and probably date from the 1920s, when Isabel’s mother had moved to Abbotsford. Right: Little Gore Street, looking south. Old stables and the end of the street are in the distance..

Isabel’s first professional appearances on stage, “as a clever child artist,” seems to have been when she was aged only 8, in February 1924, performing as part of a variety lineup called The Midnight Frolics.[9]Clay Djubal dates her earliest performance as the 1924 panto Cinderella

In early 1924, at age 8, Isabel was on stage in Melbourne.[10]The Prahran Telegraph (Vic) 22 Feb 1924, P3

Little actress lost

Over much of the next two years Isabel performed with O’Donnell and Ray’s Panto company on tour around Australia. We know this because, rather spectacularly, in late 1925, Ethel reported her daughter as missing to Police. After nine months away she had started to worry about Isabel but had been unable to contact the troupe – as they were moving rapidly from town to town and were often remote. Isabel and the company were finally found and in October 1926 she returned to her mother.[11]The Herald (Melb) 12 Oct 1926 P5 She had performed all over Australia, and in Java and Singapore.[12]Even today, tracking the company’s movements and performances is difficult

Report on Isabel in October 1926 [13]The Herald (Melb)12 Oct 1926 P5

Less than twenty years earlier, working class parents in this part of Melbourne had signed their children to perform on extended performance tours through Asia and North America with the Pollard Lilliputian Opera Company. They were away for up to two years. A few – Alf Goulding, Daphne Pollard, Snub Pollard and Ted McNamara, went on to make names for themselves. The parents contracted their children via a type of indenture and were paid through a trust. We must assume a similar scheme was applied to Isabel’s employment, although by the 1920s this arrangement was unusual. This is because the Victorian Education Act of 1872 required her to be at school, while the Australian Emigration Act of 1910 [14]written after the disastrous Pollards tour of India in 1909 prohibited any child being taken out of Australia to perform “theatrical, operatic or other work.”[15]How seriously these laws were applied is not clear. In 1985, performer Irene Goulding recalled her favourite teacher’s severe disapproval of her decision to leave on a performance tour with the … Continue reading

In spite of these laws, Isabel may have returned to touring,[16]the O’Donnell and Ray Panto Company still had a player called “Little Isobel” in 1927 – see for example a review of Babes in the Wood in the Maryborough Chronicle, Wide Bay … Continue reading however in the later 1920s, she also came under the tutelage of Melbourne’s well known dance teacher Jennie Brennan (1877-1964). Brennan had a close association with JC Williamson, the theatrical company so dominant in Australasia it was called “the firm.” It is not surprising that Isabel then appeared in a small role in When London Sleeps, at Melbourne’s King’s Theatre in August 1928.[17]The Herald (Melb) 13 Aug 1928, P19

A beaming Isabel in the pages of the national magazine The Australian Women’s Weekly, in 1934.[18]Australian Women’s Weekly, 4 Aug 1934, P20

Leading roles

Her big break-through came in January 1934, when JC Williamson’s promoted her to a leading role in Gay Divorce, after Dulcie Davenport(1913-2011) departed to pursue a career in England. Isabel was still 18 and her mother signed the JC Williamson’s contract.[19]She was still keen to exaggerate her youth – she told the Melbourne Herald she was 15. See 25 Jan 1934, P35 Immediately after that, she went into a run of The Girlfriend, followed by an Australian tour of Gay Divorce. Her contract still survives in the Australian Performing Arts Collection in Melbourne, and it reveals a continuous run of performances, back to back, in pantos and musicals for JC Williamson.[20]The contract file suggests a degree of tension over her employment and payments made And then came another exciting break-though – during the later part of 1934, pioneer director Beaumont Smith (1885-1950) cast her for his film Splendid Fellows (1934).

With her role in an Australian film confirmed, Isabel Mahon’s story of acting success was celebrated in the manner now so familiar in newspapers:
“Seventeen years old… Miss Mahon has won her name on the stage at such an early age. Small parts in J. C. Williamson have grown until she is now playing the lead in “Gay Divorce,” at Sydney Theatre Royal... Isabel Mahon was out to win through early. She appeared in pantomime at eight, and in nine juvenile years she has capped her kicking big boots in “Cinderella” by feminine leads on stage . . . and now on the screen. And so they come forward, confirming the opinion of London papers that there is plenty of acting ability in Australia.“[21]Author’s emphasis. Examiner (Tas) 10 Aug 1934, P9

Even more grandly, in one of many articles headlined “Australia’s Mary Pickford,” one Australian paper predicted “Isabel…. is made in Australia. Soon the world will know her.” [22]Author’s emphasis. Groper (WA) 5 May 1934, P1

Frank Leighton, Leo Franklyn and Isabel in Splendid Fellows.[23]Everyone’s 5 Sept 1934, P40.

Pike and Cooper [24]Pike and Cooper(1980) P223 note that Splendid Fellows was made on the very modest budget of £5000. It featured Eric Colman (the non-acting brother of Hollywood’s Ronald Colman) and included a cameo by aviator Charles Kingsford Smith. The theme of an air race made it topical, but ultimately the film was not a success and it was to be Smith’s last. NFSA curator Paul Byrnes has noted that Smith “had a tendency to require his actors to shout as if they were working to the back stalls of a noisy theatre. His staging was similarly minimal…” Clips from the film can be seen here at the NFSA site.

Beyond the excited puff-pieces about newcomer Isabel, at least one contemporary review acknowledged the problem with her voice, so obvious to the modern listener. “Isabelle Mahon, delightful in action, but —Good [heavens] —when she talks!  On the stage her voice may have quite a different timbre; but through recording and reproduction equipment it comes with the harsh metallic ring that characterised the speech of the Hollywood girls when talkies first arrived. The Americans overcame their troubles, and if Miss Mahon can do the same she should be able to pick up some nice money in productions of the near future.“[25]Everyone’s 21 Nov 1934, P29 Almost certainly, what we hear in the film was Isabel’s attempt to mitigate her working class accent and an education limited by touring from a young age.[26]Some Australian actors pursed elocution to make their voices acceptable for a stage or screen career

Isabel Mahon as Eileen McBride and Frank Bradley as her father Jim McBride in Splendid Fellows.[27]New Zealand Herald, 1 Dec 1934, P12

Off to the US with Ward Gray

Following what would be her one and only film and perhaps coinciding with disagreements with JC Williamson over pay, Isabel signed up to appear in variety on the Tivoli circuit. In their pantos – like Cinderella and revues such as Let’s Go Gay, Flying High and The Spice of Paris, she usually took featured or leading roles and was noted in reviews for singing sweetly and “dancing divinely.”[28]Table Talk (Melb)14 Nov 1935, P19 With exposure to the Tivoli’s numerous local and visiting artists, perhaps Isabel’s appetite for greener pastures had been whetted.

During her 1936 run at the Sydney Tivoli, Isabel met Canadian born vaudevillian Ward (Worden) Gray, one part of the visiting “comedy acrobatic dancing trio” Ward, Pinkie and Terry. The trio had arrived in July, performing for the Tivoli and then at breakneck speed through Australian venues. Despite a 12 year age difference, Isabel and Ward married in Sydney on November 3, 1936, and a week later they were on the SS Monterey, bound for San Francisco.[29]NSW Births Deaths & Marriages Marriage Certificate 17015/1936

Isabel and Ward in the lineup at the Tivoli in October 1936. [30]Sydney Morning Herald 15 Oct 1936, P2

Ward’s act performed on tour across the US in 1937, with Isabel being introduced to US audiences as an “Australian movie comedienne.” Australians who launched onto the variety circuits of the US found the work hard and the movement continual. Today, their professional footprints are faint and the advance publicity that found its way into the press rarely provided considered reviews and sometimes did not list performers.[31]See Leon Errol’s comments on being a touring player in vaudeville Troupes also continually broke up and regrouped – for example, after about 12 months, Ward and Isabel joined another touring troupe – the Kit Kat Club Revue, Isabel being billed as a “comedy dancer.” By late 1939 Ward and Isabel’s act had ended its run, and apparently, so had their marriage.

Isabel, made up in the best Hollywood style for the Kit Kat Club Revue in Birmingham, Alabama in March 1938.[32]The Birmingham Post 31 March 1938, P6

Touring and marriage to Earl Woodbury

Isabel’s movements from 1940 are even more difficult to verify. However, reports from later in her life state she headlined a Vaudeville road show called The Gems of 1941.[33]Pensacola News Journal (Florida) 7 Jan 1977, P35-6 The troupe included Earl ‘Woody’ Woodbury, one of the “Rhythm Ramblers”, a screwball comedy group of musicians in the style of the Ritz Brothers, whose act was dubbed “screwball swing.”[34]The Sunday Star News, Wilmington (NC) Oct 13, 1940, P15 Isabel married Earl while the troupe was in St Louis, Missouri in July 1941.

An advertisement for Gems of 1941. The author contends the photo shows Yvette Geray, who was likely Isabel. [35]Ledger-Star (Virginia) 9 Oct 1940, P12

Unfortunately, the surviving contemporary accounts of the troupe make no mention of an Isabel Mahon or Gray or Woodbury, suggesting she was probably using a stage name at the time. Yvette Geray, the troupe’s leading dancer noted for her “daring, alluring” performance, bears a similarity to Isabel in the few surviving, grainy photos.[36]Yvette Geray, supposedly from France, does not appear in records of US performances before or after The Gems of 1941, or any other records, which also suggests it was a stage name But equally, Isabel might have been one part of Rover & Mahan, a “diminutive pair of funsters,” who also had an act in the show.[37]Richmond Times-Dispatch (Virginia) 4 Oct 1940, P25

Whatever the exact nature of her performances, it had all come to an end by mid 1941, when war loomed for the US and Earl Woodbury joined the Navy.[38]Pensacola News Journal (Florida) 7 Jan 1977, P35-6

Post-war, the couple settled in Milton, Florida. However, for the three and a half years 1959-1962 they returned to Australia to live in Melbourne – making Isabel unusual amongst expat Australian performers of her era. In Australia, Earl worked for advertising agency Berry Curry.[39]Pensacola News Journal (Florida) 7 Apr 1963, P52

Isabel and Earl Woodbury on their Australian visas in April 1959. [40]Copyright National Archives of Australia – Isabel Irene & Earl Woodbury visa 1959

In late 1962, Isabel returned to Florida with Earl. Earl seems to have turned his hand to numerous jobs – in time he became a realtor and property developer. Isabel, or “Issie,” sometimes performed in local amateur theatre in Florida, but it seems her professional career had come to an end.

It is intriguing that although she saw her family in Australia, Isabel sought no publicity at all during her time in Melbourne, and Australians seemed unaware she was home. She had become a US citizen in the 1950s and lived in Florida until her death in 1993.


Nick Murphy
November 2023


References

Text

  • Andrew Pike & Ross Cooper (1980) Australian Film 1900-1977. Oxford University Press/AFI
  • Andrée Wright (1986) Brilliant Careers, Women in Australian Cinema. Pan Australia
  • Frank Van Straten (2003) Tivoli Thomas C Lothian

Australian Performing Arts Collection, Arts Centre, Melbourne

  • JC Williamson’s Collection – Contracts for Isabel Mahon

National Film and Sound Archive (NFSA)

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

Australian Variety Theatre Archive

State Library of Victoria, blog

Primary Sources

  • National Archives of Australia
  • National Library of Australia, Trove
  • National Library of New Zealand, Paperspast
  • State Library of Victoria
  • Ancestry.com
  • Victoria, Births Deaths & Marriages
  • New South Wales, Births Deaths & Marriages
  • Newspapers.com
  • Lantern Digital Media Library@ the Internet Archive
This site has been selected for archiving and preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 She appears to have exaggerated her shortness
↑2 Copyright National Archives of Australia – Isabel Irene Woodbury visa 1959
↑3 Andrée Wright (1986) Pps18-19. The inserted quote is from Picture Show, 2 August 1919
↑4 Sunday Times (WA) 22 Apr 1934 P11
↑5 Victoria Birth Certificate, 29538/1916, Isabel Irene Mahon, born 6 December 1916
↑6 The Bulletin 14 Jan 1931, P36,
↑7 also spelled Isabelle and Isobel
↑8 Truth (Melb) 8 August 1914, P3
↑9 Clay Djubal dates her earliest performance as the 1924 panto Cinderella
↑10 The Prahran Telegraph (Vic) 22 Feb 1924, P3
↑11 The Herald (Melb) 12 Oct 1926 P5
↑12 Even today, tracking the company’s movements and performances is difficult
↑13 The Herald (Melb)12 Oct 1926 P5
↑14 written after the disastrous Pollards tour of India in 1909
↑15 How seriously these laws were applied is not clear. In 1985, performer Irene Goulding recalled her favourite teacher’s severe disapproval of her decision to leave on a performance tour with the Pollards. Irene did it anyway
↑16 the O’Donnell and Ray Panto Company still had a player called “Little Isobel” in 1927 – see for example a review of Babes in the Wood in the Maryborough Chronicle, Wide Bay and Burnett Advertiser (Qld) 8 Apr 1927, P4
↑17 The Herald (Melb) 13 Aug 1928, P19
↑18 Australian Women’s Weekly, 4 Aug 1934, P20
↑19 She was still keen to exaggerate her youth – she told the Melbourne Herald she was 15. See 25 Jan 1934, P35
↑20 The contract file suggests a degree of tension over her employment and payments made
↑21 Author’s emphasis. Examiner (Tas) 10 Aug 1934, P9
↑22 Author’s emphasis. Groper (WA) 5 May 1934, P1
↑23 Everyone’s 5 Sept 1934, P40.
↑24 Pike and Cooper(1980) P223
↑25 Everyone’s 21 Nov 1934, P29
↑26 Some Australian actors pursed elocution to make their voices acceptable for a stage or screen career
↑27 New Zealand Herald, 1 Dec 1934, P12
↑28 Table Talk (Melb)14 Nov 1935, P19
↑29 NSW Births Deaths & Marriages Marriage Certificate 17015/1936
↑30 Sydney Morning Herald 15 Oct 1936, P2
↑31 See Leon Errol’s comments on being a touring player in vaudeville
↑32 The Birmingham Post 31 March 1938, P6
↑33, ↑38 Pensacola News Journal (Florida) 7 Jan 1977, P35-6
↑34 The Sunday Star News, Wilmington (NC) Oct 13, 1940, P15
↑35 Ledger-Star (Virginia) 9 Oct 1940, P12
↑36 Yvette Geray, supposedly from France, does not appear in records of US performances before or after The Gems of 1941, or any other records, which also suggests it was a stage name
↑37 Richmond Times-Dispatch (Virginia) 4 Oct 1940, P25
↑39 Pensacola News Journal (Florida) 7 Apr 1963, P52
↑40 Copyright National Archives of Australia – Isabel Irene & Earl Woodbury visa 1959

Adele Crane (1894 -1988), Jan Rubini & a career that went West

Above: Adele Crane photographed by William Frederick Hall, c1925. Collection of the Australian National Maritime Museum. [1]Although undated and not officially titled, the 2 photos in the ANNM collection match the known photos of Adele. The name Crane is also scratched into the image at the top *Went west is contemporary British and Australian slang for meeting with disaster.

The 5 second version
For about eight years Adele Crane enjoyed a highly successful career on stage in Australia. Born in Melbourne Australia in 1894, she studied music at the Melbourne Conservatorium before becoming a popular star on stage for JC Williamsons, the Australasian theatrical firm. At the height of this success, she married US based composer- conductor Jan Rubini in Melbourne in 1929, before heading to the US to pursue a career in film. Despite her good looks and beautiful voice, her achievements in the US during the next decade were very modest. Her efforts were overshadowed by Rubini’s regular court appearances in the 1930s, and finally their divorce in 1939. However, she lived in California for the rest of her life, and died at Palm Springs in 1988.
 Adele in Kid Boots in 1925. [2]Table Talk (Melb)16 Jul 1925 
 P30 Via National Library of Australia’s Trove


Born in Melbourne Australia in December 1894, Laura Adele Crane was the second child of Alfred Crane, the engraver at Gaunt & Co, a large Melbourne jeweller and instrument firm, and Florence nee Hawley.[3]Victoria, Birth Deaths & Marriages, Laura Adele Crane certificate 6305/1895 – birth 29 December 1894 Engraving a name or inscription on watches, bracelets and other gifts was very common practice at the end of the nineteenth century, and Alfred’s skills were apparently held in high regard. The family lived very comfortably in Melbourne’s eastern suburbs, with music and mixing in good society high on the family’s priorities, even after Albert’s sudden and early death in 1920. Adele and her younger sister Joan attended St Michael’s Grammar in St Kilda, Melbourne,[4]Daily Standard (Bris) 18 Jan 1928, P2, citing a radio 3LO interview. and were regular attendees at local society events – mayoral and charity balls – in the 1910s.[5]Punch (Melb), 12 Jun 1913, Page 26

Adele’s musical ability was recognised at a young age. She was performing at Ballarat’s South Street music competition as a soloist in her teens, and by the age of 19 was attending the Conservatorium of Music in East Melbourne (also known as the Melba Conservatorium).[6]The Argus (Melb) 11 Dec, 1920, P28 via National Library of Australia’s Trove. In early 1921 Table Talk predicted – “She has all the qualities that make success -voice, a good stage appearance, brains, and an alert intelligence coupled with perseverance.”[7]Table Talk (Melb) 24 Feb 1921, P27 via National Library of Australia’s Trove The Ausstage database lists her earliest performances for the JC Williamson organisation as being in the comic operas Dorothy, The Chocolate Soldier and The Mikado, all in 1922. Following this she appeared in musical comedies for “the firm” for eight years, touring Australia and New Zealand. Years later, Adele named George Tallis – the Melbourne director of the firm – as a particular mentor. Tallis had first seen her singing in the Conservatorium’s opera Figaro in 1920.

Despite her wonderful voice, in 1922 she was yet to develop her stagecraft and was still regarded as “an immature soprano“.[8]The Australasian (Melb) 15 April 1922, P35 Australian theatre entrepreneur “Ted” E.J. Tait even dismissed her as “Not a world-beater, very ordinary” at about this time.[9]Admittedly this was in a private letter to George Tallis. Cited in Tait (1971) P114 However, by 1928 she could describe with some pride the transition she had undertaken – explaining that she put in an immense effort to develop herself:

“I had to start from the bottom, and it was hard work, but eventually I proved myself and was promoted. Even then I think I was fortunate. My experience is not the general rule, but I find the added advantage of my voice… carried me through. To win through on the stage a girl must have the necessary temperament, she must be prepared to work hard [and] she must look after her appearance…”[10]Daily Standard (Bris) 18 Jan 1928, P2, citing a radio 3LO interview.

Her skills were undoubtedly sharpened by nine months work between August 1922 and May 1923, when she was part of a JC Williamson’s Gilbert & Sullivan’s Opera Company tour of India and the “Far East.” This company performed a repertoire of popular musical comedies, always a welcome diversion for the home-sick expats of colonial outposts.[11]The Sydney Morning Herald, 29 May 1923, P10 The only place the tour was not a success was Japan, where locals showed little interest in the English musical comedy tradition.[12]The Advertiser (Adel) 12 Jan 1926, P10

Adele Crane in The Student Prince in early 1928. [13]Table Talk (Melb) 16 February 1928, P1, via State Library of Victoria

By 1925, Melbourne’s Herald reported that she was now “possessor of a soprano voice of extreme purity” and “her future in musical comedy roles was assured.”[14]The Herald (Melb) 17 Jan 1925, P17 A year later, Adelaide’s News reviewed her performance in the musical So and So’s, and reported “Adele Crane is deservedly popular… she is distinctively pleasing to look upon, wears her charming frock with grace and sings with ease and expression.”[15]The News (Adel) 4 Jan 1926, P2

Her surviving JC Williamson’s contracts also provide ample evidence of her rising popularity, with a very steady stream of employment with the firm. Her starting salary had been £9 per week in 1923. By the time the lavish Broadway production Kid Boots was being staged in Australia for the first time in early 1925, she was 30 years old and a leading player, on £12 a week. But at least one source suggests she was earning £30 a week by 1929.[16]Truth (Sydney) 15 August, 1937, P18

Above: Another photo of Adele Crane, c1925, by William Frederick Hall, Collection of the Australian National Maritime Museum.

The Capitol advertising – including Jan and Adele, 1929. [17]Advocate (Melb)12 Dec 1929, P28. Enhanced with wordpress AI function

Sometime in early 1929, Swedish born, US based conductor-composer and Violinist Jan Rubini (1897-1988) arrived in Australia. He had been employed by Melbourne’s Capitol Theatre to lead their orchestra, for a fixed term. These were exciting times – the art deco theatre had been designed only a few years before by US architects Walter Burley and Marion Mahony Griffin and Rubini was a star import, helping to remind Australians of the big new cinema’s exotic Hollywood connections. At some stage in mid 1929, Jan Rubini met Adele Crane, and their engagement was announced in September. Newspapers indicated the couple would make their home in the US, and although Adele was cautious in her comments about the future, it was at this time enthusiastic Australian headlines stated that she would soon “make talkies” in the US. [18]The Herald (Melb) 21 Sep 1929, P4

In November 1929, the couple married at the Wesley Methodist church in Lonsdale St, Melbourne.[19]Victoria, Birth Deaths & Marriages, Laura Adele Crane and Jan Child Rubini, Marriage Certificate 12683 / 1929, 27 November 1929 Such was their combined fame that Police were on hand to manage the very large curious crowd who assembled outside the church, eager for a glimpse of the couple.[20]The Herald (Melb) 21 Sep 1929, P4

In the beginning, it was clearly a romantic relationship. In 1930, Jan Rubini dedicated an original piece of music to Adele Crane.[21]Everyone’s (Aust), Vol 11, No 522, 19 Feb 1930. Enhanced with wordpress AI function

Jan and Adele also began to work together. In December 1929, the Capitol Theatre presented On With the Show (1929), Vitaphone’s breakthrough colour feature length film. The program also featured Jan and Adele performing together, live onstage, before the feature film. At about the same time they also performed together on Australian radio station 3LO. (An example of Adele singing while Jan Rubini conducted can be heard here.) Adele’s final appearance at the Capitol was in a (live) stage performance entitled Hello Paris, which accompanied the RKO (film) musical comedy Rio Rita (1930). Adele’s career prospects attracted great public interest – it seemed she was another young Australian about to succeed in the US, and the marriage to a well known US-based musician from Hollywood added to the glamour.

Adele and Jan on their wedding day, with sister Joan (left) and Jan’s best man (right).[22]Table Talk (Melb), 5 Dec 1929 P7. Enhanced with wordpress AI function

In early April Adele and Jan boarded the SS Ventura bound for the US. They arrived in San Francisco on April 24, 1930.

The very popular Jan Rubini back in the US. Adele Crane is introduced in very small type at the bottom. Click image to enlarge. [23]Variety, June 25, 1930, via Lantern Digital Media History

Rubini was well known in the US and his 12 months away in Australia had done nothing to dent his popularity. Unfortunately, that popularity did not translate into a flood of new opportunities for Adele Crane. Possibly an incident in 1931 when she broke a shoulder badly in a horse riding accident delayed stage work.[24]Oakland Tribune (Oakland, CA) May 24, 1931, P1 In spite of the injury, she found a regular place singing for KMTR, the Los Angeles’ radio station, in that year. Newspaper programming shows this engagement continued until 1934. In 1932 she finally appeared on stage again – at San Francisco’s Geary Theatre – in the Viennese operetta Love Time. Variety complimented her performance but observed that “operetta won’t take in any big dough.“[25]Variety, May 31, 1932, P52 via Lantern Digital Media Indeed it didn’t. It closed after a month. Previously, in Australia, she had also indicated that she wanted to appear in films. In late 1932 she did gain a very small role in the Fox film Cavalcade – based on the Noël Coward play – a sentimental view of generational changes for an English family. Adele played Ada the music hall starlet, and appeared briefly alongside numerous Britons and a few Australians (as usual, the Australians mostly took on cockney roles) – including Billy Bevan, Tempe Pigott and Montague Shaw. Unfortunately, there were no other film offers.

Left: Jan and Adele demonstrate (with a knife) how they wish to cut alimony payments to his first wife in 1934.[26]The Los Angeles Times Nov 22, 1934 P20 and Right: Rubini’s daughter and first wife Diane Rubini argue for more support in 1937. [27]The Los Angeles Times Aug 14, 1937, P3

One of the reasons her star did not shine as brightly in the US as it once had in Australia must relate to Rubini’s temperament, and his tumultuous relationship and ongoing court battles with his first wife seems indicative of this. He had divorced his first wife Diana in 1928 and was estranged from their two children, but battles over the level of child support he was providing regularly popped up in newspapers – in November 1931,[28]The Los Angeles Times, 5 Nov 1931, P 21 August 1932,[29]The Los Angeles Times, Aug 3, 1932, P18 November 1934 [30]The Los Angeles Times, 22 Nov 1934, P20 March[31]The Los Angeles Times 4 Mar 1937, P32 and August 1937.[32]The Los Angeles Times, Aug 14, 1937, P3 In November 1938, arguments over child support even led to claims and counter-claims of assault.[33]The Los Angeles Times, 25 Nov 1938, P21

It got worse. In June 1937, after less than eight years of marriage, Jan filed for divorce from Adele. The grounds were silly, even for the era. He claimed Adele had kicked him, and had only married him “so she could come to America.” He added the slightly contradictory statement that “she loathed America and Americans, and spent all her time… in the company of Australian and English people.”[34]Oakland Post Enquirer, 22 June 1937, P2 and Long Beach Press Telegram 22 June 1937, P6

Adele responded with a counter-action and named actress Terry Walker as stealing her husband’s affections. Again, this matter dragged out in the courts and newspapers for six months – until suddenly a reconciliation was announced in March 1938. Adele said “The time we were apart opened our eyes to things we didn’t think about before.”[35]Portland Evening Express, 7 Mar 1938, P8 Quite possibly it was not a reconciliation, but a practical decision driven by a realisation that their financial affairs needed to be put in order first. Either way, following more court actions (brought by a aggrieved tenant in March 1938 and again by Diane Rubini in November 1938), in March 1939 Adele and Jan finally did divorce. [36]Jan was on his way to an Australia again at the time. He and Terry Walker married in 1940, but this third marriage also ended in an acrimonious divorce in 1955. See The Los Angeles Times, June 25, … Continue reading

An embarrassed Adele Crane hides her face under her hat, most likely at a court hearing after the charges of battery brought by Diane Rubini in Nov-Dec 1938. LA Times photo by Gordon Wallace, dated 12/13/38. Copyright holder – UCLA Charles E. Young Research Library Department of Special Collections (here)

Newspapers reported that a property settlement had already been reached out of court [37]Los Angeles Evening Citizen News 7 Mar 1939, P2 and as events would show, it left Adele well catered for financially, as she lived very comfortably in the US until her death.

Adele Crane made few appearances after 1934 and although it was claimed she did “radio work” during World War II, so far no records of this have been found. She returned to Australia for a visit in 1948, during which time she described Hollywood as “an incredible place.” She became a US citizen in 1940. By this time she had two homes, one in Beverley Hills and another at Malibu Beach, overlooking the Pacific Ocean, where she enjoyed what she called “a quiet life.”[38]Guardian (WA) 4 June 1948, P4

It is easy to blame Jan Rubini’s tempestuous relationships and emotionally charged court appearances for Adele Crane’s lack of career in the US. This was almost certainly a factor. However Adele’s speciality as a soprano and in musical comedy, her lack of experience in cinema and her age [39]she was in her mid-30s when she arrived in the US – probably also conspired to limit offers of work. She was after all, another Australian hopeful living in Hollywood during its golden age, when there were endless queues of young people eager for work.

Adele Crane (at right) celebrating her divorce in March 1939. [40]The Los Angeles Times 8 Mar 1939, P2

Adele Crane died at Palm Springs, California, in April 1988. By that time she had lived in the US for 58 years.


Nick Murphy
October 2023


References

Collections

Text

  • Viola Tait (1971) A family of Brothers. The Taits and JC Williamsons, a Theatre History. Heinemann, Melbourne

Web

Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University

Primary Sources

  • Australian Performing Arts Collection
  • National Library of New Zealand, Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa, Papers Past.
  • National Library of Australia, Trove
  • Newspapers.com
  • State Library of Victoria
  • State Library of New South Wales
  • Ancestry.com
  • Lantern Digital Media Library
  • State of Victoria, Births, Deaths & Marriages

This site has been selected for preservation in the National Library of Australia’s Pandora archive

Footnotes

Footnotes
↑1 Although undated and not officially titled, the 2 photos in the ANNM collection match the known photos of Adele. The name Crane is also scratched into the image at the top
↑2 Table Talk (Melb)16 Jul 1925 
 P30 Via National Library of Australia’s Trove
↑3 Victoria, Birth Deaths & Marriages, Laura Adele Crane certificate 6305/1895 – birth 29 December 1894
↑4, ↑10 Daily Standard (Bris) 18 Jan 1928, P2, citing a radio 3LO interview.
↑5 Punch (Melb), 12 Jun 1913, Page 26
↑6 The Argus (Melb) 11 Dec, 1920, P28 via National Library of Australia’s Trove
↑7 Table Talk (Melb) 24 Feb 1921, P27 via National Library of Australia’s Trove
↑8 The Australasian (Melb) 15 April 1922, P35
↑9 Admittedly this was in a private letter to George Tallis. Cited in Tait (1971) P114
↑11 The Sydney Morning Herald, 29 May 1923, P10
↑12 The Advertiser (Adel) 12 Jan 1926, P10
↑13 Table Talk (Melb) 16 February 1928, P1, via State Library of Victoria
↑14 The Herald (Melb) 17 Jan 1925, P17
↑15 The News (Adel) 4 Jan 1926, P2
↑16 Truth (Sydney) 15 August, 1937, P18
↑17 Advocate (Melb)12 Dec 1929, P28. Enhanced with wordpress AI function
↑18, ↑20 The Herald (Melb) 21 Sep 1929, P4
↑19 Victoria, Birth Deaths & Marriages, Laura Adele Crane and Jan Child Rubini, Marriage Certificate 12683 / 1929, 27 November 1929
↑21 Everyone’s (Aust), Vol 11, No 522, 19 Feb 1930. Enhanced with wordpress AI function
↑22 Table Talk (Melb), 5 Dec 1929 P7. Enhanced with wordpress AI function
↑23 Variety, June 25, 1930, via Lantern Digital Media History
↑24 Oakland Tribune (Oakland, CA) May 24, 1931, P1
↑25 Variety, May 31, 1932, P52 via Lantern Digital Media
↑26 The Los Angeles Times Nov 22, 1934 P20
↑27 The Los Angeles Times Aug 14, 1937, P3
↑28 The Los Angeles Times, 5 Nov 1931, P 21
↑29 The Los Angeles Times, Aug 3, 1932, P18
↑30 The Los Angeles Times, 22 Nov 1934, P20
↑31 The Los Angeles Times 4 Mar 1937, P32
↑32 The Los Angeles Times, Aug 14, 1937, P3
↑33 The Los Angeles Times, 25 Nov 1938, P21
↑34 Oakland Post Enquirer, 22 June 1937, P2 and Long Beach Press Telegram 22 June 1937, P6
↑35 Portland Evening Express, 7 Mar 1938, P8
↑36 Jan was on his way to an Australia again at the time. He and Terry Walker married in 1940, but this third marriage also ended in an acrimonious divorce in 1955. See The Los Angeles Times, June 25, 1955, P21
↑37 Los Angeles Evening Citizen News 7 Mar 1939, P2
↑38 Guardian (WA) 4 June 1948, P4
↑39 she was in her mid-30s when she arrived in the US
↑40 The Los Angeles Times 8 Mar 1939, P2